3 ms·
This memo is spot on, except for the optimism at the end. I think Nokia is toast. At the end of the day, you can't create a best-of-breed product out of nowher
by erikpukinskis 16y ago
This memo is spot on, except for the optimism at the end. I think Nokia is toast.
At the end of the day, you can't create a best-of-breed product out of nowhere. You need the core competencies to be already present in your company's DNA.
Palm came back out of nowhere and created in the Pre a phone with great usability fundamentals, and an incredibly innovative contact/data management layer. But that didn't come from nowhere.... those are exactly the things that the Palm Pilot excelled at.
Apple created a phone with incredible industrial design that pushed the boundaries of what was possible in a category of device. These things, also, have lots of precent at Apple, in the Macintosh, the iPod, OS X, and the iTunes music store.
Google, in Android, built a phone OS that has incredible integration with networked apps, and is built on a well run open source project. But before they started, they already had the best network app development teams in the world, and many world class open source developers and evangelists on staff.
What does Nokia have? I'm honestly not that familiar with their history, but they appear to have had (at one time) world class supply chain management and global distribution. And solidly built hardware? Is that it?
Honestly, I think Nokia had the right DNA to make a huge contribution to cell phones when they were a brand new, untested product with limited global reach. But now that those issues have been nailed, the distribution channels are in place, and everyone's phones, from Motorola's Android phones to LG's crappy feature phones are "good enough" for the people who buy them.
My guesses for the big future developments in phones are the web maturing as a development platform (Google seems positioned to ride that wave), powerful new software APIs (social, location, augmented reality, AI, etc), new media distribution models (Netflix, iTunes, Shopify, etc), and of course design-driven expansion of the user experience (Flipboard, FaceTime, Google Maps, etc).
I don't see product teams at Nokia who appear to be executing in any of these areas at the level that would be necessary to dominate in them. And they would need to dominate in two or three to stop hemorrhaging customers.
I think they're toast.
- wisty 16y agoNokia already produces some of the best phone hardware there is. If they got Android onto it, I'd upgrade in a heartbeat. They also know how to differentiate without creating fragmentation. Most Android products suffer because of fragmentation - different OS versions, different hardware, etc. Nokia should know to create a core platform or 2 (standard screen size, hopefully upgrade support), and then make money on marketing prettier models to the people who'll buy them. It's obvious that they need Android, maybe with some "value added" features tacked on (but not in a tacky way). OK, crappy feature phones may be "good enough", but mobile phones has always been something of a fashion business. Nokia is good at this game, they just got blindsided by the iPhone and Android.
- yason 16y agoNokia could create a fairly vanilla Android phone with Ubuntu style LTS (long-term support) for upcoming Android releases. Buying one of these Nokiandroids, you could be sure to be able to run Android 5.0 in 2014 before the support dies out. Nokia was synonymous with quality ten years ago and while nowadays anyone can order a truckload of tegra2's and whip up a new Android model out of them, the end-user quality sucks because your new phone will be outdated sooner than you can google the Android version roadmap page. Nokia could show that they deliver what people want and still ride a different wave than the Q1/2011 trendweasels.
- wisty 16y agoExactly. 10 years ago, anyone could make a dumbphone. They all just made phone calls, and sent texts, kept memos, and had some terrible Java game system. Nokia came to the top because they offered quality dumbphones, not because they offered a completely different experience. Now there's iPhones (which Nokia can't really do anything about), and Android phones (which Nokia can do better than anyone, if they really try), Windows Mobile (maybe) and burning platforms like Symbian (despite Qt rocking, or so I'm told).
- dfox 16y agoWell, Nokia is probably only GSM handset manufacturer who has their own baseband implementation. Modern S60 are smartphones that are implemented in same way as normal feature phones and thus incredibly energy-efficient (and relatively cheap). I think that this level of technical know-how can get them very far - even in today's market.
- hamidp 16y agoDefinitely. It's not like they're a huge company with significant market shares outside of the US, and they most definitely don't have tens of thousands of engineers with years of experience building phones. They should just go back to being a paper mill.