2 ms·
Monotonic version numbering is the way to go, and years are the most consistent and best understood mechanism for something with a release cadence such as WiFi
by echelon 7y ago
Monotonic version numbering is the way to go, and years are the most consistent and best understood mechanism for something with a release cadence such as WiFi or a language spec.
We should adopt this as an industry.
- Osiris 7y agoECMAScript does this (ECAMScript 2015, 2017, 2018, etc) and I also really like it.
- angrygoat 7y agoFortran has been doing it longer.. Fortran 66, 77, 90, 95, 2003, 2008, 2018. It really is a very helpful approach.
- jfoster 7y agoIt also gives an indication of whether two things were produced around the same time or not. (Eg. You'd know that Windows 2015 probably wouldn't support WiFi 2019 without support being added)
- echelon 7y agoNow that's just brilliant. It hasn't seen wide enough adoption for this to happen yet, but imagine all the USB standards and processors and whatnot did the same. That's just so simple it's genius. "That 2020 motherboard won't run USB 2025" We really need this. Please Intel, Broadcom, Nvidia, etc. folks reading this. Please.
- PaulHoule 7y agoThose firms don't have much control of the rate technology is adopted. Look at how slow USB-C has been to come on. Look at how 802.11ax has gone nowhere. Or how Intel has been dragging its feet with PCIe4.
- MereInterest 7y agoIt's also really nice for convincing people that things are out of date. It is a lot easier to defend targeting "ANSI C" than it is to defend targeting "C89", even though it shouldn't be.
- jedberg 7y agoExcept that your 2025 motherboard will run USB 2025, even though it’s the same as USB 2020. The marketing people just didn’t want to write USB 2020 on there. But since USB won’t actually Change until 2030 it doesn’t matter, right?
- agumonkey 7y agosomeone put a website to advocate something like this to replace semver, forgot the url though
- quadrifoliate 7y ago> someone put a website to advocate something like this to replace semver, forgot the url though It's probably CalVer: https://calver.org/ https://calver.org/ As other commenters have said though, manufacturers probably don't want consumers to have a good idea of just how obsolete their equipment is. The current a|c|b|g|n alphabet soup is working out just fine for selling lots of equipment. Also, there are likely to be actual manufacturing and engineering reasons why Wifi 2021 will only become widely available during 2024, and those are hard to get across to consumers too.
- ethbro 7y ago> Monotonic version numbering is the way to go, and years are the most consistent and best understood mechanism [...]. We should adopt this as an industry. Absolutely agreed. In the interest of efficiency, we should probably also truncate it to fewer digits. Perhaps 2. Since we're in the first quarter of a new century, this won't cause an issue for a long time.