7 ms·
Using market share along isn't a very good measure, because it hides that fact that they entire market is growing significantly, far outpacing the market share
by jedberg 7y ago
Using market share along isn't a very good measure, because it hides that fact that they entire market is growing significantly, far outpacing the market share loss.
It's not that Microsoft is stealing customers from Amazon. It's that both companies are brining in lots of new to the cloud customers, and Microsoft is just doing it faster.
But both businesses are growing at enviable rates.
- scarface74 7y agoAs a hypothetical CTO worried about the political consequences of failure when choosing a cloud provider, why would I choose GCP? If I choose AWS and things go wrong , I made the safe choice “and no one ever got fired for choosing AWS”. If I’m already running a MS shop, Azure is a safe political choice. Every time something goes wrong, even if it could have happen with any provider, you will always be questioned about why you chose GCP. Besides I’m sure that AWS and Azure are some where in the right top corner of Gartner’s magic quadrant.
- mlthoughts2018 7y agoTypically GCP is chosen for up front volume discounts and bundling deals with GSuite and other tools, even more so for companies that offer GSuite-as-service accounts within other products, like business tools or hosting platforms. The problem is Google can’t make up the market share from only pressuring “lackey” companies that it has leverage over to use their cloud, it has to have a big scale draw for otherwise unaffiliated customers, and to a lesser extent can’t sustain these initial volume & bundling discounts indefinitely.
- scarface74 7y agoUnfortunately, GSuite is both losing marketshare and not being adopted by larger companies.. http://www.cloudcomputing-news.net/news/2018/may/30/office-365-usage-goes-and-leaving-g-suite-behind-says-research/ http://www.cloudcomputing-news.net/news/2018/may/30/office-3... Also being the discount cloud provider is not an enviable position.
- doctor_eval 7y agoThat article is from May 2018. Much may have changed since then.
- scarface74 7y agoIn the last year and half?
- doctor_eval 7y agoSure. I don’t use google docs so I don’t know, have they fixed the ugly UI, have they had some big customer gains, has some new community adopted it? I think Google has done a huge push into education, that alone could reap significant gains in 18 months.
- JamesSwift 7y agoI can see an an argument that kubernetes workloads should be on GCP for the same reasons MS workloads should be on Azure.
- scarface74 7y agoThere is no special reason that MS workloads that should be on Azure. AWS is always bragging that they have twice as many Windows VMs as Azure. The only two features that I’m aware of on AWS that won’t work for Windows is lambda and Fargate. AWS SDKs, documentation and support for Windows/.Net Framework is excellent. I’m not making any technical arguments against Azure. I haven’t used it besides what is now “Azure Devops”. As far as Kubernetes. It’s inconsequential when a major corporation is considering which cloud provider to use. Most existing workloads on prem are not using k8s. That goes back to knowing how to meet the customers where they are and knowing how to do a “lift and shift” as phase 1.
- JamesSwift 7y agoI'm not saying they are technical arguments. I'm saying they are the same acceptable answers to "why did you choose (not AWS)". Because the platform I chose is also part of the foundation of the tech stack we run on.
- scarface74 7y agoKubernetes - which every cloud provider now offers as a managed service - might win you a few startups but won’t win you many major enterprise companies.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoYou'd probably be surprised. Kubernetes is a hot enough buzzword that even companies as bizarre as Chick-fil-A are getting on board, with a hilarious architecture. https://medium.com/@cfatechblog/bare-metal-k8s-clustering-at-chick-fil-a-scale-7b0607bd3541 https://medium.com/@cfatechblog/bare-metal-k8s-clustering-at... Edit: Way past the getting-on-board stage, apparently. It had slipped my mind that the article I linked is from 18 months ago and already described an extensive rollout.
- scarejunba 7y agoBecause as a CTO you usually answer to outcomes not defensibility. If you frequently make defensible decisions and they keep not panning out, your CEO will fire you.
- lostcolony 7y agoYes, but as a newly hired CTO, you want a win...and failing that, a loss you can defend to a non-technical CEO. "Industry leader" or "we already are in bed with them" is a reason the non-technical CEO can understand.
- scarejunba 7y agoDespite the downvotes I'm confident this is not a significant source of variation in market share.
- scarface74 7y agoThe saying that “no one ever got fired for buying IBM” didn’t come out of thin air back in the day. Few people get to be CTO without knowing the politics and perceptions involved with dealing with corporate America.
- notyourday 7y ago> If you frequently make defensible decisions and they keep not panning out, your CEO will fire you. That could be a case for startups but it is certainly not the case for established companies. The job of a CTO of an established company is not piloting a formula 1 car. Rather, it is to prevent reckless technical decisions from taking an ocean liner and smashing it into an iceberg.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fxtentacle 7y agoGoogle's Cloud TPU makes AI training like 10x cheaper than the cheapest GPU instances that AWS and Azure offer. Plus Cloud TPU is perfectly integrated into TensorFlow, due to both being Google products.
- sabalaba 7y agoIt’s not 10x more expensive. For example, Cloud TPU costs $12 for ImageNet training. AWS is $42. Lambda GPU Cloud is $19. You also need to take into account the cost of changing and tuning your code to run on a TPU. https://dawn.cs.stanford.edu/benchmark/#imagenet-train-cost https://dawn.cs.stanford.edu/benchmark/#imagenet-train-cost
- fxtentacle 7y agoIn my case it was 10x. We're training networks to estimate optical flow on Sintel and KITTI using TensorFlow. On GPU, we hit the 12GB limit which caused TensorFlow to log a message that convolution performance would be limited due to not having enough cache RAM. On TPU, we didn't hit the RAM limit. Oh and amazingly enough, I took the exact same Python file that I built on GPU on my workstation, ran it in Google Collab with a TPU connected, and I really only had to change the configuration to make it work. There was no need to change or tune anything. I was pleasantly surprised by how well that worked. And let me rant a bit longer, when we started this project I actually first tried to use AWS because our company already had billing set up with them. But AWS was using CUDA 10.0 for SageMaker, which has a known crash- and nan-inducing bug for 2D convolution. AWS support being non-existent as always, we couldn't make things work on AWS and then went bare metal for our GPU training with hetzner.com - which simultaneously also shaved like $30,000 monthly off our bill. AWS's EC2 GPU instances are really expensive when compared to a dedicated root server.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m not arguing either way. But that’s still not where the money or growth is. Cloud computing only makes up 5% of enterprise (big Fortune 500 companies) computer spend. MS recognized moving enterprises with boring workloads to Azure was where the money was along with hybrid computing. That’s how it was able to succeed so quickly. Besides,Microsoft has always been focused on the dark matter developers doing boring stuff. Their tooling is far better than Google’s and their IDEs that developers are already using integrate with their cloud offerings.
- jeffshek 7y agoGCP has a really strong ecosystem around AI. If you end up dealing with some type of ML problem with absurd memory requirements, TPUs can be useful there. A lot of recent Transformer architectures have these requirements. Also, a huge amount of cloud costs are based on egress, so having it on one cloud saves you resources.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y ago> having it on one cloud saves you resources. All the major cloud storage providers tout geo-replication so that if an earthquake or meteor takes out a datacenter there’s still other copies. But nothing can protect against an administrative SNAFU where you - or your cloud provider - and accidentally or intentionally deletes your account and everything’s gone in an instant (yes, there’s usually recourse and backups to recover from - but that’s hours or days of downtime). Sometimes it isn’t even the cloud provider’s fault: see Adobe’s blameshifting onto the US executive for their dropping all their Venezuelan customers. While Azure has the “Black Forest” unit which is legally - and technologically - firewalled off the main Azure cloud - and you can also license Azure Stack for running many (most?) of Azure’s platform on-prem or self-hosted, I haven’t seen similar offerings from AWS or Google.
- jeffshek 7y agoI’m biased toward my use case - but if I have to move a bunch of terabytes for a ML data pipeline - I arguably am having stuff on GCP. To your point though, yes there is business risk of having it on one cloud.
- mamon 7y agoGCP also considers it copyright infrigement if you use their AI services for something actually useful, like, for example, self-driving car software. So it is better to stay away from it, unless you only use it for fun.
- WalterBright 7y ago> It's not that Microsoft is stealing customers from Amazon. The trick is to buy both MSFT and AMZN, and relax!
- cjblomqvist 7y agoNote that MS might not do it faster in real numbers, just that percentage wise it's easier to grow when you're small. 15% of 20B is still a lot more than 30% of 2B (out whatever the real numbers are).