5 ms·
> That’s what’s corrosive about wealth inequality. It’s why the marginal tax rate declines at very high incomes. It’s not about doctors vs landscapers because d
by rayiner 7y ago
> That’s what’s corrosive about wealth inequality. It’s why the marginal tax rate declines at very high incomes. It’s not about doctors vs landscapers because doctors don’t have political power relating to wealth.
Tax rates decrease at the very top of the income spectrum because our tax codes make a deliberate choice to preferentially tax investments and capital gains.
You’re assuming that choice is the result of “corrosive” factors, namely the wealthy having more political power. But that’s a loaded assumption. Most economists agree that preferential tax rates on capital gains is better for the economy. That’s why almost every tax code in the developed world has that feature. I don’t think you can just assume the only reason for that is the super wealthy having disproportionate political power.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoAlready the Brookings Institution (center, center-left, center-right, depending whom you ask) disagrees: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-effect-lower-tax-rate-capital-gains https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-effect-lo...
- rayiner 7y agoBrookings tends to be mainstream American Democrat, which on tax issues is solidly to the left of the developed world consensus. (The US is the highest in the OECD for how much of tax revenue it derives from progressive taxes. Democrats are seriously proposing wealth taxes, which are unusual in Europe and were recently eliminated in France and Sweden.) Here is an interesting article on NPR on a politically diverse set of economists agreeing that corporate and income taxes should be eliminated: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-policies-economists-love-and-politicians-hate https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-....
- HarryHirsch 7y agoThat NPR article is a very strange collection. # 2: End the tax deduction companies get for providing health-care to employees. Right now, large employers receive a group discount from whatever insurance provider they choose. So to bring down healthcare costs in the US, which are 4 times that of the civilized world, this motley crew of economists suggests to eliminate the group discount. That'll work. # 3: Eliminate the corporate income tax. Yes, Joe Plumber's firm pays corporate tax in PA, but any multinational with a decent lawyer pays no tax anywhere. Incorporate in Bermuda, license the IP. In the interest of fairness one could abolish corporate tax, but one could also come down on tax oases. Why isn't that even suggested? # 4: Eliminate all income and payroll taxes We are supposed to have a consumption tax instead. The wealthier you are, the more likely are to invest. Less wealthy people do not have that luxury, what comes in goes out that month. It seems to be an attempt to shift the tax burden away form the politically connected class. It's not convincing at all, there's too many aspects missing from the discussion to be taken seriously.
- Consultant32452 7y agoFor all of these it's important to remember that the federal government doesn't have to charge taxes to anyone. It can just print more money to pay its bills, inflating the currency somewhat. All taxes therefore are social policy, without exception. So, as a social policy... when Joe Plumber is considering going out on his own, how much advantage do you want to give Mega-Plumber-Co against him? Right now Mega-Plumber-Co gets the advantages of cheaper health insurance, no corporate tax, and can easily amortize the cost of certification/licensing taxes. With regards to #4 specifically, consumption taxes are the most economically efficient. This is a social policy that encourages thrift, which is bad for mega-corps but good for the individual. If the regressive nature of consumption taxes concerns you, you can just partner them with a dividend check paid to all citizens.
- rayiner 7y ago> 2: End the tax deduction companies get for providing health-care to employees. Right now, large employers receive a group discount from whatever insurance provider they choose. So to bring down healthcare costs in the US, which are 4 times that of the civilized world, this motley crew of economists suggests to eliminate the group discount. That'll work. That’s not what they’re talking about. They’re talking about the fact that when your employer pays premiums for your health insurance, that a not considered taxable income. That is regressive (higher income people get more health insurance benefits). > Yes, Joe Plumber's firm pays corporate tax in PA, but any multinational with a decent lawyer pays no tax anywhere. Incorporate in Bermuda, license the IP. In the interest of fairness one could abolish corporate tax, but one could also come down on tax oases. Why isn't that even suggested? The idea of licensing IP from Bermuda captures the media’s imagination, so there is a lot of coverage of such efforts, but it actually doesn’t add up to much. Most companies simply can’t take advantage of such tricks because they don’t deal with intangible products. Wal-Mart’s effective tax rate is 25% for example. The average effective tax rate for the S&P 500 was about 18% in Q4 2018. That’s higher than the average effective corporate tax rates in say the Netherlands. Corporate tax avoidance just isn’t a very big deal. Estimates are that legal corporate tax avoidance costs $100-240 billion in revenue across the entire OECD: https://fortune.com/2019/10/16/corporate-taxes-unpaid-g20-summit https://fortune.com/2019/10/16/corporate-taxes-unpaid-g20-su.... That’s just 1.7% of the $15.6 trillion those countries raise in taxes each year. Why does so much media ink get spilled about such a small issue? > We are supposed to have a consumption tax instead. The wealthier you are, the more likely are to invest. Less wealthy people do not have that luxury, what comes in goes out that month. It seems to be an attempt to shift the tax burden away form the politically connected class. It’s an attempt to shift to consumption taxes, which economists broadly agree are the most efficient kind of taxes. Which circles back to my original point. You perceive the policy in terms of its effect on the “politically connected class.” But there is a rational, economic reason to favor such a tax regime even if the wealthy didn’t have greater political connections. The “political connections” reasoning doesn’t hold water to me. We’ve always had rich people. But over the last 50 years, pretty much every developed country has dramatically reduced corporate and investment taxes. Are the rich more politically connected than in 1970? I don’t see any reason to believe that’s true. What has changed over that period is economic theory on taxes. That seems to be the real cause.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> Tax rates decrease at the very top of the income spectrum because our tax codes make a deliberate choice to preferentially tax investments and capital gains. Why don't we make some more tax brackets up top and tax dividend + capital gain income more like income?
- rayiner 7y agoThree reasons. 1) Economists generally believe that it is inefficient to tax capital gains. (Dividend income is already mostly treated as ordinary income.) That is to say, raising the same amount of money through capital gains reduces economic activity more than doing so via say consumption taxes. 2) We are already on the high side of the OECD when you combine capital gains rates + corporate tax rates. (Corporate profits are taxed at both steps.) Here in Maryland, the combined state and federal capital gains rate is 28.25%, a hair below Sweden’s 30%. Sweden’s corporate tax rate is also about the same as the current post-Trump tax law. Personally, I’m uncomfortable being to the left of Sweden on anything. 3) As to adding more tax brackets, it just doesn’t raise enough money. Our tax brackets already go well into the top 1%. So you’re talking about targeting the top 0.1%. The total income of that group is about $1 trillion, or 10% of all income: https://inequality.org/facts/income-inequality https://inequality.org/facts/income-inequality. Even confiscatory taxes in that group aren’t going to raise very much money. According to 2014 data, those people paid an average of 27% in federal income taxes alone. (Excluding state income or other taxes). Doubling that, which would take their total taxes to levels far beyond what is typical in Western Europe, would raise maybe $250-300 billion. That’s assuming those people don’t head to Sweden to lower their taxes. At all levels, the United States spends $7 trillion+ annually. Another $250 billion is a drop in the bucket. It’s a fraction of the $3 trillion per year or so that Medicare for All will cost, for example.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoQuality post + discussion, thank you. Unbiased question: What’s your advice for the 50% of Americans who make less than $30k/yr? How are they supposed to afford health care + housing + transportation (let alone preparing for retirement)?
- elfexec 7y ago> Tax rates decrease at the very top of the income spectrum because our tax codes make a deliberate choice to preferentially tax investments and capital gains. Our tax codes were written by people working for the wealthy. Our tax codes make a deliberate choice for a reason. > That's why almost every tax code in the developed world has that feature. You mean the wealthy in the developed countries like preferential tax treatment? > I don’t think you can just assume the only reason for that is the super wealthy having disproportionate political power. They may not be the only reason, but they are the major reason. In a capitalistic society, political power is subservient to and works for those who have and control capital. The tax code didn't write itself. Who do you think the tax code was created by? Who do you think the tax code was created for? The janitors and street vendors?