5 ms·
This completely misses the political angle. Someone with 1 billion in liquid assets can affect the political landscape more than 1,000 people with 1,000,000$ i
by Retric 7y ago
This completely misses the political angle. Someone with 1 billion in liquid assets can affect the political landscape more than 1,000 people with 1,000,000$ in assets. Similarly to how someone making 50 million per year has more than 1000x the disposable income of someone making 50k/year.
That’s what’s corrosive about wealth inequality. It’s why the marginal tax rate declines at very high incomes. It’s not about doctors vs landscapers because doctors don’t have political power relating to wealth.
- war1025 7y ago> This completely misses the political angle. The political angle that your comment does play to is the reason why many people find the "income inequality" argument rings hollow. The piss-poor are too caught up trying to survive to have much of a political agenda. Often the people on the picket lines are in the income classes of the "doctors" in your example. Sure they don't have near the influence of a robber baron, but they're worlds ahead of a lowly immigrant landscaper.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y ago> The piss-poor are too caught up trying to survive to have much of a political agenda. With all due respect I don’t think this is true. Besides, as income level goes up, people are more likely to be a blue voter than a red voter[1], a fact people have a hard time believing. Arguably 2016 was the poor, lower middle class (one of the least represented demographics in America) rising up and rejecting globalism. They affected change, was it not the kind that you expected? After all, what class do people think the “deplorables” are? A bunch of rich dentists? 1. https://www.people-press.org/2016/09/13/2016-party-identification-detailed-tables/ https://www.people-press.org/2016/09/13/2016-party-identific...
- war1025 7y ago> as income level goes up, people are more likely to be a blue voter than a red voter That's precisely my point. Income inequality is a Democrat talking point.
- bronco21016 7y agoAre you mixing up red vs blue? I think most people tend to assume that as ones income increases they’re less in favor of a tax system that decreases income inequality.
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoWhat figures are you intending to quote from your link? I was surprised by your comment as I'd seen data showing that Obama Vs Romney had a clear trend of richer people voting Republican (the crossover point was around 70K). I knew educated people had swung towards Clinton and away from Trump, but I didn't think it was enough to change that overall result. Looking at your source, the family income section seems to agree with my assumptions. Am I missing something? Edit: I see there's a small blip in the detailed family income above 150,000 for combined dem/lean dem (though more identify as republican than democrat)
- war1025 7y agoI haven't looked into it enough to have any clear data, but I have always assumed that the distribution looks more like a layer cake than anything else. If you are X, then the people in the social groups immediately below and above you are assumed to be Y. Mainly because people compare themselves to the people directly adjacent to them. So if you are different enough to no longer be part of the "in group", then you are likely to be part of the "out group". Don't have any idea if there is truth to that or not.
- rascul 7y ago> as income level goes up, people are more likely to be a blue voter than a red voter Could you elaborate on this? I'm having trouble reaching the same conclusion from the link you provided.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoOf course he misses the political angle, if he discussed it, soon enough people would clamour for the revolution. There is William Hinton's book Fanshen, a personal account of the author of the Chinese revolution in a rural village. One of the early chapters describes the struggle for power, and how money is converted into power. It's recommended reading, you don't have to agree with his political opinion, but it does give the backstory.
- rayiner 7y ago> That’s what’s corrosive about wealth inequality. It’s why the marginal tax rate declines at very high incomes. It’s not about doctors vs landscapers because doctors don’t have political power relating to wealth. Tax rates decrease at the very top of the income spectrum because our tax codes make a deliberate choice to preferentially tax investments and capital gains. You’re assuming that choice is the result of “corrosive” factors, namely the wealthy having more political power. But that’s a loaded assumption. Most economists agree that preferential tax rates on capital gains is better for the economy. That’s why almost every tax code in the developed world has that feature. I don’t think you can just assume the only reason for that is the super wealthy having disproportionate political power.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoAlready the Brookings Institution (center, center-left, center-right, depending whom you ask) disagrees: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-effect-lower-tax-rate-capital-gains https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-effect-lo...
- rayiner 7y agoBrookings tends to be mainstream American Democrat, which on tax issues is solidly to the left of the developed world consensus. (The US is the highest in the OECD for how much of tax revenue it derives from progressive taxes. Democrats are seriously proposing wealth taxes, which are unusual in Europe and were recently eliminated in France and Sweden.) Here is an interesting article on NPR on a politically diverse set of economists agreeing that corporate and income taxes should be eliminated: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-policies-economists-love-and-politicians-hate https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/07/19/157047211/six-....
- HarryHirsch 7y agoThat NPR article is a very strange collection. # 2: End the tax deduction companies get for providing health-care to employees. Right now, large employers receive a group discount from whatever insurance provider they choose. So to bring down healthcare costs in the US, which are 4 times that of the civilized world, this motley crew of economists suggests to eliminate the group discount. That'll work. # 3: Eliminate the corporate income tax. Yes, Joe Plumber's firm pays corporate tax in PA, but any multinational with a decent lawyer pays no tax anywhere. Incorporate in Bermuda, license the IP. In the interest of fairness one could abolish corporate tax, but one could also come down on tax oases. Why isn't that even suggested? # 4: Eliminate all income and payroll taxes We are supposed to have a consumption tax instead. The wealthier you are, the more likely are to invest. Less wealthy people do not have that luxury, what comes in goes out that month. It seems to be an attempt to shift the tax burden away form the politically connected class. It's not convincing at all, there's too many aspects missing from the discussion to be taken seriously.
- zozbot234 7y agoThe article is definitely not "missing" the political angle; that part is addressed. The point is that it's indeed a question about politics, not economics. By advocating that people having 1 billion in assets should have some of their assets taxed away, you're essentially saying that our political processes are so screwy that on average, someone with say, 1 billion in assets can be expected to use the flaws of our political processes to inflict real, actual damages on the order of, say, $100M on third parties (compared to the most feasible alternative outcome) and that they should be paying restitution for those expected damages. While this may be in fact an appropriate description of a number of countries outside the highly-developed West, it definitely doesn't describe, say, Western Europe, or even the U.S.! Our current President is an exceptional case, he's nowhere close to the norm of all billionaires, and policy should not be set as if he was.
- delusional 7y agoWhy does a tax have to be proportional to "real, actual damages"?
- zozbot234 7y agoI'm not saying that all taxes have to be like this. There are other possible arguments for taxing assets, despite the fact that, prima facie, any tax on assets is double taxation and quite highly distortionary of the economy (far more than, e.g. taxes on pure rents, consumption taxes or taxes on labor income). But our existing taxes tend to account for these arguments reasonably well. So if you want to propose some extra tax on wealth, it had better be based on something tangible. And it just doesn't seem to me that this is true of what's being proposed wrt. the U.S.
- Retric 7y agoFirst, Art and collectibles are also given preferential tax treatment and have no kinds of double taxation. Anyway, unrealized capital gains are untaxed as they compound, which might be ok except inheritance and gifts under 10m for couples are also untaxed creating a giant loophole allowing for very low lifetime tax rates. It’s the same issues as companies keeping giant piles of cash offshore rather than issuing dividends. Tax loopholes create economic issues which a low AMT actually helps smooth out without creating excessive burdens. Another solution is to tax all capital gains and have an investment tax break of some kind, which allows earned income to be invested without excessive taxation relative to capital gains. PS: Couples being assumed as people have 2 parents.
- hash872 7y ago1. Changing how campaign contributions/PACs function seems like a more reasonable way to change this than simply pursing a quasi-communist means of dragging wealthy people down, in the hopes that with less money they'll have less influence over the political system. I'm kind of sympathetic to 'wealth taxes will give us more income for programs to better society', but when it turns out to outright retributive 'taking money away from some people is an aim in and of itself', I get pretty concerned. No societies that are explicitly & punitively about punishing the wealthy seem to function particularly well 2. If wealthy people like the Koch brothers are going to be taxed anyways, they may spend more of their wealth on campaign contributions simply because they'll lose the money either way. If it's 'use it or lose it', why not keep spending more on dark money PACs or whatever?
- larnmar 7y agoSo should we tax people based on their political power? A heavily-read blogger might have thousands of times more ability to affect the political landscape than an eccentric billionaire. If you were to do a scatter plot between wealth and ability to affect the political landscape I believe you’d find they were correlated but not that heavily; the things that give you political pull include charisma, eloquence, and gregariousness. If we are concerned with cancelling out the ability of the wealthy to influence politics should we not also be doing something about charismatic individuals?