3 ms·
It also feels like we've gone from a mode of thinking that computers should work for people to an era of people working for computers. One ubiquitous example i
by reaperducer 7y ago
It also feels like we've gone from a mode of thinking that computers should work for people to an era of people working for computers.
One ubiquitous example is when a web page asks for a phone number and it requires the input to be in a specific format. Considering how simple it is for a computer to strip out non-numeric information and reformat a string, this is mind-numbingly annoying to me.
- trevyn 7y agoYou would be amazed at what people mindlessly enter into fields if you don’t enforce thinking.
- frank2 7y agoThat fact nonwithstanding, users might be better served by having more "freedom of expression", e.g., by software that lets the user type any text into any field. Of course, if the user doesn't succeed in entering a phone number when asked for a phone number, the user will probably need to confront that fact eventually (or fail to achieve what he or she set out to achieve) but it doesn't have to be during the typing into the field. In fact, that is how web forms worked in the early and mid 1990s IIRC, and I have second-hand information that it was easy to get random users to interact productively with a web form during those years compared to how easy it was to get them to interact productively with other UIs, e.g., a form implemented in Windows 95.
- dgb23 7y agoWe don't do this kind of thing for very good reasons. The more rigid/precise but also guided the input, the less errors and misunderstandings can happen. The trade-off is very small and comes down to a very minor annoyance and in some cases there are only upsides because a more guided experience can be more convenient.