3 ms·
Most closed source licenses have restrictions, like "don't use this in a nuclear plant, or to control an airplane, ...". They have also restriction for countrie
by gus_massa 7y ago
Most closed source licenses have restrictions, like "don't use this in a nuclear plant, or to control an airplane, ...". They have also restriction for countries and/or organizations the government doesn't like. It's fine because they are closed source. They can add any restriction they like, for example "don't use this on Monday", except when the restriction affect a protected class or the equivalent concept in other countries, like race or religion, or when the restriction can cause a tweetstorm.
The problem is that these ethical licenses try to pass as open source licenses. For example the title in the page of the Hippocratic license is "An Ethical License for Open Source Projects". With these licenses the project is not "free software" or "open source software", it's just "source code available software".
- belorn 7y agoThe licenses clearly do not pass the free software definition or the open source definition, but I don't think that is what the author is arguing. Their point is that the license is not legal and enforceable.