4 ms·
The GPL is also an ethical license, and a lot of us buy into it. A lot of us might buy into some future, different license, and the resources for enforcement wi
by pessimizer 7y ago
The GPL is also an ethical license, and a lot of us buy into it. A lot of us might buy into some future, different license, and the resources for enforcement will come from the people who support it.
It's only the OSI license that's some kind of libertarian commons thing. The GPL comes with obligations, and people are free to avoid the GPL for that reason, or simply violate it and deal with any consequences of that. All of these arguments apply as much to the GPL as to hypothetical "don't eat meat" or "don't steal jokes" licenses.
- ThrowawayR2 7y ago> "The GPL comes with obligations" The GPL does not impose any obligations unless the user attempts to redistribute the work that is GPLed, which most users don't. The text even freely acknowledges that the user is not even required to accept the terms of the GPL ("5. You are not required to accept this License, since you have not signed it. ...")
- shadowgovt 7y agoAnd the Vaccine License does not impose any limitations unless users attempt to use the software without having vaccinations. I think the details of what limitations the licenses impose is splitting hairs; the point is they impose limitations.
- cycloptic 7y agoIt really is not. The only reason the GPL has any conditions at all is to preserve the original terms of the license past the first distribution. The conditions don't trigger on use of the software, they trigger upon copying. That is what is meant by "copyleft". Compare this to the vaccine license that apparently demands users purchase medical treatments (???) from an unrelated third party before they can even use the software at all.
- catalogia 7y ago> "OSI license" What is that even supposed to mean? There is no OSI-approved license that goes by that name, nor in fact any license at all with that name as far as I can find. Incidentally the GPL is an OSI-approved license.