3 ms·
This essay covers some interesting aesthetic trends, but its timeline and evidence are manipulated to fit the author’s argument. But rather than nitpick, I jus
by keiferski 7y ago
This essay covers some interesting aesthetic trends, but its timeline and evidence are manipulated to fit the author’s argument.
But rather than nitpick, I just wanted to say that I find the current “style maximalism” to be quite fascinating. That was always the promise of globalization to me: the juxtaposition and mixing of aesthetic and cultural traditions. Of course you will sometimes get Trump’s gaudy excess, but that’s more of a comment on his lack of taste than an argument against the baroque in itself.
Edit: For an everyday example of what I'm referring to: compare the original Blade Runner (1982) to the sequel (2017). The first film is far more baroque, dusty, maximalist, and messy - and it lends the film a real sense of atmosphere and authenticity. This scene is a good example [1]: it's raining, there are neon lights everywhere, the characters are speaking in a hodgepodge of numerous languages including Hungarian, Japanese, and German. Later in the movie, you have a variety of bizarre characters, androids, robot dolls, and city environments.
Then, compare a similar scene in the new film, 2049.[2] Its style and atmosphere are far more minimal, modernist, and simplified. It feels a little too sterile, too clean for a post-apocalyptic city with hundreds of millions of people. The rest of the film follows suit: the abandoned locations don't seem that abandoned and the characters are all pretty straightforward. It is nowhere near as strange of a film as the first one is.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcwOApqmJMQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcwOApqmJMQ
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opDlMeqRACI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opDlMeqRACI
- dmos62 7y agoI found the atmosphere in the new Blade Runner quite captivating. Post-apocalyptic is a bit of a harsh word. Apocalypse as a concept is human centric, and humanity survived; it's the surrounding ecosystems that collapsed. Humanity died in that it was redefined as independent of the planet. In 2049 the cities are somewhat sterile and you don't feel the masses of people living in it, but it's like that already today. In a city with 10+ million people you don't fall over each other when walking down the street. Usually the city is just big enough to compensate for high population. Sure you can have slums, but that wasn't explored in the movie, as far as I can remember. And this likeness to today's cities is what left the biggest impression with me. That you can have the planet dead in some meaningful way and have a lifestyle so much like ours now. It reminds me of fact that most of our current ways of living in a metropolis are alredy geared towards being independent of non-city eco-systems.
- justinmk 7y ago> In a city with 10+ million people you don't fall over each other when walking down the street. Usually the city is just big enough to compensate for high population. I guess you haven't visited Tokyo. The streets are teeming with (non-tourist) people.
- bobthepanda 7y agoIt’s crowded, but it’s still extremely orderly. When I visited it was remarkable how even a few blocks from a train station it felt small and cozy like a small suburban outpost.
- dmos62 7y agoI haven't. I recently visited Shenzhen which has a larger population. When I showed people photos they were surprised that it wasn't crowded.
- Taniwha 7y agoShenzhen is a modern city, it has big wide boulevards, wide sidewalks, which makes burying subways easy It does have smaller "cuns" sort of villages within the city, with narrow streets and more people, they seem to be knocking down the densest ones (and building upwards)