3 ms·
Note that the article uses "verbal memory and semantic fluency" as a proxy for general cognition, so readers will almost automatically score better than viewers
by tgv 7y ago
Note that the article uses "verbal memory and semantic fluency" as a proxy for general cognition, so readers will almost automatically score better than viewers. They also seem to have modeled all factors as linear, and "cannot rule out (...) the possibility of reverse causality".
So to answer your question: it depends on whether you consider all assumptions of the article relevant. One thing the article certainly doesn't contradict is the old adage "use it or lose it".
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoOr: it’s a physiology / social sciences paper, so probably nonsense / narrow in scope / “more research is needed”.
- jakobegger 7y agoYou could probably say the same thing about 90% of scientific papers. Almost all research is narrow in scope, and more research is always needed. And calling other research fields "nonsense" is also something that researchers from all fields do.
- naravara 7y agoReverse causality would be an interesting conclusion. Essentially asserting that articulate people with good memories are less likely to find TV appealing and would prefer to read or do something more interactive instead.
- jvagner 7y agoThere are probably a lot of reasons why people may watch a lot of TV, including depression or other forms of mental and emotional pain.