3 ms·
While the Wikipedia article says "no academic consensus has been reached" it seems pretty clear from the "possible causes" section that a bolide (meteor explodi
by crazygringo 7y ago
While the Wikipedia article says "no academic consensus has been reached" it seems pretty clear from the "possible causes" section that a bolide (meteor exploding in the air above) is the only explanation listed which seems to fit the facts.
I'm curious, therefore, why the lack of consensus? Is there any evidence inconsistent with the bolide hypothesis? Or is there just no positive proof whatsoever (e.g. some type of meteor residue or other) so it can never be conclusively demonstrated?
- appleflaxen 7y ago> The ground around the immediate vicinity of Wanggongchang Armory, the epicenter of the explosion, had sunken for over 2 zhangs (about 6.5 m or 21 feet), but there was a notable lack of fire damage it seems a bit improbable that a bolide would just so happen to hit the armory. Given that bolide events are rare to begin with, the low chance of hitting a military building is enough to make me skeptical. I have no idea what contemporary chemical explosives were extant, but if there were any plausible agent I would favor that instead.
- catalogia 7y ago> I have no idea what contemporary chemical explosives were extant Only black-powder. Nitroglycerin, the first practical explosive more powerful than black-powder, was invented two centuries later.
- MawKKe 7y ago> it seems a bit improbable that a bolide would just so happen to hit the armory. Given that bolide events are rare to begin with, the low chance of hitting a military building is enough to make me skeptical. Well, isn't the probability of hitting the armory identical to that of hitting anywhere else on the planet?
- colanderman 7y agoYes, but the probability of hitting a place that contains many other explosive agents which could cause the same effect is far far lower than hitting anywhere else on the planet.
- ajuc 7y agoYes, and there's a very big number of things in the "anything else" category, and only very few things in the "armory" category. On the other hand explosive materials accidents happen where big amounts of explosive materials are stored, and there's few places in the "anything else than armory" category so the event is more likely.
- nl 7y agoAn airborne explosion of the bolide (which is the most popular hypothesis) could easily cause a secondary explosion in armory.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rossdavidh 7y agoIf it were not for the astounding coincidence of it being a munitions factory, it looks to me like we would be assuming an impact. But, given the absence of any smoking gun (e.g. impact crater), and the abundance of gunpowder on the site, I'm not surprised that there is debate.
- aristophenes 7y agoExcept any sound before the initial explosion would be impossible. The meteor would be traveling faster than the speed of sound, the first thing felt or heard by anyone would be the light and heat of the explosion followed by the shockwave. When anything combustible is aerosolized and mixed with oxygen, it allows it to explode. This is how thermobaric explosives work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermobaric_weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermobaric_weapon see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_explosion Gunpowder doesn't need oxygen, but it burns instead of exploding. If there was an initial set of fires and smaller explosions that dispersed unburned gunpowder and wood/grain dust into the sky, once it was dispersed a flash could have spread through the dust cloud and created a huge explosion as described. This theory would explain both the initial disturbances and the huge explosion at the end, but I don't see it mentioned anywhere.
- nl 7y agoIf the meteor passed overhead and then exploded some distance away you'd get the sound before the shockwave. Perhaps the passby tore the roof off the armory and sucked black powder into the air, and then the impact shockwave caused a fuel/air-like explosion? Also note that the description is by survivors, so the sequence of sounds maybe different away from the impact.
- Accujack 7y ago> If there was an initial set of fires and smaller explosions that dispersed unburned gunpowder and wood/grain dust into the sky, once it was dispersed a flash could have spread through the dust cloud and created a huge explosion as described. That was my thought too, especially with the description of the initial rumbling noises. Gunpowder burning in a small space might well provide the energy needed to disperse something flammable in a cloud above the armory which could then be ignited at some interval after it was created, providing a fuel-air explosion above ground level which would explain the over pressure damage without burning, the shape of the mushroom cloud, and the magnitude of the explosion.