6 ms·
The Western Canon by Harold Bloom (2011)
- johnnylambada 7y agoI can't imagine anyone having read everything in this list. It would take more than a lifetime for me at my reading speed.
- zozbot234 7y agoI can't imagine anyone being anywhere close to an expert (meaning, highly familiar with the relevant scholarship) on more than a tiny fraction of this list - and do note that whole areas of world lit (East Asia, etc.) are entirely missing from the list, because they're so hard to even characterize in a useful way. Perhaps this is what illustrates the very real failure of this whole "canon" concept more than anything else could.
- keiferski 7y agoWell it is called “The Western Canon” and this is right at the top of the page: “I have included some Sanskrit works, scriptures and fundamental literary texts, because of their influence on the Western canon. The immense wealth of ancient Chinese literature is mostly a sphere apart from Western literary tradition and is rarely conveyed adequately in the translations available to us." If you’re looking for an Eastern-focused selection (although obviously from a Western perspective), I recommend these lists: https://www.sjc.edu/application/files/7315/7307/1179/Santa_Fe_Eastern_Classics_Reading_List.pdf https://www.sjc.edu/application/files/7315/7307/1179/Santa_F... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_Books_of_the_East https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_Books_of_the_East
- zozbot234 7y ago> ... because of their influence on the Western canon. The immense wealth of ancient Chinese literature is mostly a sphere apart ... That's quite debatable though, it seems clear to me that the West did pay quite a bit of attention to Chinese culture, starting in the 18th c. or so. The inadequacy of relying on translations may be closer to the mark, but then again that's just another way that this literature turns out to be especially challenging.
- RookyNumbas 7y agoBloom was famous for his reading speed and memory: 400 pages an hour for simpler material, and could recite most of Shakespeare's works word by word. For us mortals the canon is meant to take a lifetime to read.
- HNLurker2 7y agoThat's why we have Harvard classics so we can skip nonsense that gets irrelevant overtimes
- vo2maxer 7y agoHow does reading the classics shelter from engaging with ephemeral works?
- kerkeslager 7y agoYour reading speed would likely improve if you read that much. EDIT: I'm a bit amused by the downvotes here. I've posted plenty of controversial opinions on HN and rarely get this many downvotes. This one seems pretty non-controversial by comparison: is there really some disagreement that reading a lot will result in becoming a faster reader? I'm genuinely confused.
- vo2maxer 7y agoI am not sure either why you’re being downvoted on a non-controversial comment. I’m also honestly curious. Is your statement being conflated with ‘speed reading’? A quick search finds plenty of similar recommendations. From one of them: “The more you read, the more you will be better at it. The better you are at reading, the more you will increase your reading speed.” [1] [1] https://www.lifehack.org/articles/productivity/10-ways-increase-your-reading-speed.html https://www.lifehack.org/articles/productivity/10-ways-incre...
- zozbot234 7y agoFYI, the Guidelines of this site state that one should not complain about the voting on comments. It can change quite a bit over time, so early impressions are likely to be misleading.
- vo2maxer 7y agoI know the guidelines well, nevertheless, thank you. But I’m truly curious why such a straightforward comment by kerkeslager would get downvoted, it would honestly satisfy my intellectual curiosity. It also raises the issue with reading speed and its connotations. Examples: Is reading faster better? It depends on the material; Is speed reading as the extreme form of it of any value or just a gimmick? A gimmick of no value to me.
- caiocaiocaio 7y agoI just got a copy of The Western Canon by Bloom from the library, and I think it is the most ridiculous thing I've ever read in my life. He is a very convoluted writer that goes for as much high emotional impact as possible, because his theories are generally ridiculous and only make sense when you're lost in his fog of anger and disdain for everything. He also has a weird tendency of using "Western Civilization" and "America" as synonyms, even though most of his pet authors died before the US existed. It's like reading a book by a cartoon parody of an English professor, and it's hard to believe that he was even a real person. It all seems like an elaborate joke. If you want the actual story of the Western Canon - which includes things like Euclid, Fourier, Darwin, etc., not just the fiction that American English professors like - try "Great Books Of The Western World": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Books_of_the_Western_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Books_of_the_Western_Wor...
- qgjdvcggd 7y ago>He also has a weird tendency of using "Western Civilization" and "America" as synonyms This is definitely not unique to Harold Bloom.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- EdwardCoffin 7y agoFor what it's worth, he disavows this list, which was in the appendix of his book [1] Bloom: But can we make an agreement? Let’s forget that damned list. Interviewer: Ha. Do you mean the appendix in the back of the book that lists all the canonical works? Bloom: The list was not my idea. It was the idea of the publisher, the editor, and my agents. I fought it. I finally gave up. I hated it. I did it off the top of my head. I left out a lot of things that should be there and I probably put in a couple of things that I now would like to kick out. I kept it out of the Italian and the Swedish translations, but it’s in all the other translations—about 15 or 18 of them. I’m sick of the whole thing. All over the world, including here, people reviewed and attacked the list and didn’t read the book. So let’s agree right now, my dear. We will not mention the list. [1] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/4w4dk3/harold-bloom-431-v15n12 https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/4w4dk3/harold-bloom-431-v...
- keiferski 7y ago“Disavowed” is a misleading word to use. He had criticisms of his list, but what the quote doesn’t mention is that Bloom was involved in a decades-long battle on the value of the idea of a canon. I think he was just tired of talking about it with people that hadn’t read the book in the first place.
- EdwardCoffin 7y agoWell, disavowed was my word, not his, but I stand by it. It seems pretty clearly to be a disavowal to me.
- rayiner 7y agoRight, but you’re misreading the context in which he said it. He disavowed some of the specific choices, maybe the idea of comprehensively enumerating them in a list. But he didn’t disavow the concept of a western canon or even most of the specific books in the list. “I did it off the top of my head. I left out a lot of things that should be there and I probably put in a couple of things that I now would like to kick out.”
- ixtli 7y agoHe died recently and I found that the new york times did a pretty good job of not making him out to be some sort of god in his obit: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/14/books/harold-bloom-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/14/books/harold-bloom-dead.h...
- gshubert17 7y agoThe parent category from the original posting is a list of Great Books lists. http://sonic.net/~rteeter/greatbks.html http://sonic.net/~rteeter/greatbks.html I like Clifton Fadiman's _New Lifetime Reading Plan_. This has a larger number of selections, each with a shorter (two or three pages) context and review. Teeter's list from Fadiman is here: http://sonic.net/~rteeter/grtfad3.html http://sonic.net/~rteeter/grtfad3.html Fadiman's book: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/249186.The_New_Lifetime_Reading_Plan https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/249186.The_New_Lifetime_...
- moomin 7y agohttps://www.harpercollins.com/9780062867889/the-white-mans-guide-to-white-male-writers-of-the-western-canon/ https://www.harpercollins.com/9780062867889/the-white-mans-g...
- BossingAround 7y agoIf I'm overly simplistic, this seems to be 1/3 of an English degree. The remaining 2/3s being linguistics and history with cultural studies of the times. I'm still undecided how much I'd recommend someone else studying English (full time, as their only major). I enjoyed the studies though!
- barry-cotter 7y agoIn most of the English speaking world a degree in English would include no linguistics[1] and courses in historical literature would not be offered in the History department nor would the History department accept them for credit. Look at the Oxford curriculum. All literature. https://www.balliol.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate-admissions/english-reading-list https://www.balliol.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate-admiss... [1] Unless you think studying only English grammar, morphology, syntax etc. qualifies as studying linguistics, in which case you’re wrong. Linguistics is about the study of language, not the study of a language.
- senderista 7y agoI dunno, I was required to take an introductory linguistics course for my Spanish degree and I assume that applies to English as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BossingAround 7y ago> Unless you think studying only English grammar, morphology, syntax etc. qualifies as studying linguistics, in which case you’re wrong The idea that as soon as you're studying linguistics of a particular language, you're not studying linguistics at all seems deeply flawed. Does studying applied math not count at studying math? Or, is studying the physics of light in crystals not really studying physics? What I agree with is that if you decide to study linguistics, that doesn't mean you speak foreign languages (a common misunderstanding in largely monolingual countries, such as the USA). You study how the languages function, and how they are formed, linguistically speaking. But, studying linguistics of English surely counts as studying linguistics.
- ipnon 7y agoA similar category that has inspired my reading and language learning for about a decade now is Alexander Arguelles "Great Books" list [0]. Arguelles is a hyperpolyglot, he can read, speak and write dozens of languages. He advocates for polyliteracy, the concurrent study of languages and their associated literary canons. [0] http://foreignlanguageexpertise.com/great_books.html http://foreignlanguageexpertise.com/great_books.html
- keiferski 7y agoHis biography is really fascinating and inspiring too: http://foreignlanguageexpertise.com/about.html http://foreignlanguageexpertise.com/about.html
- ikeboy 7y agohttps://www.wsj.com/articles/SB963270836801555352 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB963270836801555352 http://archive.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2003/09/24/dumbing_down_american_readers/ http://archive.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/oped/... Basically a professional snob.
- mellosouls 7y agoIt's unwise to base your assessment of him on a single article. (Edit: I wrongly assumed the two links were to the same article, one archived). It's not unreasonable for a literary critic to view the bestowal of literary awards on commercial writers with distaste. Those writers have more fame and wealth than they will ever need; it's fair enough to query why acclaim, publicity and awards - that would benefit less populist authors far more - has been directed in this way.
- ikeboy 7y agoI had two links, from years apart, in which he denigrated two authors. He's making a different argument than you. He's not saying King shouldn't have gotten the prize because others would have deserved it more, he's saying he shouldn't have gotten it because he's trash.
- mellosouls 7y agoSorry - I saw the archive prefix, and assumed an alternative for the same article. Yes, in the article I read (the second), his tone is provocative at best, and reflects a personality defect at worst, but I think he is saying the same thing - the award was inappropriately awarded, and he has a point. I don't think your original assessment of him is fair.
- ikeboy 7y agoI'm sure he had other interesting qualities other than being a snob, and I'm not putting down his other contributions, not being familiar with them myself. But I don't think classifying him as a snob based on that sample is unfair. It's the difference between "I don't like this work" and "people who like this work are wrong".
- pram 7y agoThe idea of a canon might be controversial, but you really can’t go wrong with anything on the list. Although the lack of Marx is questionable considering his immense influence.
- camelNotation 7y agoMarx is absolutely canon, one of the most important writers in history. I'm not sure how anyone can claim to understand the western tradition without Marx.
- zozbot234 7y agoBloom cared about the canon for its aesthetic value, and was quite skeptical about the whole notion that literature (in a narrow sense) could be relevant to social change. From that POV, the absence of Marx (or for that matter, of many other non-fiction authors, who are included in other "great works" lists but missing here) might be quite understandable.
- goto11 7y agoIt doesn't have Darwin or Newton either. It is a list of literature, not overall influential works.
- shantly 7y agoHe omits a lot of philosophy, science, economics, and so on, that aren't directly relevant to the literary canon.
- claudiawerner 7y agoTrue, but he includes Nietzche - while Nietzche's literary status is beyond question, they are not so memarkable other than the fact that they were very influential. J.S. Mill's On Liberty is also included - not being particularly appraised for its literary status as much as its influence on all liberal thought. Marx was arguably a literary genius in the same way Nietzche was, and influential in the way J.S. Mill was. He should be on the list by both accounts of what the list should contain. Not to mention, Bloom includes many authors who count Marx among their primary influences, like Walter Benjamin, Brecht, Orwell, Levi-Strauss, Sartre, Camus, and Bataille.
- goto11 7y ago"English Canon" would be more precise. For example he specifically mentions the King James version of the Bible (rather than just "The Bible" in general). This translation had a large influence on the English language - just as say the translation by Martin Luther had on the German language. For the non-English works, it is clear he has selected the ones which are known and influential in the English-speaking world, not necessarily the ones which are most influential in their home country. Nothing wrong with that - he was en English professor after all - but calling it the Western Canon is a stretch.
- xixixao 7y agoDo you think the Martin Luther translation had a more significant impact on the Western Canon than the King James version? Also presumably the list’s biggest value is in allowing someone to go and read all these works to get a better understanding of the Canon. Would you suggest people read both versions? (presumably further translated to their own language) You do have a good point, but I think it’s more against the notion of the Canon than this list.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DubiousPusher 7y agoThe most important translation of the Bible for "Western" society is probably the Vulgate. The most important for English speaking society is probably the King James though the ubiquity of the NIV today may be giving it a run for its money. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulgate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulgate
- goto11 7y agoThe Martin Luther translation obviously had a more significant impact on western culture on the whole, but the King James translation had an important influence on the English language and therefore it is fair to include it in a canon over English literature.
- voidhorse 7y agoBloom is one of my least favorite literary critics. I find his writing to be snobbish, presumptuous, and self-assured. It makes for a quite frustrating read. There's plenty of writers in the field that manage to do just as much of an effective, if not better, job without constantly sounding self-righteous. James Wood, for example, is also a popular literary critic (his books likewise find their way beyond the academic gates) that makes for far more pleasant reading. To give an example: it's been some time since I've read it, but while I remember the general theory proposed in The Anxiety of Influence sounding reasonable enough, I found the overall tone of the work far too arrogant. I suppose it was somewhat of a polemic at the time, which maybe excuses the tone some, but still--I've never read Bloom and not felt that, had I met him in person, he'd annoy me to no end and he wouldn't be tons of fun to be around.
- blueboo 7y agoThe only thing worse than reading his writing was being his student. He was the ultimate bureaucratic academic, skimming off his students' research and undercutting their futures. Oh, and fucking them (or trying to), if they were pretty enough and female. His "literature of resentment" codifies the outgoing generations irritation at insufficient worship and gratitude. RIP, he won't be missed, and his ideas are sinking ever-further into irrelevance.
- svat 7y agohttp://scholars-stage.blogspot.com/2019/10/a-non-western-canon-what-would-list-of.html http://scholars-stage.blogspot.com/2019/10/a-non-western-can... -- A Non-Western Canon (along with some words on Harold Bloom)