5 ms·
I still fail to understand why 4 years in, people seem to be confused about the idea that definitions of words involve over the years and that the computer indu
by scarface74 7y ago
I still fail to understand why 4 years in, people seem to be confused about the idea that definitions of words involve over the years and that the computer industry has both been coining and adopting phrases.
But a quick Google search is all that it would take to “understand it”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serverless_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serverless_computing
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- corobo 7y agoI've found that "I don't even get what the word is supposed to mean" is someone's first experience with tech fear. In my experience (including my own personal anecdata) they tend to mean "I don't want to learn this new thing and because of that I'm worried I'll be left behind if everyone switches to this"
- scarface74 7y agoI also don’t get this. I’ve been programming either professionally or personally for 30+ years. But this isn’t a new phenomenon. Back in the early 90s you had an “Apple II Forever” movement with people still holding on to their 8 bit Apple //e’s while Apple and the rest of the world moved on.
- rumanator 7y ago> I've found that "I don't even get what the word is supposed to mean" is someone's first experience with tech fear. This is a gross misrepresentation of the actual problem affecting the "serverless" fad, which is the buzzword overload accompanied by a lack of objective definitions. Function-as-a-service (FaaS) is an objective, clear-cut concept, but "serverless computing" is supposed to be a more general term where FaaS is only a realization of the concept. Yet, by keeping the concept as a buzzword then the proponents actually avoid having to argue the merits and the advantages of this sort of architecture, thus contributing to the growing skepticism.
- corobo 7y agoFolks were saying the same about "the cloud" but we got used to that too.
- fulafel 7y agoYou get used to almost anything. "Cloud" has gotten even less specific technically as new marketing uses for it become established. What do bare metal private cloud and Google Docs have in common, anyone?
- abjKT26nO8 7y agoAs I wrote in another comment, there is a world of software outside of web development. And I'm not especially fearful of being left behind. I spend almost all my free time learning new things. But I wouldn't really jump at the opportunity of learning something that locks me into a single company's services. Learning the fundamentals of computers seems like a much better use of my time.
- scarface74 7y agoBecause after you have “learned the fundamentals” it takes a lot longer to “learn” how to write a function that takes in two parameters, zip it up with all of your dependencies and upload it....
- Rapzid 7y agoA lot of concepts that apply to serverless and other cloud computing services are applicable across providers as well. Even if the details are different. I would liken it to learning programming languages. Learning new languages isn't considered "locking you into a language". It's even widely considered beneficial because it makes learning more languages even easier and brings new perspectives to the table. Edit: An interesting example. Learning something enough to know when NOT to use it is gaining a valuable skill that's worth $$ to employers.
- abjKT26nO8 7y ago> I would liken it to learning programming languages. Learning new languages isn't considered "locking you into a language". It's even widely considered beneficial because it makes learning more languages even easier and brings new perspectives to the table. Partly true, if you don't plan on using the language. But this seems only true, because the majority of programming languages today are open source and portable across different platforms. On the other hand, some time ago C# implied .Net Framework and that would lock you into the Microsoft+Windows ecosystem. In the same way, using SQL that's understood only by PostgreSQL isn't going to be as much painful as using something specific to Oracle databases when the company behind it goes haywire as Oracle did with Java (if not for OpenJDK).
- vsareto 7y agoI can't wait until society swaps the meaning of left and right through memes
- cddotdotslash 7y agoNot a single post on Hacker News can use the term "serverless" without the exact same replies being posted every time. It's as if a certain portion of the HN crowd simply cannot fathom that a new term exists and is in use, and instead resort to the same, tired responses.
- bloopernova 7y agoI think some folks are afraid of losing their jobs, so they lash out with snark.
- scarface74 7y agoSomeone else said on HN, developers don’t just move to the cloud to avoid administering servers, we also want to avoid server administrators.
- xmly 7y agohahaha good point
- rumanator 7y ago> Not a single post on Hacker News can use the term "serverless" wits nhout the exact same replies being posted every time. As a serverless skeptic/critic, the buzzword bingo aspect of serverless computing is far from being the problem, and it's a gross missrepresentation of the problems posed by serverless computing. The main problem with server applications such as AWS lambda, along with lack of control, is how utterly expensive it becomes by enforcing a SaaS business model to simple function calls, and how convoluted and needlessly complex it becomes by having to resort to yet another premium service to simply manage workflows (see AWS step functions). Suggesting that any criticism of the serverless fad is just old grumpy incompetent developers that are too dumb to understand the future and are to scared of being out of a job is a disingenuous attack on anyone who has the audacity of not falling behind a fad.
- 7y ago
- abjKT26nO8 7y agoUnder this link I read: > Serverless computing is a cloud-computing execution model in which the cloud provider runs the server, and dynamically manages the allocation of machine resources. Pricing is based on the actual amount of resources consumed by an application, rather than on pre-purchased units of capacity. So I don't see too much of a difference from a VPS I pay for that will cost me more if I start using more network bandwidth. But then I hear that you don't have ssh access and that your architecture is built around one specific vendor, so now you can't move to a different provider. Sounds like hell to me.
- scarface74 7y agoIf I don’t have any messages in my queue/request to my API/messages in my stream, I am not paying for VMs or networking. If I have thousands of messages in my queue, enough runtimes are started to handle the messages with the throughput I configure. And as far as worrying about one vendor, the lock in boogeymen is vastly overrated. Once you have any type of scale, even if you are just using a bunch of VMs (and if you are you’re spending more money for a cloud provider than just using a colo without any of the benefits), once you have your data in the databases, network configurations, your security rules, your connection to the cloud provider with sitters Direct Connect, a site to site VPN, client to site VPNs for all of your developers, you’ve gone through security audits, etc. you’re for all intents and purposes locked in anyway where the pain of migration will be a multi month project with little to show for it. It’s like all of those bushy tailed architects who are going to use the repository pattern and not use any database specific SQl just in case one day the CTO decides to move away from their six figure a year Oracle installation to Mysql.