3 ms·
Lots of interesting precedent to come out of it as well. By putting code on Github, an American website, as a developer are you actually exporting it? Or are th
by ehnto 7y ago
Lots of interesting precedent to come out of it as well. By putting code on Github, an American website, as a developer are you actually exporting it? Or are the people cloning the repo reaching into America and extracting it?
If it is considered exporting, is github the exporter, or is the developer. Just like a company might produce a metal widget but another company procures and exports it, the original company that made the widget isn't the exporter.
- fyfy18 7y agoI would not be suprised if we get something along the lines of "Unfortunately, this repository is currently unavailable in your country" sometime soon. Many websites still completely block EU users post GDPR, e.g. Chicago Tribune.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kaybe 7y agoSo that would mean I, as a foreigner, will have to do a little work to import it instead. That won't stop a lot of technically literate people.
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoRemember how it was done the last time the idiotic US government did the same stunt with crypto.... Zimmerman (PGP) physically printed and bound books containing the full OCR-happy font of the source code. Evidently to the dinosaurs in Congress, a physical book is something COMPLETELY DIFFERENT than a file online.
- joana035 7y agous and non-us mirrors, bxa notices, oh my!
- ehnto 7y agoImagine a world where your project dependencies can be deprecated by import/export law.
- Mirioron 7y agoWhat's there to imagine? We already live in such a world.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoActually, when we buy lab equipment from the US we have to fill out paperwork saying that it will not be used to produce weapons, and that it will not be resold to "bad" countries. Probably there is some precedent by considering e.g. if Lockheed or FedEx is the exporting company if there have been cases where weapons got exported to unwanted actors. Probably github is like FedEx in these cases.