3 ms·
ETOPS seems to have done pretty well. As far as I know, no ETOPS-certified twinjets have been lost due to both engines failing. There are a couple cases of th
by jrockway 7y ago
ETOPS seems to have done pretty well. As far as I know, no ETOPS-certified twinjets have been lost due to both engines failing. There are a couple cases of the jet running out of fuel (the famous Gimli glider and Air Transat Flight 236), but that is going to be bad no matter how many engines you have. There are cases of airplanes flying into volcanic ash clouds and losing all engines; but more engines doesn't help you if the air around the plane kills engines. There are some poorly-engineered planes with 3 engines that have had a single-engine failure bring down the entire plane (United Airlines Flight 232).
ETOPS is not just some rubber stamp for a particular model of airplane that manufacturers self-certify (hello, 737 MAX debacle), but rather a process applied to (airframe, engine, airline). You have to service particular engines to particular standards to be allowed to fly ETOPS, and it depends on the airline. I could go to the store, buy a 777 and hire 4 ATPs and fly a 777... but I wouldn't be allowed to fly it ETOPS, for example.
All in all, the program seems massively successful to me. It saves fuel, which means cheaper flights and less CO2 being generated. That's a good thing. The main downside seems to be medical emergencies; I remember some stories about the aircraft that flew EWR-SIN... it has some special corpse compartments to stash away the inevitable deaths that occurred 9 hours away from an airport. (It had 4 engines, but engines don't perform heart surgery on passengers.)
The reality is that engines are pretty reliable. 2 is the right number.
- sajomojo 7y agoThanks for the thoughtful replies, all. I still don't buy the idea that this change was made with public safety as the top priority. I do get that it might be a reasonable trade off of safety/profits. I really do hope the ETOPS rule changes turn out to be a good choice over the long term.
- mulmen 7y agoETOPS is not new. The 767-200ER entered service in 1985. We live in the future you are alluding to. Your concerns have not been validated by reality.
- jrockway 7y agoThe safest way to avoid aviation incidents is to not have planes at all. From there, there is a continuum of how much risk you want to take on. If we add many safety bells and whistles to planes, it would mean nobody could afford flying. If people couldn't afford it, they'd use other transportation methods. Those methods might be more dangerous than flying. So it wouldn't actually increase the safety of travellers. Oceanliners and cars are far from 100% safe, for example.
- meristem 7y agoETOPS-like rules have been in use since late 70's. It is an evolving standard with different craft types being approved for different ETOPS. While some current frames are rated ETOPS 330 or 370, this type of operation began officially with planes allowed to do only 90-minute ETOPS. If flying commercial over oceans, it is either ETOPS, A380, or a current type of 747 (747-8).
- Piskvorrr 7y agoVolcanic ash is a completely different beast from normal ops: you could have four engines and it still wouldn't be enough, prompting what was perhaps the most British announcement in the history of aviation, as narrated here: https://everything2.com/title/The+most+engine+failures+in+one+flight https://everything2.com/title/The+most+engine+failures+in+on...