3 ms·
> Maybe it's just my millenial entitlement, but that strikes me as a bad strategy. I don't know if has anything to do with your "millenial" (seriously, you use
by jasonlotito 16y ago
> Maybe it's just my millenial entitlement, but that strikes me as a bad strategy.
I don't know if has anything to do with your "millenial" (seriously, you use this word to describe yourself?) entitlement, but it's not a bad strategy for both you or the company. You don't want to work for a company like that, and they don't want employees like you.
Extrapolate that into numerous other "First Day/First Week/First Month" tasks other companies use, and it serves it's purpose.
Do not for a moment confuse cleaning the bathroom as the strategy. It's not. The strategy is sound. Your comment, if anything, is proof of this. Which again, is a good thing. =)
- jarek 16y ago> seriously, you use this word to describe yourself? No. That was tongue in cheek. Does anyone refer to their entitlement seriously?
- jasonlotito 16y agoI was referring your use of the word 'millenial', not the entitlement part. As for anyone referring to their entitlement seriously: yes. I see it happen all the time. I guess, however, they just don't realize it's their 'entitlement' they are talking about.
- jarek 16y agoThe entire "maybe it's just my millenial entitlement" was tongue in cheek. I've never seen anyone seriously refer to their own entitlement using the word "entitlement" in a positive content.
- rimantas 16y agoStrategy is sound in what? In hiring people willing to clean bathrooms?
- jasonlotito 16y agoZappos employs the same strategy by offering up money for someone to leave. People who take the money aren't the type of person they want at Zappos. They won't fit in. The military does this as well. Basic training is more than just training. If you can't get through basic training, you aren't the type of person that will work out in the military. As for cleaning the bathroom: It's not cleaning the bathroom. It's shared ownership in the upkeep, presentation, and workings of the company. It's a small company, so everyone knows everyone I imagine. Someone not willing to clean the bathroom would probably not fit into the company. You seem stuck on the fact that it's cleaning a bathroom. What about committing code the first day you're on the job? Being forced to take ownership. What about being handed a computer and being told to put it together? Lots of companies have rituals their first day. Things the new guy does that essentially boils down to the final test to see if they'll belong. If they'll fit in. Don't make the assumption that the strategy is only cleaning a bathroom. Don't assume you have to clean a bathroom.
- jarek 16y ago> What about committing code the first day you're on the job? Wow, talk about another test that would be super successful. I'm not sure I want to work at any place where any first-dayer is made to break the build in the name of shared ownership by checking in code to a codebase he couldn't have possibly had enough time to understand to a necessary level. I suppose he will be fixing it later that evening, in the name of shared upkeep. Responsibility and desire to belong will naturally drive the new guy (it's not like it'd be a woman, is it?) to commit something small, simple, and in the big picture totally irrelevant. As with all of these tests, what you actually get is a token activity that will tell you nothing useful and that will fail to screen out anyone who doesn't want to be screened out, company fit or otherwise. The military is the only setting in which these tests will be useful, because there being masculine and doing whatever the boss says the company needs doing with no questions asked is the entirety of the job description.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> Wow, talk about another test that would be super successful. I'm not sure I want to work at any place where any first-dayer is made to break the build in the name of shared ownership by checking in code to a codebase he couldn't have possibly had enough time to understand to a necessary level. I suppose he will be fixing it later that evening, in the name of shared upkeep. You make an awful lot of wrong assumptions here. Who said anything about breaking a build? And while they may not be major projects, bug fixes go a long way. I can only say that if those things are the first things that came to your mind, I'd hate to work at the places you've worked out. > As with all of these tests, what you actually get is a token activity that will tell you nothing useful and that will fail to screen out anyone who doesn't want to be screened out, company fit or otherwise. We'll have to disagree then. Granted, with the vast number of successful companies employing these strategies, I feel I'm in good company.