4 ms·
> How long can legend persist, though? This isn't the right question. There's nothing stopping a legend from persisting indefinitely. But the information abou
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> How long can legend persist, though?
This isn't the right question. There's nothing stopping a legend from persisting indefinitely.
But the information about where a legend came from or how old it might be will become unrecoverable.
As a minor digression, consider the related question "how long can a word persist in a language?". We can trace languages back several thousand years. Many words don't go back that far. Many words do go back that far, but have changed significantly in form, meaning, or both. Some words have, by coincidence, been preserved almost exactly in both form and meaning -- in at least one descendant language. There's no reason not to expect the same pattern to hold at larger timescales... but we can't reconstruct ancestor languages at those larger timescales, so there's no way to evaluate the claim directly.
Back in the realm of legends, we know that the proto-Indo-Europeans had a legend of a warrior who kills his own son. The Irish reflex of this legend is the story of Cuchulainn, and the Greek reflex is the story of Hercules. These two stories have some suggestive similarities, but in isolation it is not obvious that they are the same story. In particular, the manner in which each kills his own son is totally different. We are nevertheless confident of the relationship between the legends because we can see the same legend occurring in other Indo-European traditions.
So in summary:
1. A cultural feature may persist for pretty much any length of time.
2. However, after a while it becomes impossible to determine how long the feature has been in place for.
3. And very old features are likely to have mutated in some ways; without points of comparison, it is not possible to tell which aspects of something are old and which are new.