4 ms·
Well, you brought it up... Anyway, I believe it is related to OP's question (and so are my other comments). If (s)he wants to see if astrology is a 'predictive
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
Well, you brought it up...
Anyway, I believe it is related to OP's question (and so are my other comments). If (s)he wants to see if astrology is a 'predictive science', make predictions, and analyse them to find and interpret any patterns (s)he has to give serious thoughts about what sort of predictions can be made and how (which I think is key since 'predictions' really are whatever the astrologer 'interprets'...), how to analyse the results and what significance any patterns might have.
As such (s)he cannot simply brush anything deemed 'inconvenient' under the carpet.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoGood point, but it is irrelevant to selecting the right tools to document, analyze, record and map. Astrology can say that your left eyelid will twitch on the seventh day of the waxing moon and it still is a data point.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoBut astrology has changed dramatically though, which I was trying to avoid getting into an argument about. I haven't studied or read up on it, but have read a lot of history, particularly of Medieval times and earlier. For hundreds of years it was inseparable from astronomy. Astronomers making predictions, astrologers identifying events in the year or night sky, diligently recording eclipses and comets. The terms were interchangeable. For centuries they were the same thing, thus there probably is valid science potentially in some of those writings, much as chemist and alchemist were at one time the same thing. Alchemists figured out many chemical reactions, or purified real drugs long before we separated them out into chemistry and mystical hogwash. Just as religion were once connected with scholarship and education (and astrology) too. So I suspect if there is any grain of predictive basis it would be astronomical or meteorological in nature rather than the vanishingly unlikely finding a life partner third week of next month or next Tuesday being particularly lucky. shrug
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt hasn't changed. Astrology uses actual astronomical observations and predictions about the movement of planets, which is scientific (astronomy), and uses them to make predictions about events on Earth, the behaviour of people, or whatnot, which isn't. That was the case then, it's still the case now. The difference is that we now know what is fact and what is fiction so that astrology is relegated to harmless issues... Astrology to decide medical treatments is no longer tolerated or legal, but to decide who to date still is.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoForget about whether you’d find a partner because of your sun sign..what about predicting eclipses or comets or drought or famine or war. That’s astrology too, yes?
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWell in old enough texts they might all be considered and described so. From our perspective, eclipses or comets -- astronomy, drought or famine -- meteorology or climatology, war -- fun one that could come into several, e.g. a climate change or drought could trigger a war with neighbours, perhaps to try and migrate. War is only one of those I think does fall under modern view of astrology as, like earthquakes, they can't be reliably predicted until inevitable. Comets like Halley's or solar eclipses can be predicted, with decent precision.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoPredicting eclipses and transit of comets has nothing to do with astrology. It's astronomy, which is an actual science.