2 ms·
> I'm surprised by how many people find the dark forest theory convincing Me too, and the evidence against is pretty much all of human history. Yes, there have
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
> I'm surprised by how many people find the dark forest theory convincing
Me too, and the evidence against is pretty much all of human history. Yes, there have been some genocides, but on the whole even though humans compete for resources we trade and work together more often than not. One might argue that humans have always been on roughly the same level technologically but that's a) wrong, and b) irrelevant to the philosophical concept that one should murder anything that competes with one's own genetic lineage [0].
[0] which, according to all known physics, is ultimately futile anyway since even the universe will eventually die.
- dragonwriter 7y agoHumans are all very close generic relatives, compared to humans vs. other terrestrial animals, and even humans and the most distantly related terrestrial life are close genetic relatives compared to humans vs. extraterrestrials. The idea that human-human interactions have anything to say about relations between species from different worlds without common origin based on relations between genetic lineages ignores the radically dissimilar situation with regard to genetic lineages. Now, I don't think genetic lineages should be the prime determinant of whether you should murder another life form, but if you are considering that question, you can't use interactions between close genetic relatives to explain what should occur between non-relatives.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoEven regarding different species, we haven't intentionally wiped out very many of them and even engage in conservation efforts. We quite literally devote resources we could use to less advanced beings. This is antithetical to the philosophy governing the Dark Forest. Now we could consider other earthly life to be a "close genetic relative" I suppose, but if we're capable of making that extension of our concept of self, then why not also extend it to other intelligent life?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoLike 'SkyMarshal, you too are forgetting the second axiom of Dark Forest theory - unexpected, rapid jumps in technological advancement. Us humans, we've eliminated or learned to protect most of the fauna that poses any danger to us. But if we would be realistically worried, that tomorrow the bears or wolves might start carrying firearms or beam weapons, we'd wipe them out to the last, out of justified sense of self-preservation.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoNo, I don't think we would, because we don't do that to humans and really what's the difference at the point that we have polar bears carrying Kalashnikovs? Intelligent beings can be reasoned with. More importantly I guess is this question: Why is our conception of "self" in the meaning of "self-preservation" exactly the size of our species for the purposes of Dark Forest? Why is it not narrower or broader? P.S.: I further disagree that your sense of self-preservation would be justification. We do not consider pre-emptive strikes to be justified for a reason.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> because we don't do that to humans Except when we do. See e.g. historical killing of enemies and their families, to preempt retaliation. > Intelligent beings can be reasoned with. Except when they can't. As the orthogonality thesis states, intelligence is orthogonal to values. You could imagine smart bears whose values and ways of thinking could be completely alien to us (though evolving in the same environment would probably make us and them more alike than us and aliens). There's a term for that coined by Orson Scott Card[0] - varelse. "They may or may not be sentient beings, but are so foreign that no meaningful communication is possible with the subject." Except perhaps math. Which, in this case, mostly means game theory. > Why is our conception of "self" in the meaning of "self-preservation" exactly the size of our species for the purposes of Dark Forest? Why is it not narrower or broader? I'd argue, because of the first axiom: inability to establish trust due to communication delays. The clustering of "sameness" is determined by the speed of light[1]. And in the case of armed bears, "sameness" would too be determined by inability to establish mutual trust, this time given by communication problems caused by differences of minds. > We do not consider pre-emptive strikes to be justified for a reason. Except when we do. -- [0] - https://enderverse.fandom.com/wiki/Hierarchy_of_Foreignness https://enderverse.fandom.com/wiki/Hierarchy_of_Foreignness [1] - if we kindly ignore the existence of whatever quantum shenanigan communications Sophons were using, as apparently the author did. IMO, Sophons ruin the self-consistency of the rules of book's universe.
- beat 7y agoMeasure not by how we treat other humans. Measure by how we treat animals who interfere with us or are perceived as a threat. Most of them are extinct.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoMost species that are extinct are not extinct because they pose a threat but rather by accident. Polar bears and gorillas are easily capable of killing humans and do, but we have conservation efforts to attempt to keep ourselves from accidentally driving them to extinction. Or look at the rat. A pest animal known to have been involved in spreading diseases that killed significant numbers of humans, yet we do not seek to eradicate the species as a whole. Even mosquitoes, whom we have a similar relationship with, are not the target of some massive effort to eradicate them from existence. Hell, even smallpox gets to continue to exist.
- beat 7y agoWe have conservation now, now that they're on the verge of extinction. For the cute species, anyway. Read the Lewis and Clark diaries sometime, see how many grizzly bears they encountered, and how much they feared grizzlys. Now look and see how many are left. That's what happens to species we consider a threat.