3 ms·
> How would that work in case of MMORPG with open world ? One clan would votekick competing clan? Any group votekick whoever they want? Checks and balances. It
by WorldMaker 7y ago
> How would that work in case of MMORPG with open world ? One clan would votekick competing clan? Any group votekick whoever they want?
Checks and balances. It's a political problem at that point. MUDs had sometimes very traditional political institutions for bans/player behavior issues, and the same can directly apply to MMOs: "councils of multiple clans", for instance. You can already think of most corporations running MMOs as "BFDLs" (benevolent dictators for life) and there's good reason to ask them to add juries/trials for a more open democratic process to bans, as one common political solution to dictatorship. The same obviously goes the other direction that if players want more involvement in bans/kicks, they need structures like juries/trials to keep things transparent and to bubble up such issues as appropriate.
You can't always solve political problems with technical solutions, but more importantly sometimes technical problems have good political solutions.
>> Provide the server software for players to host their own servers and provide their own solutions to these problems.
> Dosen't apply for most MMO games.
Arguably it should. At the very least for long term archival, MMO games should feel more pressure to provide server software access to players to host their own servers. There's also a lot of interesting history associated with MMOs that had open servers (many MUDs), or reverse engineered server shards (things like various Ultima Online player-created shards). Even if most players would prefer a "canon" experience in BFDL hosted shards, that isn't necessarily a strong reason to avoid offering players a choice to host their own servers. Arguably most good MMOs hosting your own server cluster is a great amount of effort and would be A) self-limiting (only certain groups of players would have the combo of resources/interests/skills), and B) at least somewhat useful to the game owner themselves as a form of CI/CD test (if other people can reproduce your Production environment you are more resilient against possible mistakes/failures in your Production environment).
- munk-a 7y agoMUDs, while wonderful, occasionally devolved into closed ecosystems where RP enforcement and opinions ended up creating a toxic community with the playerbase eventually shrinking to nothing. MUDs are amazing but I think they're a bad example to call on in this case.
- WorldMaker 7y agoI don't know, I feel like that only mirrors/emphasizes/complements my point: yes, political solutions are hard (we still refer to the USA as a political "experiment" 200+ years on, for some good reasons), but they are possible (versus trying to handle things entirely technically that are by their own nature political; as other arguments in this thread and elsewhere point out, dealing with bad actors that are people will almost always be at least somewhat political). Political solutions can clearly fail, and that becomes another reason to allow players to run their own servers as it is an "out" in the case of a political solution failing (a different sort of resiliency to the technical sort). MUDs also have tales of successes. Times when political alliances defeated griefers and the community was stronger for it. Partly because of the relative ease of spinning up MUDs there are so many stories and experiments out there to choose from / learn from. MUDs were an early laboratory for what became MMOs in so many ways, and it will always be easier to reproduce studies done in that sort of a laboratory setting, including the failures. In science often the failures are the greatest learning experiences leading to the most interesting hypotheses.