4 ms·
FedEx, UPS, Amazon, and private couriers are all active in the letter and package delivery business. The USPS doesn't have a monopoly, at least not in the stri
by alistairSH 7y ago
FedEx, UPS, Amazon, and private couriers are all active in the letter and package delivery business. The USPS doesn't have a monopoly, at least not in the strict text-book sense of the word.
USPS just delivers letter mail at much lower rates than the others. And does so at a fixed rate to any address within the US, whether that's a neighbor across the street or a family member in a tiny town in the mountains.
- elicash 7y agoI'm very pro-USPS and anti-privatization, but in fairness, sole use of even private mailboxes is monopolistic. https://about.usps.com/universal-postal-service/ilo-report.pdf https://about.usps.com/universal-postal-service/ilo-report.p... (PDF)
- alistairSH 7y agoFair enough, though I'm not convinced that's much of an advantage. Personally, most of the mail I receive from USPS is garbage. And my mailbox is located at the end of the block, clustered for the whole neighborhood. Due to both those facts, I rarely check the mail - it's often overflowing by the time I bother. The mail I receive at my door (non-USPS) is 99% not junk. I don't have to go out of my way to retrieve it. And it's more likely to be dry (because the screen door never gets overfull of mail like the postbox). Just an anecdote, not meant as anything more.
- elicash 7y ago> I'm not convinced that's much of an advantage. Their competitors certainly claim it gives the USPS a significant advantage, if you check the info I provided. They also give reasons for their view. Are there any particular reasons you think they're wrong?
- alistairSH 7y agoJust my personal experience that the vast majority of "letter mail" is junk that I don't want at all. It's actually a hassle to have USPS deliver junk and have to walk down the block to retrieve it, to turn right around and drop it in the trash. If I could forgo USPS delivery and just get stuff dropped in my front door (like UPS and FedEx do), I'd be better off.
- billbrown 7y agoUSPS also enjoys federal protection of its product that none of the others have: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1708 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1708 I'd wager that "porch pirates" don't go into mailboxes even though there's valuable stuff in them.
- Retric 7y agoStealing mail is very common. It’s one of the easiest ways to commit identity theft and can be surprisingly efficient. https://www.koaa.com/thieves-use-usps-informed-delivery-to-monitor-and-steal-mail https://www.koaa.com/thieves-use-usps-informed-delivery-to-m...
- jessriedel 7y agoThe USPS absolutely has a legally enforced monopoly in the textbook sense of the word. It's just not over the entire market of letter and package delivery. > The USPS actually has two legally enforced monopolies, as per Title 39 of the US Code. One is over the delivery of anything defined as a “letter,” which is within certain size and weight limits. The second is over the use of your mailbox...there are criminal violations if anyone puts anything in your mail box that is not US government approved “mail. > ...parcels were never subject to the delivery monopoly. Indeed, UPS was in that business first, and USPS entered afterwards. ...This is why DHL, FedEx, Amazon... and others are free to enter and exit the parcel business. It is defined as a different market. > FedEx is another fascinating story. There was a need for express document delivery among professional services, such as law firms (this was of course long before e-mail). The USPS was too slow and unreliable. FedEx and Fred Smith threatened to litigate the issue to death...so the USPS allowed an exception in the delivery monopoly for “extremely urgent material.” https://fee.org/articles/an-expert-explains-the-postal-monopoly/ https://fee.org/articles/an-expert-explains-the-postal-monop...
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIs that law ever enforced? I get packages from Amazon couriers and FedEx in my mailbox all the time and I've never heard of anyone going to jail for that. I can only imagine how much I'd get laughed at if I called the cops about a delivery person dropping a package off in my mailbox. Maybe I'd need to call the USPS Inspector General
- kick 7y agoThe Wikipedia article is literally about the USPS monopoly being enforced.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThe company in the Wikipedia article went out of business nearly 200 years ago, so I don't think the legal situation is necessarily the same (backed up by the anecdotal fact that I can send a letter via Fedex). The Wikipedia article also doesn't mention anything about how the government apparently has exclusive access to MY mailbox, which is a big surprise to me.