8 ms·
>No matter how many people say "but a well regulated mandatory multi-payer type of system is working in Germany" or "nationalized medicine is working in Canada"
by coldtea 7y ago
>No matter how many people say "but a well regulated mandatory multi-payer type of system is working in Germany" or "nationalized medicine is working in Canada" it's all just ignored and the argument continues anew.
I don't think their problem (at least of one side of the debate) is whether it will work or not.
Their issue is a moral one, whether they should ever pay into a health care pool for the benefit of other people.
Those that think they can manage on their own don't see why that should happen. And as a protestant inspired culture that took it even further than the original protestants, they find this appalling.
They'd rather see people die in the streets and step over them on the way to brunch, than have themselves, hardworking "good" persons that they are, contribute for the health of the poor and the "losers". Even more so if it's mandatory. Charity from their magnanimous heart, they can consider.
- Ensorceled 7y agoYeah, I definitely get that from the subtext or, sometimes, the text. The weird thing is that it's cutting off their noses to spite their faces ... they spend MORE on insurance then they would in taxes. But in a lot of cases, it's like they will not (or can not) learn from what is going on in other countries. Maybe it's also US exceptionalism at play?
- oblio 7y agoI think you can see a bit of the same thing with ID cards and unique identifiers. Most European countries have a state-issued ID card and an unique identifier for every citizen. The US has a million IDs from different institutions, states, corporations and they keep causing messes, still, having 1 ID card and a unique identifier is seen as bad for reasons that baffle me.
- war1025 7y agoI think what it comes down to for many people is that their employer covers their health insurance premiums, and they fear that they would actually have to pay market value for health insurance if it were removed from the employer benefit umbrella. For a country that supposedly values small business, there are few things I could think of that would support small business more than public healthcare. Currently, large employers can get a group plan with very reasonable rates. Small employers are pretty much out of luck. It stands to reason to me that the bigger the pool, the more predictable and lower the costs. It's ridiculous to me that arbitrary groups of people can't go in on a health plan together. If a company with 50k employees can do it, why can't a city / state / random assortment of people?
- wayoutthere 7y agoThat’s basically what the health exchanges are. Small businesses do not have to provide health insurance; and in most cases the exchanges provide more choice and lower cost than small businesses would have access to. But it does increase the gap in wages between the big corporates and small businesses. It’s very hard for small businesses to hire good talent when they can work in the corporate world for a higher salary plus benefits.
- war1025 7y agoAs someone who works for a small company (~10-15 people), it's possible we're missing out on something obvious, but two years ago we (my employer) looked pretty extensively into our different options and settled on our current plan as the best option. I have a 1500/3000 family plan with a sticker price of $32,000 / year. I pay a third of that and my employer picks up the rest. I guess it's possible that this is about the going rate and most employers just pick up more of the cost than mine. Either way, that seems like an unsustainable amount of money to be paying each year.
- wayoutthere 7y agoYeah, a family plan at my employer (a big corporate) with the same limits is about $5000/yr to the employee. And that’s on top of the fact my salary is already 25-50% higher than it would be at a small business. The deck is seriously stacked against smaller employers right now.
- rsynnott 7y ago> Their issue is a moral one, whether they should ever pay into a health care pool for the benefit of other people. I mean, realistically, that's what all insurance is anyway. The trouble with the US system (vs other mandatory/psuedo-mandatory insurance systems) is more around the way it's regulated.
- alistairSH 7y agoYes, but insurance is "voluntary". And socialism is bad. (It's not really voluntary... While you can opt out, if you have moderate income or better, you do so at your own financial peril)
- sjg007 7y agoWe already pay medicare and medicaid taxes. Those are not voluntary.
- alistairSH 7y agoTrue. We are required to pay taxes to support insurance schemes we can never use ourselves. So, in a sense, it's worse than what I stated. Payment is compulsory, but coverage is optional (and extra cost) for the majority of working Americans.
- coldtea 7y ago>I mean, realistically, that's what all insurance is anyway That's ok, as long as it's voluntary (as a sibling comment wrote), and as long as private companies, and not the public pool, benefits. /s
- SamuelAdams 7y agoThis mindset does not make sense to me. People already pay for local schools (K-12), even if they have no children. They already pay for a local library, even if they never use it. People pay for services that benefit others all the time - why should health be any different?
- war1025 7y agoMy father in law said something along the lines of "I don't know why they make us pay taxes for the public school system." So that mindset is definitely out there. (My wife and her brother got sent to a private Christian school) I think his main issue with it is that he thinks they are wasteful with their budgets. I've never really figured it out.
- SamuelAdams 7y agoThis mindset does not make sense to me. People already pay for local schools (K-12), even if they have no children. They already pay for a local library, even if they never use it. They pay for a local fire department, even if their house never burns down. They pay for a local police station, even if they are never the victim of a crime. People pay for services that benefit others all the time - why should health be any different?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThere are quite a few people in the US who would rather not pay for schools and libraries for other people’s children.
- quadrifoliate 7y ago> People already pay for local schools (K-12), even if they have no children. Very rarely. Good schools attract paying parents with large families, leading to a self-reinforcing effect and affecting property values so much that it's one of the search facets on property sites like Zillow. So really they pay for their children, usually. > They already pay for a local library, even if they never use it. This is a relic of when people did use libraries more. A lot of library systems are dying out with the excuse of "but we prefer Kindles". > They pay for a local fire department, even if their house never burns down. They pay for a local police station, even if they are never the victim of a crime. They do this more out of fear of avoiding viscerally life-threatening consequences. Somehow healthcare has assumed the status of not such a thing in the States. ----------- For what it's worth, I am strongly opposed to these viewpoints, but just stating that there is not as much self-contradiction there as you think.
- boardwaalk 7y agoWhat do you mean people “very rarely” pay for local schools? I pay over 50% of my local property taxes into the school district here. It’s roughly that much all over the city and all over any big city in my state; you can’t escape it. And it was about $2800 out of my pocket last year. And if you’re not paying this directly, it’s probably because you rent (and you’re getting passed on the cost) or it’s hidden in income taxes.
- sjg007 7y ago>Their issue is a moral one, whether they should ever pay into a health care pool for the benefit of other people. We already do. It's called private insurance. We also pay into medicaid and medicare.
- wayoutthere 7y agoThat would be great, except a large percentage of the country doesn’t make enough money to afford insurance. So they go to the ER (the most expensive form of care) and end up neck-deep in medical debt from routine health issues. Even when you can afford it, an increasing number of doctors are refusing to accept insurance. These doctors tend to be more highly regarded and provide a higher standard of care because they’re not shackled to a computer doing insurance paperwork half the day. So even with the system we have, insurance isn’t really worth it unless you have chronic health issues. This becomes a feedback loop of increasing prices and decreasing benefits for all but the most expensive patients. Profit is a moral hazard in health care.
- creaghpatr 7y agoLack of profit a deadlier hazard.
- sjg007 7y agoThat's not what I said. I am saying it's not a moral issue. We already pay! We already accept that we have to pay!
- wayoutthere 7y agoThe moral hazard isn’t in paying for it, it’s in how the profit motive multiplied across dozens of middlemen is corrosive to the quality of the system. We’re paying for it regardless, but we pay a lot more under the current system because we have to support perpetual growth of every company in the value chain.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoThat's not the same thing. Other "hard working" people are paying into private ins along with you. The poor don't because their hours are capped at 30 so they'll never get health insurance. Therefore they're not contributing, therefore they don't deserve it. Note: This is not my position on the matter. Just trying to explain the difference. Edit: Regarding Medicaid and Medicare - believe me, people would love to see Medicaid go also. I think they're OK-ish with Medicare because they know they'll get old at some point.
- Giho 7y agoThat makes me think of Braess paradox and see parallels. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess's_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess's_paradox) As most people seem to try to take the most optimal self-interested decision it does not always make the outcome the most optimal for them or everyone. As actions we take as not, affect more than ourselves and can't be totally disconnected from this world. And as a individual to be able to take the most optimal decision in complex systems is pretty difficult. What would we be without our choice and an AI or a higher power would take the decisions for us?
- Frost1x 7y agoI'd posit that the morale and cultural issue is exacerbated in mid- to lower-income brackets by the ever tightening costs of surviving in modern society. The fact people in general can barely maintain their own needs makes it even more of a struggle to sell helping everyone else in general (healthcare, fire departments, schools...). They, themselves, would like financial assistance but can't get it so have quite a bit of resentment (and who can blame them for that). If most folks had more resources (e.g. money), I think you'd find the culture would shift a reasonable amount towards supporting things like universal healthcare, etc. In a culture driven by constant economic competition for survival, it makes sense that people don't want to help their potential economic enemies. If there's fewer people, there's less competition, less kids to grow up and displace them, etc. There are still people who literally do not have any concern for the wellbeing of others and no amount of resources would change their perspectives but I argue those are relatively few in the general population.
- xorcist 7y agoWhat's particularly interesting is that military spending is completely socialized, and this does not seem to bother people nearly as much.
- frockington1 7y agoThat argument was discussed and resolved when the Articles of Confederation were disbanded some 200+ years ago. If anything military spending would be a good reason not too socialize anything as it has clearly gotten out of control.
- UncleMeat 7y agoThen they better just not like insurance in general, since that is literally "paying into a health care pool for the benefit of other people". Yet I've never once seen a "we should just pay costs" argument, since it would invariably lead to large scale preventable suffering and death.
- JustSomeNobody 7y ago> Those that think they can manage on their own don't see why that should happen. And as a protestant inspired culture that took it even further than the original protestants, they find this appalling. > They'd rather see people die in the streets and step over them on the way to brunch, than have themselves, hardworking "good" persons that they are, contribute for the health of the poor and the "losers". Even more so if it's mandatory. Charity from their magnanimous heart, they can consider. This is a great summary of the issue.
- tapland 7y agoThey are though. The US are among the top countries in the world in $/capita from public (tax) funding towards healthcare. And then they add a stack of about the same size of private funding. Americans pay about twice as much as all other western nations for the opportunity to turn people away. It's not about contributing for the health of losers, it's about being ok with paying double so that losers don't get anything. This belief that it's about not wanting to pay needs to end. They are paying just as much as everyone else from taxes, and then paying another just as big amount out of their own pockets.
- levythe 7y agoYou both fundamentally misunderstand. American conservatives don't trust the government to do right by the people. It's as simple as that.