4 ms·
Competitive markets tend to optimize large profits away. If someone is charging lots for less effective treatment, the expectation in a market economy is that a
by maxerickson 7y ago
Competitive markets tend to optimize large profits away. If someone is charging lots for less effective treatment, the expectation in a market economy is that a competitor will step in.
The analysis you present is not uncommon, where the businessman somehow gets to choose how much money he makes in a vacuum, a situation that doesn't really exist.
Ironically, lots of US regulations prevent providers from entering markets, letting providers that already have regulatory approval charge more. Some regulations are literally written with this as the goal (CONs, Medicare reimbursement rules designed to prop up small hospitals with emergency rooms).
- jbeam 7y agoFor competitive markets to work, consumers need to be able to rationally shop around. The medical system is not even close to built in such a way. You cannot shop around when you are riding an ambulance to a hospital, and those with potentially terminal diseases usually prioritize living. The existence of insurance, which no one suggests we should go without, adds another moral hazard that encourages the consumer to be less price elastic. It would be just as massive an overhaul to turn this sector into a truly competitive market as it would be to nationalize it.
- tynpeddler 7y agoResearch suggests that emergency room costs are 7% or less of total healthcare spending in the US (some studies claim it's as low as 2% of total yearly costs). In other words, there's a lot of room for shopping around.
- distances 7y agoBut in the current system you can't. Nobody will tell you the cost of operation or treatment. It's not even malice: nobody knows what it'll cost. The system efficiently avoids competition.
- tynpeddler 7y agoMy comment was not made in a vacuum. It was intended to address the concern raised by jbeam that emergency situation in healthcare completely preclude the use of market dynamics. My point is that emergencies are only a small part of healthcare, and by themselves are not enough to derail the idea of bringing markets back to healthcare.
- distances 7y agoThanks for the clarification.
- chapium 7y agoI'd argue its not a competitive market in many cases. There are limits on your doctor choice depending on your insurer. You cannot shop around for a treatment, the hospital lines one up connected to their doctor's network and your insurance.
- maxerickson 7y agoYes, absolutely, that is what I am arguing. I was trying to establish that running healthcare as a business isn't the only problem with healthcare.