4 ms·
Completely disagree here. All Corellium has done is virtualize hardware that can run iOS. How is that possibly copyright infringement (outside of the DMCA's b
by kelnos 7y ago
Completely disagree here. All Corellium has done is virtualize hardware that can run iOS. How is that possibly copyright infringement (outside of the DMCA's brain-dead bullshit, anyway)?
If Corellium is distributing the IPSWs that can run on their emulator, then sure, that would be out of bounds (presumably Apple has not licensed other entities to distribute iOS)[0]. But if the user provides the IPSW to run, this is analogous to a version of VirtualBox that can boot iOS. It's absurd to think that should be illegal.
If this suit doesn't go well for Corellium, I really hope they open-source their tech. Good luck to Apple trying to ban that from existence.
[0] Regardless, this is not what Apple appears to be suing them about.
- toyg 7y agoApple forbids in its EULAs to run their software on non-Apple hardware, including any virtualization platform if it’s not running on Apple hardware, and I doubt Corellium is running their saas on repurposed MacPros.
- coldtea 7y agoSo? EULAs are not exactly legally binding in most countries, and even in the US it's complicated whether they are or not: https://superuser.com/questions/30940/is-an-eula-enforceable https://superuser.com/questions/30940/is-an-eula-enforceable The enforceability of an EULA depends on several factors, one of them being the court in which the case is heard. Some courts that have addressed the validity of the shrinkwrap license agreements have found some EULAs to be invalid, characterizing them as contracts of adhesion, unconscionable, and/or unacceptable pursuant to the U.C.C.—see, for instance, Step-Saver Data Systems, Inc. v. Wyse Technology,[6] Vault Corp. v. Quaid Software Ltd..[7] Other courts have determined that the shrinkwrap license agreement is valid and enforceable: see ProCD, Inc. v. Zeidenberg,[8] Microsoft v. Harmony Computers,[9] Novell v. Network Trade Center,[10] and Ariz. Cartridge Remanufacturers Ass'n v. Lexmark Int'l, Inc.[11] may have some bearing as well. No court has ruled on the validity of EULAs generally; decisions are limited to particular provisions and terms. (Wikipedia)
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 7y agoIf we're lucky we'll get better precedent from this suit.
- dahfizz 7y agoIANAL, but seeing as Corellium is not an end user, I don't see how the end user license agreement matters.
- rowanG077 7y agoSo what? EULAs are mostly bullshit documents that aren't enforceable in most countries.
- kelnos 7y agoI can download iOS from Apple's servers without seeing or agreeing to any EULA whatsoever, so that's not really relevant.
- FDSGSG 7y ago> All Corellium has done is virtualize hardware that can run iOS This is a downright lie. >The Corellium Apple Product makes modifications to iOS that allows it to be installed on, and run from, Corellium-developed or Corellium-operated hardware. Such modifications include disabling loadable firmware validation, disabling self-verification of the FIPS module, adding Corellium software to the “trust cache,” and instructing the restore tool not to contact Apple servers for kernel / device tree / firmware signing. - > But if the user provides the IPSW to run Ok, but that's not how Corellium works as is evident from the links in TFA https://i.imgur.com/RXe2aE2.png https://i.imgur.com/RXe2aE2.png
- jakeashacks 7y agoThere is nothing wrong with doing modifications. Jailbreaks do modifications to iOS but they are legal. And Corellium might not ask the user for the software but they still are downloading it from Apple servers, so I don't see how that makes a difference (but if it does, Corellium can very well apply the upload-your-own-ipsw idea)
- jjeaff 7y agoI don't think jailbreaking is necessarily legal. There is a lot of conflicting case law. I don't know if there have been any iOS jailbreak related cases but the Sony, geohot thing comes to mind. And cracking drm, even for backup purposes seems to be against the dmca.
- jakeashacks 7y agoJailbreaking is against DMCA laws (which by the way are pretty stupid; they should only account for cases when the locks are circumvented for piracy/malware purposes; but at least we got exemptions...), but there is an exemption that specifically allows jailbreaking. Important to note however, that is a DMCA exemption, not an "EULA exemption" (used quotes because that term probably doesn't exist), the exemption ignores the DMCA law, not the EULA, which proves that the EULA isn't really legally enforceable, it's more of a threat from Apple "if you do that we won't give you support/service".