4 ms·
It's certainly discriminatory. The question is if it's legal to discriminate in this way or if nicotine use is a protected class. That they're choosing to only
by toast0 7y ago
It's certainly discriminatory. The question is if it's legal to discriminate in this way or if nicotine use is a protected class. That they're choosing to only implement this in some states may indicate that they're not totally confident.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoI’m concerned it’s creating unnecessary hardships. Quitting smoking is hard. If you’ve lost a job and need a new job then stressing over U-Haul’s no-nicotine policy - or losing out on a job that you’re otherwise qualified for only because of your nicotine habit - then I imagine the added stress and disappointment - and hit to one’s ego - might drive someone to smoke more - or adopt other unhealthy habits like drinking. Also, I’d be very surprised if significant numbers of people give up not just smoking, but all forms of nicotine, just to get a job at U-Haul. They’re probably missing out on great talent this way. ...now, if they instead would hire a smoker on the condition they complete a company-funded stop-smoking treatment course, then that’s different. I admit I haven’t read the article so I don’t know if that was mentioned.
- dehrmann 7y agoUnless this veers into mental health or Native Americans with a legitimate religious use, yeah, no protected class here.
- thaeli 7y agoIt may also indicate that they think this will reduce their labor pool too much in some states.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoSmoking anything has no relation to protected class status. The question is if they'd qualify as Disabled under the ADA as addictions can qualify as a disability.
- apta 7y agoIt's quite ridiculous if that's the case. Someone getting him or herself willingly into an addiction (especially nicotine) should not constitute a "disability". Unless they're classified as mentally disabled since they couldn't judge right from wrong to begin with, in which case they have other issues to worry about.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoSo if I get drunk and drive into a tree and can't work anymore because my injuries were too severe, I should be able to get disability, but if I managed to get hooked on an addictive substance then I can't even be allowed to manage my addiction symptoms? Only thing ridiculous here is your short-sightedness.
- apta 7y agoPerhaps, getting drunk is a deliberate decision in general. People should face the consequences of such (and we already see it).