4 ms·
That's kinda how encryption works. Keeps everyones comminication safe. Incl terrorists. Society just need to decide how it wants to play this because its an ei
by Havoc 7y ago
That's kinda how encryption works. Keeps everyones comminication safe. Incl terrorists.
Society just need to decide how it wants to play this because its an either or proposition.
There is no technical encryption protocol that works only for the good guys. Unfortunately the legislators are too thick to realise this simple fact.
- rubyfan 7y agoThey aren’t too thick. They just don’t care.
- nyokodo 7y agoAssuming that society decided that encrypted communication was a common good and diligently protected it, something that I support, it's important to consider what this really means and what it doesn't mean. Law enforcement and national security agencies will retain all other means of investigating and tracking threats. It does mean that it's harder for them to casually snoop on everyone for no good reason.
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> It does mean that it's harder for them to casually snoop on everyone for no good reason. It should be straight up impossible.
- im3w1l 7y agoInteresting. By making the implicit explicit you open it to questioning. Is it really either or? Backdoored encryption is an interesting concept, but suffers from the problem that the bad guys could get their hands on the key. But could there be another way? Something like k-out-of-n keyholders have to agree for the backdoor to open. Shamir's secret sharing could do it, but has the drawbacks that it's one-shot and that someone has to know the key to set the scheme up. You want every investigation to require a new k-out-of-n agreement. Ultimately we ought to design society so that a large group (legitimate protest) of people can defy the government but a small group (criminal gang) cannot.
- behringer 7y agoYes. Just like the founding fathers, small groups are extremely dangerous.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jshevek 7y agoI disagree with the suggestion that the size of the group is important here. For example, a better measure might be the nature of the harm, if any, done by the defiant group.
- colechristensen 7y agoIf I send a text message to my partner in the other room, nobody has any right to intercept that whether I'm a "good guy" or not. Before technology I might have walked into the other room and spoken, if I did that nobody would have any right to enter my home and set up a recording device, that's obvious. If I hired a messenger to take a spoken message to my partner across town, the same applies. Nobody has any right to interrogate my messenger and he has no obligation to answer. If I send electronic messages it should be no different. The fact that interception and surveillance is possible doesn't suddenly make it obligatory. Technology is power, in whatever form it comes in from weapons to education to communication. That power makes law enforcement more powerful and criminals more powerful. Law enforcement wants it both ways. They want the increased power of their own encrypted communications, their own education, their own better tools and techniques AND they want to use technology to take away power that their supposed adversaries wouldn't have even been able to lose before the tech existed. The technology exists. It can't be taken off the playing field. It doesn't matter how bad the "bad guys" are, law enforcement does not deserve that much power in a free society. The power balance between the state's monopoly on force and the people needs to be maintained. If it is not, abuses are inevitable.
- caseysoftware 7y agoIf we want to fix this problem, the first step is eliminating Third Party Doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine Basically, it says as soon as you involve a third party - in your example, a messaging app - you can't expect privacy and therefore law enforcement doesn't need a warrant. If law enforcement had to get warrants for all of this information from services, providers, and vendors, they'd be forced to a) be more selective and b) move slower for judicial review. Both constraints would significantly improve the situation.
- yason 7y agoIf I mail you a letter doesn't that remain private and protected unless law enforcement has a warrant to explicitly intercept my mail?
- WarOnPrivacy 7y ago> Society just need to decide how it wants to play this because its an either or proposition. In the US the odds of dying in a terror attack have remained historically low since the mid 1970s. Specifically, it's between 1:12M and 1:40M - about the same as picking the correct inch between DC and NYC. Conversely, the odds of a US citizen (who is not suspected of a crime) being inappropriately surveilled is near 100%. How to play it? Prioritize real threats over the nearly imaginary ones.
- sfifs 7y ago> Unfortunately the legislators are too thick to realise this simple fact. In general I have seen that if people are smart enough to get people to vote for them, they probably have smarts and leadership skills not dissimilar to business leaders. They very likely understand what encryption entails. They probably don't share your values on whether it's a good thing.