3 ms·
> there are thousands of lines of hacked-together proprietary vendor code in those kernels where just going up a minor version will break the build. For a 2.6 b
by mschuster91 7y ago
> there are thousands of lines of hacked-together proprietary vendor code in those kernels where just going up a minor version will break the build. For a 2.6 based system in particular, you would essentially need to convert the entire board support to a device tree based system.
What I don't get with these cases at all: by the GPL manufacturers are forced to provide the full (!) Linux kernel source code, same goes for u-boot. But while Tesla at least seems to provide source code (https://github.com/teslamotors https://github.com/teslamotors), why the fuck and how can Android phone and other embedded device makers get away with not publishing anything?
Let's just take two examples of hardware that I know run Linux because I managed to root them:
- Sony A7S2 camera: the firmware is at https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/downloads/00016077 https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/downloads/00016077, but no mention at all about contained open-source code, licenses, or build instructions
- HP Z2100 24-inch plotter: firmware is at https://support.hp.com/sg-en/drivers/selfservice/hp-designjet-z2100-photo-printer-series/3204963 https://support.hp.com/sg-en/drivers/selfservice/hp-designje... (you have to select Windows XP 32-bit to see the firmware download, even though the firmware can be installed via anything capable of running a browser), and again, no mention of anything regarding Linux.
- saagarjha 7y agoBecause nobody goes after them for it.
- cjbprime 7y ago> why the fuck and how can Android phone and other embedded device makers get away with not publishing anything? In general, the answer is that Linus Torvalds especially, and kernel developers in general, are very uninterested in filing copyright lawsuits, and it's them who have standing to bring a GPL violation lawsuit, rather than you as a purchaser -- it's not your rights that have been legally infringed, it's the code author's rights. If the device manufacturer is not a US company (like the often-Chinese Android phone manufacturers), filing that lawsuit would be especially difficult even if the authors wanted to. In these Sony and HP cases, they aren't required to put the source code on their firmware download pages. They're required to offer and produce it in response to a written request under GPLv2, or to instead bundle it with the hardware (e.g. on companion CD). You might find they actually do one of those two, since they're large US companies with mostly competent legal departments. Incidentally, it took a lawsuit, or at least the imminent threat of one, for Tesla to start publishing kernel source: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2018/may/18/tesla-incomplete-ccs/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2018/may/18/tesla-incomplete-... . I think the lawsuit was primarily filed on behalf of Busybox authors rather than Linux authors.
- mirashii 7y agoIt's important to remember that the GPL does not require that the modified source be publicly accessible, only available to those who you've distributed the modified program to. How that's verified and distributed is unspecified.
- cjbprime 7y ago> only available to those who you've distributed the modified program to That's not true. GPLv2 text: > Accompany it with a written offer, valid for at least three years, to give any third party, for a charge no more than your cost of physically performing source distribution, a complete machine-readable copy of the corresponding source code (Emphasis mine.)
- mirashii 7y agoThere's two issues with that. First, that's only one of three available options (two for commercial entities) that satisfy the license. The other is to include a copy of the source code with the software distribution. However, separately, this does not require that the source code be posted in a public place for anyone to access. You only must give with the distribution a written offer. That offer is valid to anyone, but it doesn't need to be posted in public and the source code does not need to be posted in public.