4 ms·
The parent comment is complete drivel. RISC-V has a very small instruction set (under 50 instructions in the base arch) and lacks the weirdness of UltraSPARC (
by rwmj 7y ago
The parent comment is complete drivel. RISC-V has a very small instruction set (under 50 instructions in the base arch) and lacks the weirdness of UltraSPARC (register windows! branch delay slots!). 680x0 was a joy to program in assembly, I used to be a commercial 68k developer on VMEbus systems, but those days are long gone and are never coming back. There is simply no point optimizing a modern architecture for hand-written assembler coding.
- CalChris 7y agotagged integers I'm not a RISC-V fan-boi by any stretch of the imagination but I have to admit that they certainly cleaned up RISC which 40+ years later was in order for a thorough house cleaning. X86 is gloriously messy but RISC had become quite a mess as well.
- floatboth 7y ago> RISC had become quite a mess as well That's kind of a nonsensical statement — "RISC" is not a particular ISA, RISC is a vague methodology/philosophy. RISC-V is not officially related to any previous ISA, but people like to call it "MIPS in a trenchcoat". RISC-V got off the ground in academia, and MIPS was often used for teaching before. They are quite similar in some ways, but it's really independent.
- CalChris 7y agoThat is being overly pedantic. I'm actually paraphrasing chapter 2 of Andrew Waterman's thesis, The Design Of The RISC-V Instruction Set Architecture. https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~krste/papers/EECS-2016-1.pdf https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~krste/papers/EECS-2016-1.p...
- rstuart4133 7y agoThat link was a fantastic read. Thank you.
- ncmncm 7y agoI wonder why they studiously avoided even ever mentioning IBM Power architecture. It is considerably more open than MIPS or ARM, and quite a lot cleaner than either has become.
- CalChris 7y agoWell, open-ness wasn't what RISC-V was looking at in ISA models. Is Power clean? Myself, I've never liked its special purpose Condition, Link and Count registers. I don't see the need for a Branch Processing Unit being an architectural division. The last time I checked, pushing a register value across that boundary was slow. It wasn't handled by a renamer.
- ncmncm 7y agoClean-er. Not suggesting it as a substitute for RV, just wondering why they saw nothing in it to learn from. It's not defunct like PA-RISC, Alpha, and (forgive me) SPARC, and quite some research has gone into it.
- CalChris 7y agoI have to admit that leaving Power out of the analysis is a bit odd; the Berkeley crew can be rather parochial. I wrote PowerPC assembly back when the Mac used that ISA and liked it. Alpha lives on, to a degree, in the Sunway Chinese supercomputers. Intel should have gone with Alpha rather than Itanium. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunway_(processor) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunway_(processor) Is there an architectural feature in Power you think should have been considered by RISC-V for inclusion or omission? My 2030 prediction is that Intel will have a simpler x86 where they discard a shit ton of legacy.
- ncmncm 7y agoDon't know it well enough to suggest any. That is what inclusion in the survey would have been useful for. It is conventional to complain about condition codes, but I don't see what would be debilitating about just appending a set of condition codes to each register, so that renaming a register carries them along. Going from storing 64 bits to 70 bits each would't break the bank.
- Annatar 7y agoYou haven't been paying attention: we now run 64-bit AMMX extended MC68080's which get faster and faster every firmware update. SPARC register windows are an awesome thing once you grok them; 256 virtual registers and pedal to the metal!
- zozbot234 7y agoThere are unofficial extensions to the architecture, but I don't think Moto/Freescale/NXP have gone ahead with anything like that. This matters for serious users who care about more than keeping up the 68k legacy. RISC-V is a big deal in computer architecture, the latest vanity extensions on the 68k not really.
- Annatar 7y agoWhen you can show me a 1U, 19" rack mountable server with a RISC-V processor in it which beats the competition in both price and performance, then we'll talk; until then, it's just a toy.