5 ms·
Every Republican nominee and political organization has been compared to fascists and Hitler since the early 1950s. It long ago lost its punch yet it's still t
by dmix 7y ago
Every Republican nominee and political organization has been compared to fascists and Hitler since the early 1950s.
It long ago lost its punch yet it's still the go-to for every leftwing political ideologue like it will be taken seriously.
I agree that this same stuff has been going on forever but I've noticed a significant decline in tolerance by the left of even engaging and debating those on the right. The positions of ivory tower righteous we-know-best reputation which the left has always been known for has gone into overdrive - mostly on social media but it's leaking into reputable papers like NYT and less reputable ones in terms of neutrality like WaPo. Plus the crazy radical stuff coming out of places like Teen Vogue are also quite new.
Crossing lines has always been a critical political necessity as so much of politics is built on compromise. But at least culturally the hysteria and FUD being stirred up online has completely destroyed any sense of understanding or breaching the other side. Which is turning modern politics into a form of trench warfare.
The right have certainly contributed to it by tolerating their crazies a little too frequently (even though they rarely win or have any power outside of useful headlines in the political media coverage) when in the past they'd stay the fringe and get zero news coverage or attention, which would otherwise increase their standing and help with recruitment to turn otherwise fringe crazies into groups the media presents with seriousness and legitimacy - because they find it useful to attach it to more mainstream and moderate voters. Which I think is a dangerous game to play and one we've already seen the consequences of.
It's far easier for the baddies to recruit and be real threads when the media and other influential people connect them to the real power players in Washington who've never heard of them and would want nothing to do with them.
- seamyb88 7y agoJust a friendly outsider perspective, with no vested interests, which is commonly shared all over the world: The US Republican party are Fascists. Hope this helps.
- dmix 7y agoVery effective strategy you got there. It's been tried in every one of the last 6 decades of elections, I'm sure it will penetrate the minds of the voters so effectively and not highlight how out-of-touch and extreme certain quarters have become or remain. Not even just republicans, plenty on the left would laugh off such banal and uninteresting of takes.
- seamyb88 7y agoStrategy? You're a bit paranoid are ye? I'm from Ireland and have never set, nor would I want to set, foot in Shamerica. f'n gun nuts who hate immigrants despite themselves being founded on the genocide of the original people on the land. I feel sorry for the people in your country who aren't thick as two planks.
- Mirioron 7y agoI'd like to add to what you're saying: the religious right of the 2000s and earlier is what some of the left wing looks like today. Instead of religion they have some form of social justice.
- adamsea 7y agoI agree that fascist / Nazi comparisons aren’t very useful. I do think that the current administration exhibits behavior (verifiable, fact-checkable behavior) which legitimately meets the definition of “authoritarian” — “demanding total obedience to those in positions of authority” - https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/authoritarian https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/authorit... — in ways that are different from past administrations,
- celticmusic 7y agoit goes in cycles, each side gains power, abuses it, then loses it. When the left gain power, it becomes all about political correctness. When the right gain power, it becomes all about religious morality. both try to suffocate each other, and both make being in the middle incredibly difficult because the middle gets attacked from both sides.
- dmix 7y agoThe difference is the right has never gain power in the media, academia, and based on a resent report showing a 75% left or far left leaning on Twitter, social media. My concern is when the more hysterical stuff you’d find at protests (ie, Bush’s face overlaid on Hitler) starts leaking into more reputable sources and every person on the right is treated like a complete pariah... the right had always famously been the “silent majority”. The silent part is becoming a hard requirement these days which really concerns me. All things should happen in the daylight and a complete intolerance, misrepresentation, and overreaction is what pushes them underground only worsens these radicalism and extremism which we should expunge from both sides by challenging it openly. Instead of one side having an unfiltered field day and monopoly on the media which treats them like villains non stop. Especially when the only option left is Fox News which is full of crazy bullshit (but compared to most traffic rates of major websites not really that popular among the average voter in the big picture).
- stOneskull 7y agoYou are totally right and your calm nature in talking about it is impressive. It drives me nuts so I put my head in the sand and try to pretend it doesn't exist
- toss1 7y ago>>"the right has never gain power in the media, academia" Excluding, the Murdoch empire including Fox News, the entire RW media ecosystem,'access journalism' as practiced by such as the NYT, and the general false equivalence presumption of most large media outlets. Denying that there is any RW power in the media is a strawman argument at best. In Academia? Seems to overlook the fact that when given sufficient thought, many RW concepts are justifications for policies that do not hold up to data-backed studies (e.g., benefits of treating drug use as a public health issue), are simply outright denial of science (climate change / AGW denialism), or are straight-up anti-intellectualism used to support popular movements. Combine these trends, and there is sound reason to consider that academia being more liberal is not some crass bias, but based on well-founded reasons.
- shiftless 7y agoThe real fact of the matter is both the R's and the D's are on the same team, both of them working for the destruction of the nation, and they always have been from the beginning. If you believe otherwise, as you seem to be implying by your long "It's Really All Those People's Fault" comment, then you have been deceived. Trump isn't your hero. He's a lying ass Yankee piece of shit. He didn't come to drain the swamp, but to expand it to 10x the size, and to destroy the nation in the process. Comparisons of Trump to Hitler (both of whom are/were simply front men, hired by the same people) are uncannily unaccurate, which is why they brought out this comparison early on and had all of the well-hated political figures of America (whom they knew via opinion polls over decades that everyone hates) to make the comparison, beating that drum constantly so everyone would tire of it and be conditioned (like a dog) to tune it out, along with creating violent thug groups like Antifa as the "controlled opposition", simply as a way of brainwashing people to interpret the situation as you have interpreted it--so that you will ignore the haters and goosestep behind Trump right off the edge of the cliff. It's psychological manipulation on a mass scale. Look at a picture of Angela Merkel some time, president of Germany. Study her face closely. That's Hitler's daughter.
- sgnelson 7y ago"The right have certainly contributed to it by tolerating their crazies a little too frequently (even though they rarely win or have any power outside of useful headlines in the political media coverage) when in the past they'd stay the fringe and get zero news coverage or attention..." I find that pretty funny considering who the current president is. I would go further to argue that was in part the reason he was elected. This is after all the man who started getting more and more attention for claiming that the former president was born in Kenya.