15 ms·
As a long term Australian, this is categorically the worst fire season Australia has experienced. Summer in Australia always comes with one or two big fires in
by BLKNSLVR 7y ago
As a long term Australian, this is categorically the worst fire season Australia has experienced.
Summer in Australia always comes with one or two big fires in at-risk rural areas over the months from December to February.
Queensland and New South Wales were burning heavily by early December. And now Victoria and South Australia have joined in as well and we're still only just into the second month of three. It's unprecedented.
The one thing that may provide back handed comfort is that so much has burnt that it will be a few years before enough 'fuel' is regrown for fires of this scale to be possible again.
I'm wondering the unknowable tipping point at which the cost of rebuilding from bushfires outweighs the costs of de-carbonising the economy. Part of the problem with that is who / where the costs are borne / spread amongst.
- shard972 7y agoHow will de-carbonising the economy stop bush-fires on this scale?
- raaaaraaaa2 7y agoI would expect that intensive large fires will destroy all forests in affected areas... So next season will be 'fine' (= no trees at all).
- Tehdasi 7y agoNot quite, there will be less fuel, but not less trees. The bushland of Australia has had regular fires baked into it's ecosystem, so the plant species all have coping mechanisms to deal with fire. A good example is are the Banksia varieties that rely on a bushfire to germinate.
- Scarblac 7y agoYes, but apparently there are now also lots of forests burning that have never burned before and where the trees aren't adapted for it.
- gwillz 7y agoIn addition to that, some fires are burning so hot and so regularly that the trees and seeds completely die. They haven't got the breathing time to recover.
- h0l0cube 7y agoThese are typically areas where eucalypts have died off after centuries, allowing other species to fill the gap. Now that the fires have come through, the eucalypts will come back to fill the gaps and will quickly out-compete any other plants with superior height and canopy. They will get their next chance, a few centuries hence.
- bjowen 7y agoThis isn’t true of the areas of greatest concern, where Gondwanan rainforest is burning. Eucalyptus is the newcomer, and it is fire-adapted and hot weather adapted, it out-competes the ancient forests where there are fires, and the nothofagus does not grow back.
- h0l0cube 7y agoThis process happens too in Tasmania where most of that beautiful nothofagus grows. But you are right, these populations could be wiped out completely if fires increase and there's no chance for recovery - or the entire population is burnt. I wasn't suggesting that everything is okay, because it clearly isn't.
- elyobo 7y ago> second month of three Well, we hope there's only three. The long range forecasts weren't looking great, with lower than average levels of rainfall up until April.
- maddog3356 7y ago> the costs of de-carbonising the economy The costs are supposed to be about $94 T just in the US: See https://cei.org/blog/how-much-will-green-new-deal-cost-your-family?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIit2Ah__k5AIVD_DACh0m_wkZEAAYASAAEgJsQ_D_BwE https://cei.org/blog/how-much-will-green-new-deal-cost-your-... But there is no good evidence at all that human sources of CO2 have any significant effect on the temperature or climate of the earth: There is no good evidence that more CO2 would increase temperatures or that less CO2 would lower temperatures. For some solid details that drive a stake through the heart of the climate alarmist monster, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21933963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21933963 Here we can save the "costs", the $94 T in the US.
- maddog3356 7y agoSome anonymous viewers voted down this post. This post was very carefully written by a STEM field Ph.D. from a world class research university and is solid science and not politics. If you have a rational argument, then make it. Else it appears that HN has some dedicated climate alarmists who attack anything that questions their orthodoxy. Such behavior is political and against the Hacker News rules.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoWhat was the consensus percentage amongst climate scientists that human activity was causing the changing climate? 90+% But thanks for your single example of a counter viewpoint.
- braythwayt 7y agoYou have a new account, and complain about “anonymous viewers.” Hello, irony. Suggestion: if you are new here, read the posting guidelines and learn community norms. One of which is, don’t complain about downvotes. Everyone gets to choose how to vote, and neither you nor I are allowed to tell them that they shouldn’t downvote our comments. I’ve been here for a decade or so, I get downvoted into the negatives sometimes. It’s how HN works.
- adrianN 7y ago
- Scarblac 7y agoComparing the costs of decarbonising vs rebuilding isn't quite the right comparison though (though it'll be psychologically important). It's not as if climate change would be reverted or even stop if we stopped burning fossil fuel now. There is a lag on the effect, and the situation would still be getting worse for a century or so. The comparison is between all the extra future damage of burning even more than we already have vs the economic gains today.
- Brakenshire 7y agoCould you say that the dipole effect is giving an advanced preview of what the shifting baseline of global warming will deliver every year in a decade or two?
- polotics 7y agoOxides are very stable, Carbone dioxide is no exception, so... https://jancovici.com/en/climate-change/ghg-and-carbon-cycle/what-gases-are-greenhouse-gases/ https://jancovici.com/en/climate-change/ghg-and-carbon-cycle...
- roenxi 7y agoIf we could magically put a negative in front of Australia's CO2 emissions it would change nothing [0]. Even if we stopped selling coal and absorbed that amount of CO2 instead - and assume that nobody else mines coal to meet the market's demand - we would still easily see 90% of the worlds emissions at play. Australia is a moderate player in global terms, but decarbonising is literally a symbolic gesture with real negative consequences. The only response that makes any sense is to focus on better bushfire prevention methods. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita#/media/File:2018_AQAL_Group_variwide_chart_%22Worldwide_Co2_emissions%22.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
- Intermernet 7y agoAustralia is also actively not supporting local research and development into renewable energy technologies. Even if I bought the whole "we're only a small contributor to the problem, so it's not really our problem" argument (which I obviously don't), it'd be nice if we at least supported research and development that could actually make money as opposed to holding to the hard line that "anthropogenic climate change is a myth and therefore any effort to reduce it deserves no support".
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoP.S. Adelaide, South Australia forecast for 42 degrees Celsius tomorrow, but a cool change coming the following day.
- spodek 7y ago> the costs of de-carbonising the economy Global warming is important, but only one environmental problem, so important to consider here, but not the only environmental issue. Contributing to every environmental issue, including this one, is overpopulation. Humans have altered every continent, reducing biodiversity, introducing species that don't handle local climates as well, or too well and displace existing ones, making extinct species, and so on. I'm no expert, but the situation in Australia looks related to huge cities and lots of farms supporting a much larger human population than had ever lived there reducing biodiversity and resilience to fire, exacerbated by global warming. People fear discussing overpopulation because they only know of China's policy and eugenics, as did I until I learned of the successful, non-coercive policies of Thailand, Iran, Mexico, etc that increased peace, prosperity, and stability. I first learned of successful noncoercive birthrate reducing policies through Alan Weisman's excellent Countdown https://www.amazon.com/Countdown-Last-Best-Future-Earth/dp/0316097756 https://www.amazon.com/Countdown-Last-Best-Future-Earth/dp/0..., and of the critical importance of population through Limits to Growth https://www.amazon.com/Limits-Growth-Donella-H-Meadows/dp/193149858X https://www.amazon.com/Limits-Growth-Donella-H-Meadows/dp/19.... Those examples show that we can peacefully and stably lower birth rate to increase peace and prosperity and ease all other environmental problems. Steady-state following de-growth works more successfully on a full finite planet than pushing economic and population growth forever, which exacerbates problems like these and increases their impact on humans and other wildlife.
- DraftDodger67 7y agoThe biggest driver of Australia's increased emissions is the increasing population: https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2017/07/greenhouse-gas-emissions-tracking-population-growth/ https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2017/07/greenhouse-gas-emis... Under current immigration settings Australia will reach 40 million people by 2050. With zero net overseas migration, the population would stabilise at 27 million then fall slightly. This is the most important change that could be made to assist the Australian environment, but sadly discussing immigration is completely disallowed in mainstream Australian media. There is no need to limit birthrates - they are already sub-replacement in Australia. Just cut immigration.