4 ms·
That's only part of the equation though. People who disagree with PoVs not only want to get people suspended or banned from ubiquitous comms platforms but they
by mc32 7y ago
That's only part of the equation though. People who disagree with PoVs not only want to get people suspended or banned from ubiquitous comms platforms but they also want to doxx them and publicly shame them. I'm not talking about immediate threats of violence or disgusting vile language. But more generic points of view on various contentious topics.
But let's take your objection at face value. Let's say a certain Senator has declared the senator wants to break up some certain major tech companies and these companies disagree. Under your take they would be within their rights to suspend or ban or de-rank such candidates given they already have their websites as platforms to comms and moreover that's a non event.
- wavefunction 7y agoI don't agree with doxxing or getting people fired. I am fine with facebook/twitter/etc. de-ranking/suspending/hiding/whatever a candidate who has called for their breakup, even though I support their breakup.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI agree with it all. Here's the thing, you either support freedom of speech and expression, or you don't. Now if you do, then you have to support the nazi's right to speak and express, the abortion doctor's right to speak and express, the senator's right to speak and express, and the beggar's right to speak and express. Everyone's right must be supported. If someone wants to express themselves to my boss via boycott in an effort to get me fired, so be it. That's their right. Just as it's the nazi's right to express himself on the internet to better inform people about the tenets of his ideology. The government must have no ability to constrict either activity. It may not seem like it, but it's actually a good thing that the government can't stop any of these people from doing any of these things. If you want to get the government to disallow any boycotts of companies, then you are not really in favor of freedom of speech and expression.
- nl 7y agoHere's the thing, you either support freedom of speech and expression, or you don't. There are plenty of gradients to freedom of expression - child porn is an obvious one, and German law against Nazi speech is another, and there are things in-between like advertisements for opioids or tobacco. All you've done is restate the absolutist position, without addressing the challenges of that position which include: criminal speech, commercial speech, and the fact the restrictions on some speech have been successfully implemented without all the negative side effects that absolutists claim are inevitable.
- thenewnewguy 7y agoDo you support (or at least not want the government to ban) libel/slander? What about child pornography? Should I be able to run into an airport and yell "BOMB"? Perjury? Should it be illegal to lie in court? I also assume that if I had your real name, address, and SSN that you think it should be legal for me to post that info in this comment ('doxxing')? Now, the thing is, I mostly agree with you. However, it's plainly ridiculous to claim that someone has to fully support/oppose free speech. Make a real argument rather than just claim your opponent's position doesn't exist in order to strawman their position as 'not suporting freedom of speech and expression'.
- wavefunction 7y agoI support the rights of NAZIs or others to express themselves within the law. I don't believe that facebook should be compelled to carry their speech without being compelled to carry all legal speech. Finally, I will say I don't believe facebook or others should be compelled to carry all legal speech.
- nl 7y agoPeople who disagree with PoVs not only want to get people suspended or banned from ubiquitous comms platforms but they also want to doxx them and publicly shame them. "People" is awfully non-specific here. I support the right of companies to decide what is on their platforms but I don't want people doxxed or shamed. Let's say a certain Senator has declared the senator wants to break up some certain major tech companies and these companies disagree. Under your take they would be within their rights to suspend or ban or de-rank such candidates given they already have their websites as platforms to comms and moreover that's a non event. This is already the case - Newspapers, TV station and other publications already can refuse advertisements and frequently don't carry news they disagree with. That's why a competitive news ecosystem is incredibly important.
- jonathankoren 7y agoYou’re advocating for compelled speech and state control of private property. If you truly believe this, give me control of your account. Otherwise, you’re censoring me.