4 ms·
Our wealth has grown exponentially in recent decades but poor people still work 9 to 5 or more. Wealth is manufactured by machines not people. Some generation
by scotty79 16y ago
Our wealth has grown exponentially in recent decades but poor people still work 9 to 5 or more.
Wealth is manufactured by machines not people.
Some generation has to close the gap between how wealthy society is and how much average member of society has to work for same basic needs.
You can't make basic necessities cost always nearly same amount of work because that work thanks to technology is producing more and more wealth.
You can't keep prices of meals to be higher than recent technological wonder. Someone at some point will call bullshit on that. "My sandwich is not worth same amount of wealth as 4GB flash thumb drive. They just want me to pay this much for sandwich to keep me working because I need sandwich. I'll just pass on working, buy cheapest food and see how this works out. They don't seem to want me in their companies anyway."
This unemployed generation can be the first one to take advantage of wealth humans get from technology en masse without need to cunningly trick everyone else out of their share. They'll get their share just by being more or less human dead weight that rich won't be able to shake off because they can't kill them or even let them die because there's for the first time too many of them.
- jerf 16y ago"Our wealth has grown exponentially in recent decades but poor people still work 9 to 5 or more." Our poor people, at least in the US, are a lot more wealthy than they were several decades ago. Actually if you dig into the economics of deciding how much to work and for what, how preferences vary depending on how much of a resource you have and how cheap a lot of things are compared to decades ago, this is neither surprising nor terrible, nor really even preventable without actually going down to these people and dictating their economic preferences and proper lifestyle to them, which I at least find a repugnant idea. If you want to live a simple life with nothing from beyond 1950, no modern medicine, no modern tech gadgets, nothing beyond 1950, you can do it substantially cheaper. But it's just so easy to work a few more hours and get the modern stuff that it's the rare person who will choose to do this. If there's anything to be horrified by, it would be the cheapening of debt that has made it too easy to get buried under it vs. decades past.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOur wealth has grown exponentially in recent decades but poor people still work 9 to 5 or more. This is a myth. The poor work very little - their full time labor force participation rate is only 10% or so (this includes both the employed and unemployed). 80% of the poor don't work at all. http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2007.pdf http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2007.pdf (Before you criticize this statistic as being too simple, go see this thread where I answer many objections: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2129845 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2129845 In particular, this is not a result of the poor being disproportionately old or young.)
- lukeschlather 16y agoYou were called out for it in the previous thread, and yet you're still including children in your full-time labor force participation rate. And as near as I can tell you've conjured your "80% of the poor don't work at all." figure out of thin air. You don't adequately address the objections in the linked thread, and you're making the same oversimplifications.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou were called out for it in the previous thread, and yet you're still including children in your full-time labor force participation rate. Yes, Michaelchiasri raised this objection. He didn't bother to do the math, which showed that it has little effect. I addressed his concerns in the reply to that comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2130441 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2130441 It's very strange - you read his comment, but not my reply to it. Let me repeat one more time, since apparently you are using a browser in which links only work sporadically: Poor adults have a full time labor force participation rate of 15% (vs 73% for the nation as a whole), rather than 10% for all poor people (and 65% for all Americans). The low labor force participation rate of the poor is not caused by demographic differences. Labor force participation rates usually include everyone. If you object to this practice, take it up with the BLS. And as near as I can tell you've conjured your "80% of the poor don't work at all." figure out of thin air. That's because you didn't bother reading the first paragraph of the BLS report I linked to. I'll give you a hint: 7.5 million is about 20% of 37.3 million. Before you object that I'm including children (just like the BLS does), the figure rises to 31% if you exclude children (and to 85% for the USA as a whole).
- Tichy 16y agoI expect in the future a lot of people will be employed in computer games. It would not be so different from working for Disney World. Not sure how many support people Blizzard has, but it is a shame that doing real business is usually outlawed in most MMORPGs.