4 ms·
Branding isn't a very logical science; so sure they probably should. Them and the GNU Image Manipulation Program, which has 100% lost users because of the stupi
by roenxi 7y ago
Branding isn't a very logical science; so sure they probably should. Them and the GNU Image Manipulation Program, which has 100% lost users because of the stupid name.
That said, we also need to be able to separate the good and bad people do. Reiser in his capacity as a programmer is really a different entity to him in his capacity as a murderer. Celebrating one is not celebrating the other.
It is the stereotypical example, but it is such a good one that it deserves to become a cliche. Fritz Haber was sufficiently evil that apparently his wife committed suicide because of him. The Haber–Bosch process is probably one of the greatest technical contributions to humanity, ever, full stop. Maybe the steam engine can compete or a handful of other things. We can't allow technical excellence to be shunned because the technician had horrible problems - the shunning lessens us all. We can afford for bad people to be remembered if the price they pay is to create something of great use.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kick 7y agoGIMP changing its name seems pointless at this point, especially because of where the conversations there led. It would have been smarter for them to argue that "gimp" is a sexual term, and therefore gross, rather than an antiquated ableist term, because the former is more common than the latter usage (which is never used). Reiser's accomplishments are already out there, there's no need to continue with his name on something he hasn't contributed a patch to in a decade, and there's literally no harm in changing the name of a program like this; it's not a binary decision between "remember the person" and "use their work," plenty of people have their work utilized despite no one knowing their name. I think that's fine.
- hakfoo 7y agoI think the "antiquated ableist" form is used for GIMP, but more as a verb than a noun. "FooCorp will gimp the 700LC with a 30-watt power limit, ensuring it won't compete with the full-performance 700.".
- shiftless 7y ago> 'Reiser's accomplishments are already out there, there's no need to continue with his name on something he hasn't contributed a patch to in a decade' He's been in prison. I doubt kernel driver writing is encouraged there. > 'there's literally no harm in changing the name of a program like this; it's not a binary decision between "remember the person" and "use their work,"' You are literally incorrect in saying there is literally no harm. The harm is this: you're engaging in the "Two Minutes Hate." I don't want to live in the kind of corrupt society that rushes out to scrub a person's name from the history books just because a skeleton is (literally) discovered in their closet. Removing Hans Reiser's name from his creation would be equally immoral to putting him to death--because among other reasons, you cannot guarantee that he is guilty with 100% certainty. I think that the name should stand, so that the community can collectively enjoy the constant whining and bitching from all corners every time the subject comes up, rather than anyone having a technical discussion about boring things like the filesystem's merits.
- strainer 7y agoI'm not convinced by the long term benefit of nitrogen fertiliser synthesis. A significant boom in food production is attributable to it but also long term degradation of agricultural soils, pollution from fertiliser run off and repression of more sustainable agriculture and food distribution options. Perhaps if it had been used to buy time for more ecological and equitable policies it would be more impressive, but it seems only to have advanced the alternative.
- shiftless 7y agoYou're right on the money. A major, growing world problem (that noone talks about, because they're too busy focusing on manufactured frauds like 'global warming') is depletion of soil micronutrients. Zinc, selenium, boron depletion are some particularly serious examples. The vast majority of the world's agricultural soil is zinc deficient, including most of US soil. This of course leads to deficiencies in our food also, with many foods in the USA being seriously depleted of nutrition, and the corresponding health effects in the populace. It's a slow-motion downward spiral, and existential crisis. I understand other nutrients like iron are deficient in some of the more serious locales. Fortification of foods with various nutrients has been tried as a stopgap measure, but this problem is only going to worsen as time goes on. The plain fact is, industrial agriculture is a dead end road, as you allude to in your comment about synthetic nitrogen fertilizer. Phosphorus (rock phosphate) is an equally major problem, in that it's used way too much, tends to wash out of the soil and cause its own pollution, and is in decreasing world supply also. Likewise, potassium is essential in large amounts for plant fruiting and flowering. There isn't really enough of it out there in good, usable, convenient forms. The only answer is to use manure fertilizer, i.e. organics, and the end of industrial farming. Not going to happen without a major disaster occurring first, because the masses aren't known for their deep thinking, and the people running the show aren't known for anything other than total selfishness, and steering nations purposely into disaster for the sake of their own power or profit. I have no idea how your post got here on a post about ReiserFS, unless it's an HN bug or something.
- bb010g 7y agoHave you heard of Glimpse Image Editor? https://glimpse-editor.org/ https://glimpse-editor.org/
- rurban 7y agoShishkinFS really? It would better, of course, but there should be different options to save it.