3 ms·
>And then there’s bloat. Web apps could open up to 10 times faster if you just simply blocked all ads. Google begs everyone to stop shooting themselves in the f
by coldtea 7y ago
>And then there’s bloat. Web apps could open up to 10 times faster if you just simply blocked all ads. Google begs everyone to stop shooting themselves in the foot with the AMP initiative—a technology solution to a problem that doesn’t need any technology, just a little bit of common sense. If you remove bloat, the web becomes crazy fast. How smart do you have to be to understand that?
If you "simply blocked all ads" the people making the pages wouldn't have the income which they maintain the pages with.
How smart do you have to be to understand that?
>We haven’t seen new OS kernels in what, 25 years? It’s just too complex to simply rewrite by now. Browsers are so full of edge cases and historical precedents by now that nobody dares to write layout engine from scratch.
Well, there's Fucsia, speaking of new kernels. And Mozilla is doing exactly that, written a new layout engine from scratch (plus a language to write it in).
(I agree with the general sentiment of the post, but the examples are often shoddy)
- lainga 7y agoWhat if the site has multiple revenue avenues, of which ads are just a part? What if the site's actually a part of the OS that I've already paid for, but which inexplicably has to be connected to the Internet and serving me ads for Candy Crush?
- coldtea 7y ago>What if the site has multiple revenue avenues, of which ads are just a part? Well, in most cases this is not the case. Subscriptions don't work but for outlets with passionate niche audiences, or for upper income targeted "high class" outlets. Which leaves most of mainstream media outlets outside. Besides those outlets where ads are peripheral to the main income streams (niche fan supported, paywalled) usually have less ads to begin with. >What if the site's actually a part of the OS that I've already paid for, but which inexplicably has to be connected to the Internet and serving me ads for Candy Crush? Well, then it doesn't really need ads.
- buboard 7y agoAds dont have to be so heavy. They load entire frameworks in ads these days.
- neilalexander 7y ago> If you "simply blocked all ads" the people making the pages wouldn't have the income which they maintain the pages with. One upon a time, adverts were just cross-linked GIF images. No iframes, no Flash, no javascript, no cookies, just images. Easy for rendering engines to show, no need to call script interpreters or to add boatloads of rubbish into the DOM. No real performance hit beyond downloading the image initially. I would quite happily return to that world.
- lazyjones 7y ago> If you "simply blocked all ads" the people making the pages wouldn't have the income which they maintain the pages with. That's how we get deliberately slow pages, articles split over multiple page loads, image slideshows and deliberately slow pages (because time spent on your site is time not spent on the competing websites). On the other hand we have pages like HN, paid for(?) using other means and built to be perfectly usable and fast. Or some CSEs where revenue comes from affiliates and CPC fees instead of ads, so they try to keep things fast too. Then we have news sites with paywalls and hopefully some day better engineered UI to read those news. People should just vote with their pockets for a better user experience, IMO.
- jodrellblank 7y agoPeople should just vote with their pockets for a better user experience, IMO. How? How can I vote with my pocket for old.reddit.com instead of new reddit UI? How can I vote for another site which is different, when the main draw of Reddit is the number of people on there? How can I vote for an instant messenger which works the way I want, when the people I talk to aren't using it because the people they talk to aren't using it? How can I pay for a faster Windows 10 where the start menu works every time I press the start button and updates install in the time it takes to copy the data to SSD and no longer? That option isn't on the market.
- drpixie 7y agoI'll vote for the old version - fix the bugs and DON'T add new features. One app, one task.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> If you "simply blocked all ads" the people making the pages wouldn't have the income which they maintain the pages with. I agree with regards to ads specifically; that's why I don't use an ad blocker. But the problem is so much greater than ads. Ads aren't what's slowing down the new gmail, or Slack.