7 ms·
The problem with endless expansion is it requires stability over very long time scales. Sending a probe to another solar system is hardly enough. If you can s
by Retric 7y ago
The problem with endless expansion is it requires stability over very long time scales. Sending a probe to another solar system is hardly enough. If you can send a ship say 100 light years from your home planet that’s 2,000+ repetitions of terraforming and colonizing a planet, building up an industrial base, then sending ships to every planet in reach. Under ideal conditions that might take 10,000 years assuming everything went well so you need 20 million years to colonize our galaxy. But, assuming everything goes well for 20 million years and colonization continues to be a priority seems unlikely.
It’s very possible to reach a wall where zero teraformable planets are within reach of your ships. For large civilizations that’s unlikely to totally block expansion, but it might make the path very convoluted thus increasing total time by a rather extreme factor.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoCulture rot will kill you quicker than density of colonisable planets. The transport layer is the easy part. Content integrity is a much harder problem. All of your probes and colony ships have to reproduce the source culture - or some viable subservient spin-off - with 100% accuracy. This explicitly means 100% reproductive success of all features, especially the politics and economics, with no errors. For a successful colony, stability and conformity have to be maintained for long periods - centuries at a minimum, perhaps even millions of years. And of course this assumes the source culture is stable in the first place. Otherwise you're just seeding the galaxy with potential competitors, and/or setting up some kind of galactic Battle Royale. I'm bemused by the suggestion the first option is actually possible. The second seems more likely, but might not be considered a success in the sense of creating a stable galaxy-spanning civ capable of common strategic goals.
- andrewflnr 7y ago> All of your probes and colony ships have to reproduce the source culture - or some viable subservient spin-off - with 100% accuracy. The only thing that needs to be preserved is the desire to build more colonies. I'll grant even that's a stretch, but demanding 100% cultural fidelity is silly for discussing the Fermi paradox.
- maxander 7y agoNot just the desire, but also the ability- the cultural context for an industrial base potentially far more powerful than what we have. That may be extremely difficult to sustain over such timescales.
- wongarsu 7y agoEven on earth we had plenty of colonies rebelling against the founding nation, gaining independence and becoming a serious competitor. Britain might conclude that they would be better off today had they never colonized America and India. Repeat this pattern often enough over millennia and it seems plausible that an entire race might become very cautious with forming permanent colonies.
- jdsully 7y agoBritain had to colonize the Americas or France and Spain would have without them. It would take another 200 years for the empire to fully collapse. It’s hard to say colonization was a net negative just because of America’s independence. Further it seems much less likely the populace would be so willing to send aide to Britain during WWI if it weren’t for the cultural similarities. If instead Spain had colonized the US it seems very likely the country would have remained neutral as Spain did.
- ben_w 7y agoSpain did colonise much of what is now the USA. That’s why it’s “Los Angeles” and “San Francisco”. https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Imperios_Español_y_Portugués_1790.svg https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Imperios_Español_y...
- krapp 7y agoAnd Louisiana was French.
- wongarsu 7y agoMy gut feeling would say colonization was a net positive to Britain, but it's hard to say. It's just too big of a what-if. The US would have likely gone to France, their main rival at the time. On the other hand Britain spend a lot of resources on their US colonies, both building them and fighting France in America. Who knows what else they could have with those resources. It's not just the US either. India was a profitable colony at the time but might turn out to be a major detriment to Britain overall, both as a source of cheap skilled labor and as a powerful nation of their own. Who knows what would have happened without the British. A lot of the borders in the Middle East are drawn by Britain as part of their WWI mandates/colonies, and the problems from how those borders were drawn spill over into Britain (yes, it's not the only problem in the Middle East by a long shot, but it's one of them). I still think overall Britain came out ahead (just look at Hong Kong for what cultural influence can do), but it's not hard to imagine how colonization might be seen as a net negative if a few times things turned out even slightly worse.
- mc32 7y agoDoes intelligence and innovation predict cultural change? Is there evidence that this is prevalent in other species?
- phs318u 7y ago> For a successful colony, stability and conformity have to be maintained for long periods - centuries at a minimum, perhaps even millions of years. The number one attribute that needs to be preserved is the disinclination to blow each other to smithereens. I suspect self-destruction (to a level where technological progress is setback millenia) is a common enough occurrence that would occur well-before FTL becomes a possibility. I also suspect (despite decades of reading SF and my own wishes to the contrary), that the kinds of attributes that encourage exploration, expansion and risk-taking, are also somehow linked to aggression and violence - "might makes right".
- wruza 7y agoImplying culture as we have it may be a stretch too big for other species. Who may form single integral units like a zerg swarm. Yeah, it is a game fiction, but you got the idea. Why do cells split and grow with no complaints about their life? Because it is the way they are, and if they were not, they simply didn’t. What is their strategic goal? A counterargument to this is that swarm may be not intelligent enough to make it, but my point is that our lifeform’s culture is not the only one possible, and the culture as we have it may be not a requirement. (Not that it is any sort of beauty anyway. Apart from particular individuals, it is mostly disgusting and ineffective.) Also, a neighbor idea of the scientific progression in thousand years from now on doesn’t account for an artificial biology progression, like the same humans in 1k years would do unimaginable things. Would they be still individual humans? Personally I don’t think it is more than juvenile civilization’s tunnel vision illusions.
- drran 7y agoIf you can create ship, which can travel for generations, why you need to colonize anything? For second generation, their home will be starship, not a planet.
- ncmncm 7y agoThis. Planets are incubators for civilizations.
- est31 7y ago> All of your probes and colony ships have to reproduce the source culture - or some viable subservient spin-off - with 100% accuracy. Any empire/political system/civilization needs some means of holding it together. Traditionally this is done through armies. As our transport technology has gotten better, our ability to move armies around the world has increased and with it the ability to control large economic systems without them breaking apart. Nowadays we have a globe-spanning economy. However, time scales of interstellar travel are so big that cultural change is much faster than the method to build a colony. By the time that nuclear bomb ship has arrived at the other planet, we might have changed our mind threefold. In fact, already if you send a generational spaceship to a star 100 ly away to reach its destination in a thousand years, by the time you receive message from their arrival, both their as our language will have evolved by 1100 years. So yeah you are right, cultural decay (or rather "change") is a big problem. Currently our governments are run by humans with all the human failings. Instability, corruption, etc are components of the governments due to our human nature. You are right that it would be hard for human run governments to colonize the galaxy as due to the light speed limit, we can't achieve transport scales needed for a human-run civilization. However, we won't need humans to run the governments. In the future we'll be able to engineer and build extremely intelligent AI systems with multiple layers of error checking to withstand decay for trillions of years. You think that sounds undoable? Check how many cells humans are made out of and how well they work together for decades. The unsolvable political problem will just be turned into a solvable engineering problem. Those AI systems would run key parts of the governments and economies themselves (entirely without needing human help) and enforce a set of basic rules like preventing nuclear weapons, bioweapons, torture, etc alongside ensuring they are the most powerful factor in those places, i.e. are able to fend off any kind of attack. Otherwise they won't interfere with human matters and let humans govern themselves with the human imperfections. Basically, they'd provide the "galactic federation layer" and ensure peace through their programming. Some factors of their programming could be changed by the human population, but others, like preventing nuclear weapons, couldn't. So even if the humans wanted, they wouldn't be able to wage catastrophic war with the neighbour planet, or at least specific types of war (allowing trade war but not allowing nuclear war). Even if the risk for interplanetary war is just 0.1% per year, over millennia that's a large number and interplanetary war can have major consequences. To the present reader, those AI systems probably seem weird and dystopic, but I think we are already evolving towards them. Already, many parts of the governments and economies of various countries are being automated. One day in the future the automation will have minimized human involvement enough so that you can think about von Neumann probes. The first people to develop AI ran governments will probably be the dictatorships who want absolute control and micromanagement (single-operator government). But in general, the systems are more efficient than chaotic systems, and with increasing perfection of the technology, once a system is a dictatorship, it probably won't change back to a non-dictatorship without outside interference. It's important to eventually remove human control from them as otherwise over the millions of years, eventually someone will figure out how to flip the switch and create dictatorships. So it's kinda important to get the "right" set of rules into these computers. Already building these computers is a huge project that would take a long time to get it right. But it's an easier task for humans to do than running an intergalactic civilization. Also note that those systems don't have to necessarily deal with humans in their current form. They could also deal with human simulations uploaded to the cloud and the systems would just provide the resources to run that cloud. The "real world" might become utterly uninteresting to humans.
- pfdietz 7y agoNo, endless expansion does not require stability over very long time scales. It just requires that each colony produce, on average, at least one successful daughter colony. It's not even necessary for the colony to have any cultural continuity between when it is created and when those descendant colonies are created.
- svieira 7y agoThere is a very interesting series by John C. Wright called _The Eschaton Sequence_ that explores this idea of stability over long time scales this in great detail (builds up through K7 civilizations over the course of the work) https://us.macmillan.com/series/theeschatonsequence/ https://us.macmillan.com/series/theeschatonsequence/
- gadjo95 7y agoI think you could take some ideas from the Foundation Series of Asimov (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundation_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundation_series)