5 ms·
> Seriously there is NO WAY in the world an UBI will cover the rent - even the rent alone - in any place where it makes sense starting a business. You can get
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Seriously there is NO WAY in the world an UBI will cover the rent - even the rent alone - in any place where it makes sense starting a business.
You can get a one bedroom in Austin for less than $800/month, to say nothing of arrangements that involve roommates or shared facilities or couples who would then have a second UBI.
> I would imagine an UBI will be mostly used by people to exclude themselves from active workforce to "retire" in low-cost destinations. Because that will be the only thing it will really allow doing.
You're forgetting the possibility for supplemental income. Combine the UBI with a part time job and you could live just outside of New York City and spend the other half of your time on the business for as long as it takes until it makes enough for you to quit the part time job.
There is also a whole lot of work that really doesn't care about location at all. You can do software development in Kansas if you want to, as well as anything else that involves selling your product over the internet.
> Say you impose a super huge 30% income tax (anything above that will cause a revolt in the middle classes, and mass exodus in upper classes)
The marginal rate isn't what causes revolts, it's the effective rate. Middle class people don't care about paying $12,000 in tax if they also get a $12,000 UBI. Upper middle class people aren't going to revolt over a difference between the two of an amount similar to what they pay already for the existing welfare system we would no longer need.
And the whole point of using VAT is that billionaires and international corporations can't avoid it.
- gonational 7y ago> You can get a one bedroom in Austin for less than $800/month ... because there is currently no program in Austin whereby residents each get $1,000 of free money month.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoTrue, if only people in Austin got a $1000 UBI then many people would want to move there for the UBI and rents there would go up by supply and demand. But if everybody in the country gets the same UBI then people are going to move from where to where exactly? If the answer is from places with higher housing costs to places with lower housing costs, I think you're going to find that there's more than enough empty space in the middle of nowhere to satisfy all of that demand without significant rent increases.
- gonational 7y agoYou’ve misunderstood. I’m not suggesting that the rent would go up because of the increased demand for a living in Austin. I am suggesting that the rent would go up because everybody has at least $1,000 per month of free money, on top of whatever income they earned.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoBy what mechanism does that cause the rent to go up? The entire reason people are setting up shop in Austin is that it's so much less expensive than San Francisco. If landlords in Austin tried to raise rents then people would go to Kansas City or Buffalo or Louisville. Some of the landlords would figure out that it's more profitable to have tenants at lower rents than higher rents and no tenants.
- gonational 7y agoPerhaps the reason is not obvious because of the scale, so lets exaggerate the numbers to make it more obvious: If everyone in the US was given $1 million per month, do you think that rent in Austin would go up in absolute terms? If yes, by what mechanism can you imagine this effect is caused? If no, I don’t know what to say.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe reason it goes up if you give everyone $1M/month is that $1M/month of money for everyone in the country doesn't actually exist. That's ~$330T/month. You couldn't collect that amount in taxes because nobody has it to collect it from; or if you did then nobody would actually be getting $1M/month since they'd just all be paying ~$1M/month in taxes to fund it. The implied way to do it is, of course, by printing the money. Which would indeed cause inflation in not just rents but everything. But how does that apply to the real case when the money doesn't come from printing it?
- maxsilver 7y ago> If landlords in Austin tried to raise rents then people would go to Kansas City or Buffalo or Louisville. In the real world, most people can't just relocate their life on a whim, and the majority of citizens are more-or-less locked into a specific area for long periods of time, for a whole bunch of reasons. (Employer, Spouse, Children, Extended Family, Networks, etc) It's not impossible to relocate or anything. But most people can't do so, and the few who can usually can't do so easily. It's not like window shopping for cars or clothes, these markets are effectively soft-Monopolies. If landlords in Austin raised rents, most people would just have to eat it, unless it got to dystopian levels that forced them to relocate.
- enraged_camel 7y agoYou're making the mistake of assuming that rents are dependent purely on renters' ability to pay them. Whereas the fact of the matter is that the market is driven largely by housing supply and demand, as it always has been. A $1,000 monthly check is unlikely to move the numbers much.