8 ms·
Why would they stop at thousands of colonies? What is it preventing the colonies from themselves creating colonies? Also, realize that a colony in the system
by pfdietz 7y ago
Why would they stop at thousands of colonies? What is it preventing the colonies from themselves creating colonies? Also, realize that a colony in the system of another star will move away from the originating system. In our neck of the galactic woods the rate of separation is typically about 10^-4 c, so in a million years they'd separate by 100 light years.
- ohazi 7y agoI think you could change these guesses to be almost whatever you wanted with similar results. We would not observe anything different unless one of them actually flew to our solar system and tried to contact us. That's how bad we are at detecting distant life.
- lonelappde 7y agoI reckon astronomers would find anything that entered our solar system and stayed in some solar orbit.
- ohazi 7y agoTrue, but without radio transmissions, I bet we would spend decades arguing about whether it was actually an asteroid and a measurement anomaly. We can't really distinguish a rock from a Battlestar at those distances without physically flying over to look.
- close04 7y agoAt this point we're relying almost exclusively on radio waves to detect any traces of intelligent life out there. So whether they're building moon stations in their neighborhood, or sending rockets here and there, we'd still look for their transmissions to identify their existence and to tell them apart from a random natural event. And while intelligent life may exist on a planet for millions of years, their window of actually emitting something into the void in a manner we can detect with our tech today [0] will probably be a lot shorter than that. This gives us a relatively tiny and limited visibility window into the history of life out there. Unless we manage to sync our window perfectly with theirs we'll never know they existed. [0] https://www.xkcd.com/638/ https://www.xkcd.com/638/
- K0SM0S 7y agoCompounded by the fact that advanced space communications would likely rely mostly on laser beams[1], whose efficiency and general design fits much better with that environment and its infrastructure. Unless pointing directly at your instrument (good luck, what are the odds?) and missed by the intended receiver, the beam will never reach you anyway. [1] Particularly if your operation is covert, discrete, observational, non-disruptive: you'd want to avoid signaling your presence in all directions, while wasting 99.99% of that energy away from your intended receiver. It's just military efficiency, a photon-VPN so to speak, that you'd need to "physically MitM" to hack.
- aruggirello 7y agoYou really mean anything at least comet/asteroid sized, passing within the inner Solar System with a speed and an albedo that would make it stand out against the background of stars (reaching at least say, apparent magnitude 8-10). Also, note that it should be found near the ecliptic plane, to improve the chances of detection. Now, exchange that for a black-ish ship a few hundred meters sized, quietly coming from Vega to visit say, Saturn. Nobody would probably notice it coming and going, despite Saturn being one of the most popular targets of the entire sky.
- K0SM0S 7y agoYou'd be surprised how much stuff there is just in our neighborhood that we're unable to catch, yet. We mostly track dangerous stuff, the big enough - fast enough to destroy us, and we now have probably in the 6-7 figures objects tracked in the inner solar system. That's it. Elusive 9th planets and other major 'quests' are shots in the dark so far, mostly — read accounts on why they target some region of the sky, how narrow our observational capabilities are as we can only point to a very specific direction at a time with each telescope, etc. So, some alien unmanned probe the likes of Voyager in large orbit around the Sun? Yeah, no chance in hell we'd detect that by random chance, we'd have to seriously upgrade our space infrastructure to even pretend 'monitoring' our close vicinity, let alone post-Jovian space. And we have virtually no knowledge of about half the distance between interstellar medium and the Sun, that's how limited we are to even modeling the closest star systems. Edit: apparently double-post with aruggirello; I agree with him.
- Beldin 7y agoTo underline this point: we shot a red tesla into space about 2 years ago [1]. We cannot detect it any more. We'd need a telescope with a mirror of 15km to see it. Due to uncertainties accumulating, even if we'd had a scope like that, we'd probably not be able to point it exactly enough. Oh, and that thing is mostly between the orbits of Mars and earth - much smaller search space than "the entire solar system" [1] https://www.whereisroadster.com/ https://www.whereisroadster.com/
- Aperocky 7y agoYou’re very mistaken. We still regularly find 300ft boulders in _Earth Orbit_. And routinely find city sized asteroid in asteroid belt and state sized minor planet in Kuiper belt. Suggesting that a ship can be found as long as it’s in Solar Orbit is an extremely misinformed opinion.
- pfdietz 7y agoWe have never found a 300 ft boulder in Earth Orbit. Perhaps you mean in a solar orbit near the Earth?
- emiliobumachar 7y agoSorry to pile on, and I don't think you deserved the downvotes, but I'd like to point out there may be an undiscovered planet in the solar system. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Nine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Nine
- hnuser123456 7y agoThere may also/instead be an undiscovered primordial black hole in the solar system. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/09/planet-nine-may-actually-be-black-hole https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/09/planet-nine-may-actu...
- krapp 7y agoIt's entirely possible that a civilization would stop at thousands of colonies because, they no longer have the technological capacity (having regressed for whatever reason) or the desire to continue further. It's also possible that the odds against successfully expanding beyond a single colony are so great that no one ever makes it to a thousand.
- pfdietz 7y agoALL the colonies regress? And stay regressed? Forever? How is that supposed to work?
- krapp 7y agoTechnological civilizations are fragile - it's more likely that they collapse than remain and progress exponentially forever.
- merpnderp 7y agoIs this true? Ours is far less fragile than at any point in history. Our only long term threat is nuclear war.
- krapp 7y agoWe're on the edge of a global environmental collapse, and most of our civilization's knowledge is being kept on the internet of all places. Also, we were able to land men on the moon 50 years ago, and now that knowledge is basically gone, and the tapes lost, and people are starting to believe the Earth is flat and that the moon landing never even happened. Meanwhile, we can still read tax records from ancient Sumeria because they were carved into clay. Complex systems are always more fragile than simple ones. It seems to me like we've been standing on a house of cards for the last century.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoOur worst long-term threat is our inability to coordinate our efforts in order to save ourselves. This test is not graded, it's pass-fail.
- astrobe_ 7y ago> Why would they stop at thousands of colonies Why would we stop at a hundred of colonies? A couple of observations: - in rich countries, the trend is that the birth rate is declining, the population gets "older". There seems to be a link between wealth and birth rate. Even if space conquest gives us a lot of resources, if that trend persists, the lack of people will be the limiting factor. - there are only really two reasons to go out: curiosity and making sure that a stellar-scale catastrophic event doesn't wipe out our civilization. A bunch of colonies "far enough" from Sol achieves this. And probably after visiting a dozen of systems, the next one will look like one of the previously visited.
- akiselev 7y agoThe curiosity aspect might be generational. After growing for enough generations, the critical mass of "curious" individuals - people who are persecuted, who don't fit into the prevailing culture, or who are just really bored - might be there for exploring outwards, even if it had already been done many time before.
- K0SM0S 7y agoThat's the general story of humanity. From the first settlements to the ever-away "final frontier" — somewhere between Moon and Mars as we speak. There is no doubt in the mind of any historian, psychologist or sociologist, IMHO, that we'll probably keep doing this for as long as we are "homo sapiens sapiens". That should be ~50K years total based on past mutations (iirc? anyhow much bigger than recorded history), so I figure we can take curiosity for granted as a civilization trait for next-gen politics. Like, lots of gens. ;-)
- astrobe_ 7y agoSince I'm no historian, psychologist, etc. I have always believed that great migrations were caused by local population pressure - id est too few resources for too many people. Even Columbus stumbled upon Americas because he was looking for a better trade route.
- Retric 7y agoThe problem with endless expansion is it requires stability over very long time scales. Sending a probe to another solar system is hardly enough. If you can send a ship say 100 light years from your home planet that’s 2,000+ repetitions of terraforming and colonizing a planet, building up an industrial base, then sending ships to every planet in reach. Under ideal conditions that might take 10,000 years assuming everything went well so you need 20 million years to colonize our galaxy. But, assuming everything goes well for 20 million years and colonization continues to be a priority seems unlikely. It’s very possible to reach a wall where zero teraformable planets are within reach of your ships. For large civilizations that’s unlikely to totally block expansion, but it might make the path very convoluted thus increasing total time by a rather extreme factor.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoCulture rot will kill you quicker than density of colonisable planets. The transport layer is the easy part. Content integrity is a much harder problem. All of your probes and colony ships have to reproduce the source culture - or some viable subservient spin-off - with 100% accuracy. This explicitly means 100% reproductive success of all features, especially the politics and economics, with no errors. For a successful colony, stability and conformity have to be maintained for long periods - centuries at a minimum, perhaps even millions of years. And of course this assumes the source culture is stable in the first place. Otherwise you're just seeding the galaxy with potential competitors, and/or setting up some kind of galactic Battle Royale. I'm bemused by the suggestion the first option is actually possible. The second seems more likely, but might not be considered a success in the sense of creating a stable galaxy-spanning civ capable of common strategic goals.
- andrewflnr 7y ago> All of your probes and colony ships have to reproduce the source culture - or some viable subservient spin-off - with 100% accuracy. The only thing that needs to be preserved is the desire to build more colonies. I'll grant even that's a stretch, but demanding 100% cultural fidelity is silly for discussing the Fermi paradox.
- StanislavPetrov 7y agoWhy does everyone assume alien races would want to spread out and colonize the universe? Perhaps we should consider the possibility that the insatiable desire to constantly expand like a virus is coupled with the tendency for civilizations to destroy themselves through warfare. Maybe civilizations with advanced technology also have advanced philosophy and are content to merely exist and be content? Why do we take it as a given that aliens would be anything like us, with the same desires and tendencies we have? Its fine to consider that as a possibility, but there are many unknowns we should acknowledge.
- randallsquared 7y ago> Why does everyone assume alien races would want to spread out and colonize the universe? ...because organisms (and presumably cultures) without that characteristic wouldn't be as numerous as otherwise identical organisms which do have that drive, in a given environment.
- StanislavPetrov 7y agoMaybe we don't see them because they aren't as numerous, because they aren't interested in spreading out. Maybe the "drive" to spread out and colonize the universe or the cultures that would encourage that frame of thought are linked to a propensity to wage war or other some other counterproductive behavior that results in extinction before achieving the ability to colonize the stars.