2 ms·
I don't see how it would have helped anyone if he had just moved on with his life and not downloaded the album. Isn't the usual justification for intellectual p
by _delirium 16y ago
I don't see how it would have helped anyone if he had just moved on with his life and not downloaded the album. Isn't the usual justification for intellectual property that it rewards the creator? If you compare the "download the album" and the "move on and don't listen to the album at all" alternatives, the creator gets no reward either way, so it seems ethically neutral--- contrary to the case where he could've paid the creator and instead chose not to, where the creator actually loses out on a sale.
Now perhaps you could say that it's unethical because if he hadn't downloaded this album, he would've paid for someone else's, so he's not stealing from the creator of this album, but indirectly from the creators of other albums that he didn't buy instead. But that seems like an argument that proves too much; in that scenario, is it also unethical to listen to CC-licensed music, because doing so steals business from non-CC-licensed music?
- mhb 16y agoSo what if you don't see what the motivations are of the people who own the content or the distribution network? Can you imagine a world in which those people are making decisions whose justification they don't wish to share with you? Maybe they've done A/B testing on the way to release content to maximize their profit or some other good that they value and think that revealing the results to you would affect the outcome.
- _delirium 16y agoI suppose I don't see that as part of the copyright social contract, though some people do argue for a complete ability to control (for a temporary period of time) the use of a work. The model of copyright that makes sense to me is intended to provide a mechanism for creators to be compensated for published work, i.e. to prevent readers/listeners/etc. from bypassing the paid distribution channel. The justification is that if everyone is funneled towards the paid distribution channel, that will provide funds and encouragement for more such work to be created and published. But if the work isn't being published (or isn't being published to a particular audience), then that side of the social contract isn't being upheld, so the purpose of copyright (to encourage such material to be produced and made available) isn't being fulfilled, and therefore I don't see copyright as ethically applicable (or ethically applicable to that audience). I guess a shorter version of the obligation I feel users of a work have is: Compensate the creator, if they'll take your money.
- mhb 16y agoInvoking copyright just obfuscates the straightforward moral question. Someone has produced something which they wish to sell on whatever terms they make up. The decision of a potential consumer is to agree to the terms or not. If you and the musician are face-to-face and she says you can have an MP3 of her music for $1000, it's not right to take it if you think it's too expensive.
- _delirium 16y agoI disagree; I don't believe there is any moral right to "sell on whatever terms they make up". I do think copyright is justified in an ethical sense, as a social contract that encourages the production of more creative works. (I was speaking in the ethical sense; my comment was certainly not accurate as a legal analysis of current U.S. copyright law.) But I think the proper way to analyze ethical issues involving creative works is, therefore, to see who is upholding or violating the social contract that we call "copyright". I don't think there's any separate moral issue, and it certainly isn't a form of property (due to being non-rivalrous).
- steveklabnik 16y agoYou're oversimplifying by applying physical property thinking to this. I and a musician are face-to-face, and she says I'm not allowed to listen to this particular waveform unless I hand her $1000. It's not right for her to claim monopoly over this non-rivalrous good because she feels like she owns it.