5 ms·
That's a total oversimplification of two very different auto markets. Germans relate to their cars very differently than do americans, including on environment
by sandworm101 7y ago
That's a total oversimplification of two very different auto markets. Germans relate to their cars very differently than do americans, including on environmental issues.
For one, Germany has a much more well-developed public transport network. An eco-minded German is much more likely to park their car and take a bus/train etc. So if you take the bus/train regularly, you don't feel so bad about having a diesel car for use when you need it. Contrast that with Tesla's home turf: California. Public transport there is ludicrously bad. The car is king. So, lacking proper public transport options, the eco-minded californian will consider electric options much more readily.
I have never met a Tesla owner on a bus or train in north america. I have met many German BMW/Merc/Porche owners on European trains. I have met plenty of Tesla owners on aircraft, going on their holidays. I do laugh at the irony of all those Teslas parked at SFO. How many of their owners are flying business class or better? How many of them have extensive solar panels on their houses? Electric cars in north america are more of a fashion statement than they are in europe.
Another big market difference: Engine size. Germans prefer smaller engines and make them work. Americans prefer larger engines that putter along at 10% capacity. Another: transmission preferences. US = 98% automatic, Germany = <30%. The markets are so different that any direct comparison can only happen after extensive couching of every statistic.
- option 7y agowhile either extreme is bad, I find it much more comfortable in CA vs Germany. Have you ever been in people traffic in subway during rush hours? Throw in flu season on the mix. I’ll take car traffic any day over that. Electric self driving cars (land a lot of related infrastructure sounds much more compelling then anything Germany or Europe has to offer right now
- sandworm101 7y agoI have. The people traffic in the US is far far worse. Hygiene matters more than numbers. I cannot stand the spitting, something that most of the western world made illegal for good reason. I see Americans spit on the subway platform in SF every time I go there. I've never seen that in germany/france/UK. I'm far more afraid of catching something from that single american spitting on the ground than any crowded German rail station. I would consider a Tesla just to avoid disease at BART stations, a balance that would be a non-issue in germany. Again, two very different markets.
- option 7y agoSF is hygiene disaster. I’m 100% with you on this. It is very, very sad what has happened to SF over the last decade :(
- nlp_1 7y agooh boy, if you're worried about the spit. You should throw away all the shoes you've worn in SF. There's poop on it.
- sandworm101 7y agoIronically, poop isn't so bad. You can get water-borne illnesses from poop but you get the nasty air-borne stuff (ie TB, measles) via saliva. Water-borne diseases can be avoided by drinking clean water. Air-borne diseases cannot be so easily avoided.
- BubRoss 7y agoHave you gotten a lot of TB and Measles while riding the subway?
- jcims 7y ago>I have never met a Tesla owner on a bus or train in north america. >I would consider a Tesla just to avoid disease at BART stations, a balance that would be a non-issue in germany. Ding ding ding!!!
- micheljansen 7y agoIf you move over one country and look at The Netherlands, you’ll see a lot of the same things hold true there, yet Tesla (and other EVs) are wildly successful there. Key differences are EV tax breaks and excellent public charging infrastructure in a smaller, denser country making EV ownership practical and economic. The same people absolutely do drive EVs and use public transport, usually combined with some bicycle rides mixed in.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> a smaller, denser country making EV ownership practical and economic. Ya. I'm in Canada. The total opposite. Vast stretches of wilderness between cities. Bitter winter cold. Darkness. And in many area less than reliable grid power[1]. If we are listed countries by the practicality of electric vehicles, Canada, Russia, Australia and Mongolia are in leagues of their own. [1] We are having a windstorm in my area atm. Power has dropped out twice in the last few hours, only for a few minutes at a time, but at this time last year we lost power for three days. https://www.bchydro.com/power-outages/app/outage-map.html https://www.bchydro.com/power-outages/app/outage-map.html 250ish different outages means about 35,000 people are without grid power in BC at the moment.
- mymythisisthis 7y agoDowntown Toronto needs to ban cars. Sure trucks are needed all over rural Ontario, but not downtown.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 7y agoI assume you mean SUVs, not the cargo-carrying semi trailers. Banning "trucks" is like banning assault rifles: you instantly get into a huge debate about what is and isn't an truck. Is it to be be size? Weight? (Teslas are heavy) Passenger capacity? Whatever definition you use, the results will not be what you want. It's like when london allowed electric vehicles to skip paying the congestion charge. They thought this was going to benefit the drivers of small electric cars. Then came all the electric sports/super cars. Now Jeremy Clarkson in his 200mph electric hypercar doesn't pay the tax while James May in a tiny fiat panda does.
- Cougher 7y ago"I have never met a Tesla owner on a bus or train in north america. I have met many German BMW/Merc/Porche owners on European trains." There is so much wrong with drawing conclusions from these experiences, which itself is "a total oversimplification of two very different auto markets" and public transport markets as you yourself have noted, in addition to the fact that Tesla owners are still a very small minority of car owners which is reason enough that you'd be unlikely to meet one on a train. "I do laugh at the irony of all those Teslas parked at SFO . . . Electric cars in north america are more of a fashion statement than they are in europe." You seem to be skewing your view of EVs in America toward Tesla owners so that you can skewer Tesla owners.