4 ms·
a) The great majority of the population who perceives a salary not needing to file taxes. In the United States, and many other nations, the vast majority of ta
by reaperducer 7y ago
a) The great majority of the population who perceives a salary not needing to file taxes.
In the United States, and many other nations, the vast majority of taxes aren't collected from payroll. If that was the case, things would be easy. But there are hundreds of other ways that taxes are collected, and they vary from person to person.
More importantly, taxes aren't exclusively about revenue generation. They're used to encourage people to do or not do things: Save money, invest money, buy houses, have babies, buy cars, add solar panels, and thousands of other things.
There are plenty of people who shout "flat tax!" whenever this topic comes up. But they're mostly people who have only led simple lives where the IRS only touches them on their paycheck, or who don't understand the full range of how taxes are used.
- naniwaduni 7y ago> They're used to encourage people to do or not do things: They might be better if this were the goal if people could actual interpret what they're being encouraged to do!
- syshum 7y agoOr people do understand how taxes are used and fundementaly disagree that taxes should be used for those purposes Taxes sole purpose should be to collect money to provide services, Nothing else they should not be used to socially engineer the society the way the government sees fit, that is not a free society or a functioning democracy/republic at that point
- Sabinus 7y agoAustralia gives tax cuts if you have a family with children. (Family tax benefit part A and B). Do you think that's unacceptable social engineering?
- layoutIfNeeded 7y agoThat’s ok, because by having children you provide a service to the state (i.e. ensuring its existence in the long run).
- TeMPOraL 7y agoBut this argument can be trivially extended to all other "social engineering" taxes. Vice taxes make you drink or smoke less? You're reducing state's expenses on healthcare, law enforcement and social services. Tax benefits for installing photovoltaics or buying electric cars? You're helping to improve the quality of life, again saving state on healthcare, and in the future, on various forms of crisis management once the climate issues start taking their toll in full. (FWIW, I'm generally in favor of this kind of "social engineering" when done by democracies.)
- syshum 7y agoYes, Why should a person the choose not to have children be punished by the state with higher taxes for their choice?
- anoncake 7y agoIf having children benefits society those who choose to do that should be rewarded.
- syshum 7y agoSee I am an individualist, not a Collectivist, I believe the only role government should have is protect my individual human rights from other individuals Not to pick and choose what is "best" for society, governments have a terrible track record at picking winners and losers What is the saying, if left of to government we would have the best iron lungs money could buy but we would not have a polio vaccine
- anoncake 7y agoA democracy doesn't stop being democratic because you don't like the outcome. If a democratic government performs social engineering, the people socially engineers itself.