4 ms·
All true, although one of the things that bothers me is that even if you can read music you to need to understand the historical context in order to play a piec
by tomcam 7y ago
All true, although one of the things that bothers me is that even if you can read music you to need to understand the historical context in order to play a piece properly. For example, you would play a Bach piece with a lighter touch and less legato than you would a Beethoven piece with the same notes. And of course a jazz musician looking at music from a certain area is almost certainly going to play what look like eighth notes with swing, which is a completely different feel and should actually be notated differently as well.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoThe notation is shorthand for the composers' intent, not a computer program to perfectly reconstruct the music every time. Ambiguity is a feature, not a bug.
- skywhopper 7y agoNot sure why this bothers you. Musical notation is, by necessity, a greatly simplified representation of the intended performance. Not only that, but the composers themselves well understand that the interpretation of their notation is itself an artistic activity that is independent from the musical notation they write. There are thousands of recorded performances of any particular Bach or Beethoven work, every one different, sometimes very very much different. And none of them are “wrong”. We certainly don’t know for sure how Bach’s and Beethoven’s works were performed in their own days—there’s uncertainty over tuning, dynamics, and tempo, to say nothing of stylistic details—but we do know that the instruments they had available were very different, and yet their works are still great today, even though we can never reproduce what they were “supposed” to sound like.
- zozbot234 7y ago"Swing" was known even in the Baroque era, actually. It was called notes inégales (which literally means "non-equal notes"), while playing eighths "straight" would be called notes égales ("equal notes"). Some of these other variations are inherent in how notation has evolved over time - by the time of Beethoven, lots of indications would be written into the piece to try and convey how it should be played. You don't get that kind of thing from Bach-era scores, and sometimes people play them a bit too mechanically as a result. It's very much a matter of finding the right balance for every subgenre or tradition.
- meowface 7y agoThis is why I tend to prefer "auteur" music; music composed, arranged, produced, performed, and ideally even mixed by the same person/small group of people. It's a shame we'll never get to hear Beethoven or Mozart playing their pieces themselves, in their intended locations and with their preferred instruments and seats and such. I suspect it'd sound much better than any other performer who's interpreted their work.
- jacquesm 7y agoThere are pianoroll recordings of Rachmaninoff and also some very precious early recordings: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBx-tr1FDvY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBx-tr1FDvY