9 ms·
Perhaps not a "positive" story, but legit dmcas do happen from time to time and seem reasonable enough to me (or at least reasonable enough in a world with copy
by bawolff 7y ago
Perhaps not a "positive" story, but legit dmcas do happen from time to time and seem reasonable enough to me (or at least reasonable enough in a world with copyrights). For example look at this list of dmca notices against wikipedia that wmf actually thought were valid
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Office_actions/DMCA_notices https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Office_actions/DM... most of them seem reasonable enough to me. (IANAL)
The problem is no effective oversight. Laws without oversight are going to be obviously abused. The DMCA is like if police were responsible to ensure their own warrents are valid.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> The problem is no effective oversight. Laws without oversight are going to be obviously abused. Lots of laws are privately enforced. DMCA doesn't have to be different. If you file a false DMCA claim, even if unknowingly, you should be liable for damages. To the platform, for their cost in dealing with your B.S. An to the content owner, for their costs (including time and attorneys fees) and any lost or interrupted revenue. I'd also make such judgements eligible for summary judgment, provided the damages are less than e.g. $25,000.
- aaronax 7y agoI believe similar ramifications should apply to the uploader in the case of a valid DMCA complaint to make this fair. There are some logistical issues with enforcing that. I admit that upfront as I don't think those are a fruitful topic if you wish to discuss my initial "belief."
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> similar ramifications should apply to the uploader in the case of a valid DMCA complaint to make this fair They do. They're the penalties for copyright infringement. DMCA provides a quick takedown mechanism; other copyright law lifts the rest.
- aaronax 7y agoGood point. I guess I've never heard of someone getting penalized for uploading stuff to YouTube for example.
- bawolff 7y agoWouldn't that just be a normal copyright infringement lawsuit?
- ikeboy 7y agoIn theory, you are liable. It's just difficult to actually enforce that because most people won't actually spend a fortune in legal fees hoping they'll win it back down the road.
- kevingadd 7y agoPlatform holders (Google for example) also generally refuse to give you information on the submitter, which means you can't chase them down in court even if you want to.
- ikeboy 7y agoMy understanding is Google will tell you that info as well as publish it to the Lumen database. If not, you can always subpoena Google for the exact info in court, it only adds a step.
- kevingadd 7y agoThis is true (in my experience) for search results but not for the chrome web store. Sure, you could take Google to court if you have more money and time to waste...
- ikeboy 7y agoSearching turns up https://adampash.kinja.com/google-just-dmcaed-my-chrome-extension-1684908823 https://adampash.kinja.com/google-just-dmcaed-my-chrome-exte..., which has the text of an email Google sent out that does include the sender information. You can submit a counter-notice, and if for some reason they didn't give you the required information I'd expect you could contact support and ask for it.
- kevingadd 7y agoYeah, they omitted critical information and rejected my attempts to get the information. They also kept the extension down for a month. I contacted a lawyer about this but the costs would have been extravagant, so. You'll note how in that example, they provide lots of information on the party that filed the DMCA claim. That info is only provided to you if the DMCA notice actually included the info - Google will for some reason process malformed notices that don't contain the required information, which leaves you with no options. In this case the person filing the claim provided no information except their name (4 japanese kanji) with no further contact information or other details. I was unable to find them on Google, if that was even their name.
- craftinator 7y agoAnd if you jail enough people at random, you'll eventually jail a percentage of lawbreakers that reflects the actual percentage of people who break the law in your country.
- cesarb 7y agoAnother problem with the DMCA is that AFAIK, to file a counter notice, you must submit to the jurisdiction of USA courts. For instance, if Bob submits a DMCA takedown notice, and Alice successfully files a DMCA counter-notice, everything is back to how it was before the takedown, except that Alice is now under the jurisdiction of a USA court. That is, either Alice has to accept the takedown, or she has to accept to submit to a foreign country's jurisdiction, even if the original DMCA takedown notice was invalid.
- DanBC 7y agoThis one seems to be a reasonable use of DMCA: this is a logo that shouldn't exist, it's never used, but it's on Wikipedia and people are finding it there and attempting to use it for actual purposes, which is confusing. So BP issues a narrow DMCA for only this incorrect version of the logo, leaving all others untouched. https://foundation.wikimedia.org/wiki/Legal:DMCA_BP_logo https://foundation.wikimedia.org/wiki/Legal:DMCA_BP_logo
- ceph_ 7y agoThey claim that they did not create the incorrect logo and state that it was created by a third party. Doesn't that entirely invalidate their claim to own copyright over it?