6 ms·
> we gotta ban collecting & monetizing user info anything that runs across a network can be monitored, and such data is valuable when you are able to merge it
by ekianjo 7y ago
> we gotta ban collecting & monetizing user info
anything that runs across a network can be monitored, and such data is valuable when you are able to merge it across several data sources. It's very unlikely tracking can even be banned or un-monitized.
- shantly 7y agoMaking it illegal so no legitimate business can do it without incredible risk of being sued/charged out of existence seems quite feasible.
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoYou really don’t think companies would figure out a way around any such “illegality” or just use it anti competitively as is being done throughout the EU with its ham-handed policies?
- shantly 7y agoI find this kind of defeatism entirely baffling. Regulating corporations is hard so we shouldn't try? This is a lot less complicated than many sorts of regulation we attempt. Just give up on all of it, it's pointless? Where's the bottom on this line of thought?
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoYes, it's pointless. There is nothing illegal about what is going on now, and nothing which should be illegal about what is going on. In this context, "regulating" simply means making a behavior we didn't see coming illegal. It's a short-sighted, unimaginative, and blatantly violent way to solve a problem which stems entirely from the consumer public, not from big bad corporations. It will be used by major corps as an anti-competitive weapon against smaller up-start competition - an outcome we should expect from all such attempts at "regulating" the tech oligarchy.
- shantly 7y ago> There is nothing illegal about what is going on now, and nothing which should be illegal about what is going on. In this context, "regulating" simply means making a behavior we didn't see coming illegal. When we don't like they way corporate-driven markets (so... all of them, really) are developing we should attempt to change things until they develop a way we like, where "we" is any interest group. If we're not harnessing the activity of companies to the collective good, why let our democratic states charter them in the first place?
- AndrewUnmuted 7y ago> we should attempt to change things until they develop a way we like, where "we" is any interest group. OK, then my interest group is "respecting contracts and continuing to place the burden on consumers to make informed decisions, and on corporations to not commit fraud." What you present is, frankly, a disgusting way to think, and gives absolutely no volition to or consideration of the rights of the individuals who work in and operate these companies. Their rights are just as valid as yours, and you have no legitimate right to change or invalidate the contractual relationship a company has with its customers. It's also not a "free software" way to think about the problem. FOSS methodology suggests that you present a better alternative, not to use the violence of central authorities to force your way upon everyone else. > democratic states Speak for yourself buddy. I live in a Constitutional Republic, not a democracy.
- shantly 7y agoCompanies are creations of the state. We should do with them what we think most valuable and likely to create the best environment. This may, and probably does, include permitting them a wide variety of liberties and privileges. > > democratic states > Speak for yourself buddy. I live in a Constitutional Republic, not a democracy. FYI the colloquial usage of "democratic" or "democracy" is also the way actual political scientists use it when dealing in generalities of this sort, so splitting this straw is not some I'm-better-educated-on-this-than-you "gotcha", and signals the opposite of what you're intending.
- 7y ago
- DataWorker 7y agoThe same spirit was what kept slavery viable for so long. They said abolishing slavery wasn’t practical. Many had conflicting interests, as do many here.
- na85 7y agoSo are you suggesting there's no way to defeat the tech oligarchy and we should just surrender to them?
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoWe are the ones that enable the tech oligarchy. We are, therefore, surrendering to them right now. My suggestion is to use our brains and not rely on the useless and frivolous "services" these tech oligarchy participants provide. We give them their power.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIf one builds something better, people will use it. The challenge is that it's actually quite hard to build something better. Centralization has huge advantages of common-goal, ability to curtail and exclude antagonistic actors, and decreased barriers to flow of resources. I think the lack of alternatives to Facebook has a lot less to do with "evil" practices Facebook undertakes and a lot more to do with Facebook actually building a good tool that's easy to use for most people. Alternatives haven't hit that level of simplicity.
- JohnFen 7y ago> We are, therefore, surrendering to them right now. Who's "we"? I am not surrendering to them.
- na85 7y agoIsn't that the same "just don't get addicted to nicotine" argument, but updated to the modern era?
- JohnFen 7y agoWorst case, such a ban would be a speed bump. But even just a speed bump would be an improvement over the way things are now.
- ekianjo 7y agoHow do you make illegal monitoring access to services? Because at the core this is what tracking is based on. Even if you trickled tracking down to IP addresses and time of usage only you could still have a very useful database of users across services. Oh and by the way, tracking was not invented by Internet companies, all payment systems and credit cards have been doing tracking for ages before that and selling their data to third parties.
- shantly 7y agoOh yeah, I strongly agree those need to be stopped to. We keep hand wringing over all these leaks and such and "oh gee how to we improve security?", when the clear solution is to not allow it in the first place. That way a leak doesn't become some lame civil matter, but "oh, you had this plainly-illegal-to-collect info? Looks like your business is over" (which would be a rare occurrence, if it were actually that risky to do it, since it'd be hard to keep such collection secret given how many people would be involved and so how many potential whistle blowers there would be, and how large a "paper" trail is necessarily involved in mass-scale data collection, making it extremely easy to investigate and prove)
- spaced-out 7y agoVery few voters will support a bill that will result in them having to pay for things like email, facebook, youtube, etc...
- shantly 7y agoInternet service used to include basic services like email and newsgroups. Still "paid", but effectively bundled, and a tiny part of the total cost.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoThey do so nowadays, too. At least around where i am. Inconvenient when you change ISPs.
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoThis may be true but it doesn’t justify the monetization of user data. If this data is useful to cross reference, let the user opt in and use it. Give the user control and insight into the data collection. The data can be useful without tricking users and making money off their private use activities.
- ekianjo 7y ago> This may be true but it doesn’t justify the monetization of user data. I don't understand your point. If it can technically be done and it is valuable in any way, it WILL be done. No matter the justification.
- saagarjha 7y agoNot if it were illegal.
- ekianjo 7y agoHow can you make monitoring logs illegal? Because that is pretty much enough to start tracking users.
- shantly 7y agoYou don't need to make IP logging illegal to make collecting user info that's not absolutely necessary to a transaction illegal, and to make selling or using any necessarily-collected data for anything other than e.g. auditing or further service to the transaction (returns, say) also illegal. I don't know how this became about Apache logs or whatever. [EDIT] my point is there's a ton of info being collected that goes way beyond web server logging, so I don't know how this became about why all this is impossible because server logs are a thing.
- ekianjo 7y ago> absolutely necessary to a transaction illegal, "absolutely necessary" does not mean anything. For example, tracking in banking systems has very good justifications such as fraud detection. That alone means banks have a blank check to connect tons of features about their users, and not for nefarious purposes. [EDIT] to your EDIT point: even with server logs you could start building user tracking and if your net is large enough you can derive a massive amount of data just from that. Pattern analysis, sites/services users connect to, geolocation, etc... even without the most sophisticated tracking systems this is already good enough to build business value.
- hans1729 7y ago>It's very unlikely tracking can even be banned [...] How so? It's just politics - no more, no less. I don't even consider it highly unlikely that it will, letalone can, be banned, at least in the EU.
- ekianjo 7y agoBecause whatever flows in networks is a fundamental properties of the networks and it's natural for it to be available for anyone/any entity running centralized or decentralized services. Tracking is a natural consequence of operating networks.
- shantly 7y agoWhat Facebook and Google and Twitter and Amazon and American Express and so on collect and do with their data is not remotely necessary to operating their services and businesses, except to the extent that they make money by spying on people per se.