3 ms·
> Malcolm Gladwell also cherry picks research findings and observations and uses them to support some narrative I'm mixed about this. I feel like this critic i
by baby 7y ago
> Malcolm Gladwell also cherry picks research findings and observations and uses them to support some narrative
I'm mixed about this. I feel like this critic is true for any book. Books are not research papers.
- maxerickson 7y agoWhen a book is presented as a popularization of science, it's reasonable to expect that it is evenhanded with the evidence that is available when it is written. Gladwell would probably end up making his books stand up better to criticism without making them any less interesting. It's fun to read about how much practice talented people have done. The problem is when you distill that down to a soundbite that sounds like a conclusion.
- tonystubblebine 7y agoI watched his Master Class and at no point does he even mention getting it right as a goal. His writing tips are only about making it interesting, memorable and shareable. IMO, he's breaking the Spiderman rule of morality, "With great power comes great responsibility." He's putting out intellectual versions of fraudulent ear worms without any sense of responsibility.