6 ms·
Immortal Game
- letientai299 7y agoIt was an interesting read. But ... why is it on HN home page with just 3 points within 45m?
- Reventlov 7y agoBecause Americans are sleeping.
- eru 7y agoCompare (one of the best) chess games that isn't even a chess game: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/e2n3df/kramnik_proposes_a_variant_nocastling_chess/ https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/e2n3df/kramnik_propo...
- default-kramer 7y agoWhat is interesting is in the comments on chess.com, people propose "NBC [no black castling] Armageddon" meaning black is not allowed to castle but wins with a draw. And it seems balanced! I'd really like to see some top humans try it out.
- MAXPOOL 7y agoIt would be interesting to see AlphaZero trained to play very aggressive romantic style. AlphaImmortal's goal should be beating Magnus Carlsen 51% of the time with the most amazing games ever played. I think you could do this by changing the value function: - reward short game over long games, - draw reward closer to loss reward, - reward capture more. In fact, I would like to play against AlphaImmortal specially trained to play against my Elo-rating level opponents with 51% win rate. That would be fun!
- Someone 7y ago"AlphaZero trained to play very aggressive romantic style. […] I think you could do this by changing the value function” The essential thing with AlphaZero is that it doesn’t have a value function that you can change. It learns it from the games it plays against itself. The best you could do is train it by playing against some algorithm that plays aggressive romantic style (playing against humans playing aggressive romantic style would work, too, but that would make for slow training) I doubt that would produce an AlphaZero that itself plays aggressive romantic style, though. Edit: one thing that _might_ work is to, during training, change the rules of chess to “both players lose if the game lasts over N moves” for some small N (40?). That should put incentives on aggressive play. Disadvantage would be that AlphaZero would learn very little about endgames.
- MAXPOOL 7y agoYou can make AlphaZero learn different value function by changing the reward from the game. Game with no reward from draw, more reward from shorter games with more captures creates different value functions.
- V-2 7y agoOr by training it against a flawed version of the algorithm that tends to overlook best defence like a human would. This was what made the romantic style possible in the first place: humans perform worse under pressure, so they tend to crack once they're put on the ropes. It's psychologically easier to attack than to defend accurately
- Someone 7y agoI don’t think that would work. A weird attacking style only works if your attacking moves that technically are losing ones lead to situations so complex that your opponent are unlikely to find the moves that win it for them. AlphaZero would not have trouble finding the (likely fairly dull) winning moves, and certainly wouldn’t see any reason to play such a move itself.
- pickdenis 7y ago
- V-2 7y agoAs a matter of fact, AlphaZero already plays more aggressively than typically expected of chess engines. Eg. in a well-known game it beated Stockfish (the strongest traditional chess engine), brilliantly sacrificing 3 pawns for a non-obvious, human-like compensation. This once again challenged the notion of what the perfect play boils down to in chess. Oversimplifying a bit, it had already been assumed that it's solely about grinding the opponent down by mercilessly accumulating miniscule advantages, while all the flashiness only worked because human players are error-prone. As it turns out, it may have been just another limitation of chess engines as we knew (and built) them.
- lonelappde 7y agoYou mean "reward capture less", to emphasize positional place and sacrifices.
- nabla9 7y agoAlphaZero against my level player using some wacky reward like sacrificing maximum amount of pawns over winning every time could wind me up like a God in bath salts.
- rictic 7y agoOnly somewhat related, but if you found these ideas amusing, you'd probably enjoy watching tom7's video on unusual chess engine strategies: https://youtu.be/DpXy041BIlA https://youtu.be/DpXy041BIlA
- freepor 7y agoAs a non-player who knows the rules these would be fun to watch. When I watch world championship matches I don’t really understand why what’s happening is happening. It would be cool to see games that are over optimized for the daring sacrifices that seem like blunders even to total novices but then end up being devious traps.
- Glosster 7y agoWho else thinks that Chess is too simple and too boring compared to other strategy games that we have now? Starcraft 2, Agricola, Twilight Struggle, Through The Ages, etc.
- zeitg3ist 7y agoAll these games include some sort of random component and thus cannot be compared to chess which is purely skill based.
- Retric 7y agoStarcraft is deterministic, the only random element is how people click. Slow the game to 1/10,000th current speed and it’s turn based.
- jmgao 7y agoStarcraft is not deterministic, and the nondeterminism can matter in significant ways. In Starcraft 1, every ranged attack had a 120/256 chance of missing a unit that was up a hill or behind a tree, and a 1/256 chance of missing always. In Starcraft 2, attack cooldowns are slightly randomized, so two units that are commanded to attack each other will almost never kill each other simultaneously.
- Retric 7y agoStarcraft 2 replays work by replaying player actions not game state, they don’t need to record a random number generator’s output just a shared seed. Now, you can argue the prng is effectively a random number generator, but that’s more semantics than reality. Further, RTS games use a shared seed to minimize network traffic. So, this is an important design choice. However, as I said the player’s actions prevent individual players from exploiting the prng as they both interact with it.
- BoiledCabbage 7y ago
- Fabled 7y agoCoincidentally I was watching reviews of some games from AlphaZero vs. Stockfish 9 and people were amazed at the "human-like" nature of some of AlphaZero's decisions. It was seemingly sacrificing material with no obvious gain, only to come back much later in the game with a stronger strategic position. While Stockfish evaluates all possible moves it is limited by computation time and can't see too far into the future. AlphaZero responded much faster because it has already precomputed the expected probability of winning for most branches, so it can seemingly blunder when in fact it is following the path that led to victory most often.
- mik09 7y agokinda reminds me of josh waitskin
- 8bitsrule 7y agoA seven-minute summary of the game, and some history too! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaKWUiiEHgA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaKWUiiEHgA
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]