4 ms·
Amazon got a tax refund of $129 million this past year from the feds alone. How many shelters could be operated for a year with that kind of budget?
by int_19h 7y ago
Amazon got a tax refund of $129 million this past year from the feds alone.
How many shelters could be operated for a year with that kind of budget?
- ars 7y agoA tax refund just means they overpaid estimated taxes. It's not "found money".
- c3534l 7y agoYou're confusing "tax refund" with "tax rebate." Also, Amazon had carryforward losses, so they paid too much in taxes in prior years and therefor didn't have to pay taxes this year. Not exactly nefarious, carryforward losses are an intentional part of the tax code that prevents companies from paying more in supposed earnings they have on paper that can never be realized as profit because taxes are based on estimates. Every business, not just Amazon, get carryforward losses when they overpay in taxes. Edit: I suppose it's equivalent to say it prevents them from overpaying in taxes in the future. That might be easier to understand if you consider that in any given year, a company pays zero in taxes if they don't make money, regardless of how much money they lose. That timing difference means that the tax burden changes from year to year as investments in a company are realized through buying and selling goods. It's a smoothing out of taxes. Instead of forcing Amazon to structure it's business to always make the same profit each year, they get to smooth it out over a maximum of a 10 year rolling window. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_operating_loss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_operating_loss
- clairity 7y agothat's a vigorous defense of time-shifting gains and losses for businesses. now how about individual taxpayers?
- int_19h 7y agoYes, you're right, and I got the word wrong - it is a tax rebate. The point remains that Amazon paid $0 in taxes past year, and actually received money from the federal government instead. And no, it's not just because of carryforward losses. It was also because of the various tax credits, and changes to tax laws in 2017.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>How many shelters could be operated for a year with that kind of budget? Where? Determine where and then determine - rent/purchase price of a property. - cost of utilities - cost of maintenance and cleaning - cost of security and other staff - adequate liability insurance - cost of any programs/services to help the people using the shelter to get back on their feat (if they even want to) - cost of therapists/psychiatrists/psychologists/medical doctors to visit and provide services It looks like 'supportive housing' cost $12,800 [1] per head per year and I don't believe that factors in food/supplies/medical etc. So realistically, they could probably provide 12-18 months of housing/food/bare bottom basic medical care/a few sessions of therapy/a few outfits/interview training to 5000-7500 people for 129 million dollars. [1] https://endhomelessness.org/resource/ending-chronic-homelessness-saves-taxpayers-money-2/ https://endhomelessness.org/resource/ending-chronic-homeless...