7 ms·
Separated bike lanes means you cant move out of the way quickly when there are slow newbie bikers (Ive had two accidents because of bikers like this who swerve
by dmix 7y ago
Separated bike lanes means you cant move out of the way quickly when there are slow newbie bikers (Ive had two accidents because of bikers like this who swerve unpredictably as a natural course of biking), pedestrians crossing over them, or garbage, or w/e in the way. I avoid them at any point where high speed is possible and Ive never seen a car complain because I know how to ride with traffic without slowing them down.
In my view separated bike lanes are for casuals, not serious commuters. I'd much prefer sharrows and marked mixed lanes personally. Just visual reminders to drivers to share the road is designate our area is sufficient IMO.
- Symbiote 7y agoYou are perhaps cycling more for sport than transport. Cycling infrastructure needs to be usable for the majority of people (age 6 to 86, fit, fat, bicycle, tricycle etc). Segregated lanes in Denmark and the Netherlands work fine. Those using a bicycle for energetic exercise will choose quiet places and times, just like car drivers who want to drive fast can't use city streets.
- dmix 7y agoNo I commuted for years, I live close enough to walk to work now so I’m less invested in this debate these days. But I just think the marked lanes and sharrows are a good enough compromise for the serious commuters and the casuals. I’m not an expert nor closer to the mean of the typical rider (I build my own bikes, ride fast but safe, like a bike messenger without the suicide wish) so I try not to get all holy about this. I should also note I find Toronto’s more plentiful marked lanes to be pretty good but I avoid the separated one on Adelaide. it’s much improved over past years.
- tga_d 7y ago>But I just think the marked lanes and sharrows are a good enough compromise for the serious commuters and the casuals. There have been several studies that show sharrows don't actually help, and in some cases even hinder, bike safety. E.g., https://trid.trb.org/view/1393928 https://trid.trb.org/view/1393928 https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/40917 https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/40917 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2046043018300583 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S204604301...
- richk449 7y agoWhat are sharrows for? I already have the right to the road without the sharrows. As far as I can tell, their only purpose is to let cities pretend that they have done something for bikers, while actually doing nothing. perhaps less than nothing - if a sharrows implies anything, then the absence of a sharrows must imply the opposite, right? And there are a lot more streets without sharrows than with.
- mumblemumble 7y agoI'm pretty sure sharrows are for indicating to motorists that they should give you 20cm of margin when passing instead of the meter or so that would be customary on a street without them.
- dmix 7y agoLike I said I’m not heavily invested in this argument but separated lanes aren’t a panacea and are probably the best compromise for the average rider. It’s just something me and a lot of people I know would avoid for safety and further push us into traffic while confused cars think we’re the dumb ones. I’ve never been on a separated bike lane without it being jammed up and cluttered with people who don’t know what they are doing, unless it’s dead out I’m not using them or would avoid the street entirely. I miss Montreal which built bike highways in neighborhoods adjacent to busy one way streets (another good idea). Riding there was always a joy. SF scared the shit out of me but mostly because the city is disgustingly dirty and the roads are weird.
- Cougher 7y ago'Speed differential' is a thing for any sort of traffic, be it cars, bicycles, and runners. 'Experience differential' is also a thing. It may be that one of the problems that you've experienced is due to the fact that you yourself "don't know what [you're] doing" and are riding far too aggressively amongst people who are learning or riding "casually" . . . as they have every right to.
- 7y ago
- rsynnott 7y agoSerious commuters and ‘casuals’ is a fascinating concept. “How do you commute to work?” “Oh, I get there on a train, but I wouldn’t consider it a _commute_; I don’t take it very seriously” I mean, what?
- crooked-v 7y agoBike lanes in the middle of a city are generally going to be interrupted by intersections every block or every few blocks anyway, so there's no reason to optimize for speed at the expense of the 'casuals' who make up most of the population.
- DangerousPie 7y agoThis may be different in the US but all the separated bike lanes I have encountered in Europe are wide enough to pass other cyclists. There are also much fewer "slow newbie" bikers swerving around unpredictably than you seem to suggest. Yes, sometimes you may need to slow down a bit because someone is already overtaking or the lane is too narrow but I will take that over having to share the road with cars any day of the week. And FWIW I've been commuting by bike for about 20 years so I wouldn't consider myself a "casual".
- dmix 7y agoToronto doesn’t have that many separated and the ones I’ve been on have scared me more than riding on a street without any marking. I guess experiences my vary.
- bkor 7y agoThat's a complete opposite of how it is in The Netherlands. I don't think it's the experience though, it highly likely it's the implementation. In any other country they often completely mess up all of the bike infrastructure, including separated bike lanes only in name (loads of steps not done). E.g. the width of the bike lane should be based on the amount of bikes they've estimated to ride on there. Bike traffic here is measured often. If needed the bike lane is expanded. Then height differences, consistent colouring, marking, etc. It should be obvious without thinking, something that's often not the case.
- eli 7y agoAround me in DC in roads with congested bike lanes the “serious” commuters tend to just ride with traffic. I think this works ok? The bike lane on 15th actually has two parallel lanes and you can overtake slower riders when there’s no oncoming traffic. (Also I challenge the idea that relatively slow cyclists who nonetheless bike to work every day are somehow less serious)
- Symbiote 7y agoPerhaps 1 in 500 cyclists in Copenhagen will use the road, even when it's congested. Even then, they usually do it only at the junctions, to get to the front or make an illegal turn on red. Part of this will be cultural, Danes are relaxed and good at following rules, but it's also because it's less stressful just to wait until the next change of the lights, or go 20% slower and not have to pay attention to the cars.