4 ms·
> The bike lanes are all on noisy, busy streets that aren't pleasant to ride on Usually they get put there because of it; a quiet residential street doesn't n
by bobthepanda 7y ago
> The bike lanes are all on noisy, busy streets that aren't pleasant to ride on
Usually they get put there because of it; a quiet residential street doesn't need nearly as much intervention to be good for cycling, so they don't really bother with it.
The other thing is that, particularly in non-gridded cities, the roads are noisy and busy because they are often the most direct, flat route from A to B.
Finally, these thoroughfares are usually the safest places to cross other, similar thoroughfares. Less busy roads will have lower priorities at crossings, which can mean no traffic lights giving you guaranteed passage to cross, or even physical blockers in the median preventing you from crossing as well.
- gumby 7y agoI don’t know: Palo Alto has “bike boulevards” which are residential streets but - have nonstop signs (all stop signs are on the cross streets) and dead ends (for cars, not bikes or pedestrians) every few blocks. Really makes them worth taking.
- gibolt 7y agoI use these all the time and wish more cities would do it. One downside is that the cross streets usually have cars just rolling through the stop signs with no attention paid to the possiblity of an oncoming cyclist. Maybe adding a bike indicator on all the stop signs would be a partial solution. Parking a bike anywhere still sucks, even in a city that provides such well labeled lanes.
- ianai 7y ago“Maybe adding a bike indicator on all the stop signs would be a partial solution.” Doubtful. Motorists tend to be strongly apathetic to anyone but themselves. Probably a red light that’s capable of spotting a cyclist and timing a crossing would be a blue sky solution.
- bkor 7y ago> Usually they get put there because of it; a quiet residential street doesn't need nearly as much intervention to be good for cycling, so they don't really bother with it. In my view (I'm Dutch), every road and intersection needs to be built with pedestrians and cyclists in mind. You might even consider another mode, as electric bikes and similar can be quite a bit quicker than bikes, but slower than cars. Alternatively, let's say everything is built for pedestrians and cyclists. Then cars just have to "make do" and only in busy roads you make it safe for everyone. That's considered crazy but exactly the case in many countries for both pedestrians and cyclists. Easy example: try walking a few blocks in various cities. How long do you have to wait for traffic lights? Now try the same in The Netherlands. The wait in other countries is often insane (1-2 minutes).
- maxerickson 7y agoThe Netherlands has done a great job investing in infrastructure, but it's not really a typical place. Even when you include all the land set aside for farming and nature, the population density is very high. The region here is about the same physical size and has ~300,000 people. Dedicated infrastructure is often helpful, but there's not the resources or justification to build it everywhere.
- mumblemumble 7y agoAs density goes up, the need for specific infrastructure goes up, but you don't have to get as intense about it as the Netherlands does to create an environment that's safe and pleasant for cyclists and pedestrians. Montréal, for example, is about as dense as any other large North American city (which is to say, not very), but still does a great job without, from what I can tell, any serious expenditure of resources on physical infrastructure. There are a few physically separated bike lanes, but mostly the city just focuses on calming down the traffic: More one-way streets, left turns permitted at fewer intersections, and a ban on turning right at a red light go a long way toward making the city's streets more pleasant for everyone. I even find it's more pleasant to drive there than it is in my city.