5 ms·
I'm glad this was posted here because I never would have heard about it otherwise, until one of my sites' monthly downloads would have broken. But I still can'
by crazygringo 7y ago
I'm glad this was posted here because I never would have heard about it otherwise, until one of my sites' monthly downloads would have broken.
But I still can't quite figure out if anything's changing technically except a new file location that requires an account to access, and new license terms -- or is there something else?
If someone requests a "do not sell" for their IP address that is in the middle of a range... is the range being split in 2, and skipping that address? Or are the ranges staying the same, and is there a separate "blacklist" of some kind that says, if the IP is any of these individual addresses, it's against the law to geolocate? And is that blacklist in the same file, or something to do with "we will... communicate all valid “Do Not Sell” requests to you as we receive them"?
Wish this post were both clearer, and that it had been announced at least a couple of months in advance, rather than less than 2 weeks before taking effect today. (Still, I can't complain too much -- it's free so I'm just glad the public databases exists at all.)
- tyingq 7y ago"... is the range being split in 2, and skipping that address?" That would be funny, as it will create, by omission, a defacto database of "IP addresses of privacy nuts". Which might have commercial/advertising value.
- mirimir 7y agoOK, privacy nut here :) I go to great lengths to avoid being associated with the IP address assigned by my ISP. But I'd never request that it be removed from the dataset. It would obviously be stupid to do it as Mirimir (for example). But less obviously, it would also be stupid to do it as my meatspace identity. Because that would flag it as a privacy nut. Which I'm very careful to avoid doing. So I wonder what people think that it's smart to have their IP addresses delisted.
- 2shortplanks 7y agoWe apologize for not providing more notice. The CCPA was finalized in October, and it contains a number of ambiguities, particularly as it relates to our products. To arrive at our current interpretation, it has taken many weeks of working with privacy lawyers, following discussions in the privacy community, and observing actions other companies have taken. We're sorry for the timing, appreciating the frustration it causes, and wish we could have provided more notice. MaxMind will provide immediate notification of Do Not Sell requests via the https://www.maxmind.com/en/accounts/current/do-not-sell-requests https://www.maxmind.com/en/accounts/current/do-not-sell-requ... page on our website (login required). Future builds of the database will exclude those IP addresses by introducing the "split ranges" you describe. Hope that helps. Mark Fowler MaxMind
- gav 7y agoGiven that for home users, IP address assignment is temporary, is there a plan to add them back after some time has elapsed?
- maxmindjason 7y agoYes. We will add them back if we are confident they've been reallocated. Jason Ketola MaxMind
- crazygringo 7y agoThanks for the clarity and explanation -- totally appreciate that this was a challenge to figure out legally. And thanks also for keeping the database itself up!
- kyledrake 7y agoMark, what's the best way to programmatically download the files? I created an account, but I need something I can do easily with cURL. edit: This is it: https://download.maxmind.com/app/geoip_download?edition_id=GeoLite2-City&license_key=YOUR_LICENSE_KEY_GOES_HERE&suffix=tar.gz https://download.maxmind.com/app/geoip_download?edition_id=G... Use a license key generated in "my license key" section. Use quotes if in shell.
- yardstick 7y agoWill it be possible for malicious users to inflate the size of the database dramatically by submitting thousands/millions of Do Not Sell IPs? Also, what’s the procedure a user needs to go through before adding an IP to the Do Not Sell list? How do you determine the users authority to make a change? I didn’t see any info on the notice itself. Hopefully you require the user to show extended “ownership” of the IP over the course of a month or more, lest users on dynamic IPs and temporary AWS/GCP/etc IPs are submitted for removal.
- maxmindjason 7y agoThe procedure is indicated in our privacy policy: https://www.maxmind.com/en/privacy-policy https://www.maxmind.com/en/privacy-policy. We do have a vetting process in place. Jason Ketola MaxMind