3 ms·
Ask HN: What's up with all the 4chan love?
It seems everyone is supporting Anonymous over there: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2189907. Let's get some facts straight about those guys:
1. They DDoSed PayPal, Swiss bank PostFinance, etc. Probably caused millions of dollars in damage.[1]
2. They illegaly hacked into a company's servers, stole and published confidential data.[2]
3. They are part of a community that mostly hosts child porn, pirated material, etc.[3]
I challenge anyone to give me a single reason (apart from the technical prowess) that would justify any sort of admiration... Seriously.
[1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/12/4chan-rushes-to-wikileaks-defense-forces-swiss-banking-site-offline.ars
[2] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/02/anonymous-to-security-firm-working-with-fbi-youve-angered-the-hive.ars
[3] http://boards.4chan.org/b/
- throwaway2134 16y agoI'm no 4chan expert, but I've been there (hasn't everyone?) and I've never done anything with anonymous so I'm not really fully aware of their community or what it entails, but I think I know enough to say what I'm going to say, if that makes sense! I take issue with the use of the word mostly in #3. In fact, I'd remove #3 entirely as it isn't really accurate at all. I've been to 4chan 100s of times, and never once seen child porn or pirated material. I'm absolutely sure that it goes on, and that its even happening right now, but without a doubt, it is not most of the content on /b/ Second, 4chan isn't anonymous and anonymous isn't 4chan. Anonymous isn't even a group, it doesn't have leaders, goals, consensus, or anything else as far as I know. Anonymous is a very loose term and is taken on by diverse groups of people, and individuals too, with rare ties to each other. Because they're not really a group or an organization its really hard to love or hate them, so I think a lot of times, the actions of "anonymous" get judged on that particular story/event without taking into context a past or a future. This, I believe, is why you're not seeing more people talking about what they have done, there really isn't a "they" and the people responsible for one thing may not even be related to another. Its partly their refusal to be identified and grouped that gives them freedom to do whatever they want, whether others think its good or bad. A lot of the things they do are pretty illegal, but in my view personally not really very immoral. The love for anonymous right now comes from them making a fool of a company that in my opinion deserved it, by flexing the power of the individual in the face of what many would consider to be an over-reaching state organization, and by showing the world these things in a fun and light hearted way. What "they" have done in the past, for me, doesn't really exist, because I don't know "them" to be the same people that DDOS'ed paypal/swissbank/etc. (who also deserved what they got IMO even though it wasn't legal)
- noodle 16y agomaking absolutely no judgment calls on any of the situations, there are definitely a few cases of hasty generalization fallacy in the OP.